Overweight But Healthy?

hero image
01 Jul 2013

weight scale

“Can people be overweight but still be healthy?”  This question has been the subject of an intense debate by obesity researchers in the last few years.   Is the number on the scale the only thing that counts or should we take other factors into consideration?  What are the latest findings on “fatness versus fitness” when it comes to determining the overall health  of an overweight individual?

A small but vocal group of researchers have been challenging conventional wisdom. They argue that not only is it possible to be both fat and fit, but fitness is actually a more significant measure of health than body weight.  The first major fatness versus fitness study was conducted by researchers at the Cooper Institute, a nonprofit fitness organization in Dallas. In a study of 22,000 men ages 30–83, the researchers measured subjects’ body composition (the proportion of fat to muscle) and put them through treadmill tests.   They concluded that if you are fit, being overweight doesn’t increase mortality risk.

Dr. Steven N. Blair, who headed the Cooper Institute at that time, and has now continued his research at the University of South Carolina, defends the role of fitness as a major determinant of health regardless of one’s weight.  “We’ve studied this from many perspectives in women and in men and we get the same answer: It’s not the obesity—it’s the fitness,” Blair said. “Fitness can substantially reduce, if not eliminate, the high risk of being obese.” (Please note that Dr. Blair himself exercises every day but is overweight)

Blair’s most famous study was called the Aerobics Center Longitudinal Study (ACLS) and the findings were astounding.  It showed that obese men who were moderately/highly fit had less than half the risk of dying than the normal-weight men who were unfit.  In plain English, an obese man who was fit cut his risk of dying of any cause at any time by half!

Results of studies done by Mary Fran Sowers and Judith Wylie, obesity researchers at the University of Michigan, showed that thin, unfit people can develop heart-related problems that fat but fit people often do not.  Kelly Brownell, Director of the Yale Center for Eating and Weight Disorders, concluded in a 2003 study that heavy people that are fit have a lower risk of heart disease than thin people who are unfit.

However, others are concerned that sending this message will be misunderstood, giving overweight and obese individuals the message that weight doesn’t matter; and these finding offer the perfect excuse to accept those extra pounds as unimportant and not to worry about dieting as long as you’re exercising.   “Being overweight has a clear association with important health problems, and even modest weight loss has important health benefits,” said Walter Willett, an expert on nutrition and health at the Harvard School of Public Health. “To tell people it doesn’t matter is really misleading. It does make a difference. It makes a huge difference.”

The Nurses’ Health Study, which since 1976, has been looking at the lifestyle habits and mortality rates of approximately 238,000 nurses, found that being a little active and a little fat wasn’t such a bad combination.  But physical activity didn’t completely eliminate the risks that were associated with being overweight or obese. In fact, when the nurses were grouped by how active they were, the heavier nurses had a higher rate of mortality than the lighter ones at every activity level.

Despite the differences in these studies, they all suggest that physical activity will offset some of the effects of excess weight, if it’s just a few extra pounds. No one is debating that there is a marked difference in disease rates in the obese vs. the overweight.  When assessing overall health risk, we need to look at many factors, not just the number on the scale.

Those of you who read my columns already know that the way to weight loss is NOT to go on a diet (you will just go on the diet and then go off the diet).  Diet’s focus on the deprivation side of the equation and the willpower will eventually run out. Learn good eating habits—how to eat less and at the same time enjoy your food more. Most of all learn to eat less and at the same time enjoy your food more.   And moderate intensity exercise can do you a lot of good.  One doesn’t have to spend hours in the gym and run for miles and miles in order to reap the benefits.  Walk briskly daily for 35 minutes and do some muscle building twice a week and you will see tremendous improvement in your health both from the point of view of your vital measurements (blood tests, blood pressure and resting pulse) and from the way you feel. You will be more functional in your daily tasks and feel better emotionally.

Exercise is important and weight loss is important.  We need both.  But remember that if you are one of the many who have a hard time losing all of your weight, whatever you lose is beneficial and if you do indeed emphasize exercise as the key to your health that may just be the most important thing you do for your health and longevity.

Weight loss is a must! Exercise is a must! And together they will “add hours to your day, days to your year, and years to your life.”  



Alan Freishtat is an A.C.E. CERTIFIED PERSONAL TRAINER and a BEHAVIORAL CHANGE and WELLNESS COACH with over 19 years of professional experience. Alan is the creator and director of the “10 Weeks to Health” program for weight loss. He is available for private coaching sessions, consultations, assessments and personalized workout programs both in his office and by telephone and skype. Alan also lectures and gives seminars and workshops. He can be reached at 02-651-8502 or 050-555-7175, or by email at alan@alanfitness.com Check out the his web site –www.alanfitness.com US Line: 516-568-5027.


The words of this author reflect his/her own opinions and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Orthodox Union.