Beyond Good Intentions: Supporting Couples Experiencing Infertility

Nov 18, 2026

How thoughtful words, sensitivity, and compassion can make a difficult journey feel less isolating

Renowned Torah educator and lecturer Michal Horowitz still remembers the sting of a friend’s offhand remark. The comment came as Horowitz and her husband, Moshe, were preparing to host a barbecue.

“Our eldest child was about three or four years old,” recalls the Woodmere, New York-based author of Abled: Living With a Disability, a Torah View. “I asked my friend how many burgers and hot dogs her family would eat so I could plan accordingly. She replied, ‘Oh, you still count because you only have one kid. I don’t count anymore.’”

That was over 25 years ago.

Although Horowitz has long forgiven her friend, she still remembers how deeply the comment hurt at the time. What the woman didn’t know was that her remark had touched on a deeply painful struggle: Horowitz and her husband, Moshe, were quietly contending with secondary infertility, the difficulty of conceiving after already having a child.

“Our son was born just over 14 months after we got married,” she says. “When we struggled to conceive again, infertility seemed to come out of nowhere, thrusting us into an unfamiliar world, as I imagine it does for many couples facing this difficult nisayon. Although our circumstances were different from those experiencing primary infertility, many challenges were similar. We underwent numerous procedures and faced the physical, emotional, and financial burdens, and the longing, waiting, and uncertainty that accompany infertility.”

The Horowitzs eventually welcomed their second child, six years after their first, followed by twins two and a half years later. Yet Michal has never forgotten the challenges of infertility or the pain experienced by those still yearning to build a family. When presenting shiurim, she is careful never to assume that everyone in her audience has children. 

According to the World Health Organization, approximately one in six adults worldwide experiences infertility in their lifetime. Within the Jewish community, numerous organizations provide medical, financial, and emotional support to couples facing these challenges. Yet beyond these invaluable resources, couples experiencing infertility also need compassion, understanding, and sensitivity from those around them.

Dr. Shoshana Karasick is a New York–based clinical psychologist specializing in infertility, pregnancy loss, and perinatal mental health. She leads monthly support groups and is a frequent speaker for ATIME, an organization dedicated to supporting Jewish couples and families navigating infertility and other reproductive health challenges. Grounded in privacy, dignity, and halacha, ATIME provides emotional support, educational resources, medical referrals, and practical assistance through a global network of medical specialists, rabbanim, clinics, support groups, and volunteers.

As in Horowitz’s case, Dr. Karasick says even well-intentioned comments can unintentionally minimize the medical and emotional complexity of a couple’s infertility journey and cause tremendous pain.

“Women in my support groups have shared the painful questions they’ve been asked, such as, How many children do you have? How old is your oldest? or What schools do you send your kids to? Since we never know what others may be going through, it’s important to avoid assumptions and approach every interaction with thoughtfulness, sensitivity, and kindness.”

Horowitz also cautions against offering guarantees or unsolicited advice to a couple experiencing infertility.

“You should not tell someone that their yeshua will surely come next year, or suggest they try a specific segula,” she says. “Similarly, you should not say, ‘I understand what you’re going through.’ Even those who have experienced infertility themselves may not fully understand another couple’s journey. And you should not tell a couple experiencing secondary infertility, ‘At least you have one child. Don’t complain.’”

Dr. Aimee Baron is the founder and executive director of I Was Supposed To Have A Baby (IWSTHAB), a nonprofit dedicated to transforming how the Jewish community supports individuals and families navigating fertility challenges and loss. The organization provides emotional support, educational resources, and meaningful connections for those experiencing infertility, miscarriage, stillbirth, termination for medical reasons (TFMR), and other family-building journeys, including donor conception, adoption, and surrogacy.

Dr. Baron has seen firsthand how painful Shabbat and Jewish holidays can be for those struggling to build a family.

“Shabbat can be especially challenging, with conversations often centered on babies, pregnancies, and family life,” notes Dr. Baron, a pediatrician, speaker, and host of IWSTHAB’s Talking Away the Taboo, a podcast addressing infertility and pregnancy loss within the Jewish community. “Holidays can also be painful reminders of hopes that have yet to be realized. Someone may have thought, ‘Surely by this time next year, I’ll have a baby in my arms.’”

From Chanukah presents and Purim costumes to the Pesach Seder, the emphasis on children during Jewish holidays can deepen the isolation experienced by those struggling with infertility.

“It’s important to create opportunities for connection that aren’t focused exclusively on children, such as adult-only gatherings or meals where conversations extend beyond family life,” Dr. Baron says.

Celebrations such as a brit and simchat bat can be equally difficult.

“Those smachot can be extremely painful for couples struggling with infertility,” says Horowitz. “There is no real way to ease the pain entirely, but it’s important not to make a couple feel like a “nebach” case. You shouldn’t apologize for making a simcha or beat around the bush, and you should not let them hear the news from someone else. At the same time, you shouldn’t gush to them about your overwhelming joy at having been blessed with this incredible gift. Relay the news in a mature, direct, and respectful fashion. Then give the couple time and space to absorb it, without infringing on their privacy.”

She adds that, while well-meaning, comments like “Im yirtzeh Hashem, by you” at baby-related celebrations can be particularly hurtful.

Sensitivity, however, extends beyond avoiding hurtful comments. Family and friends can also find meaningful ways to reach out and help.

Dr. Karasick emphasizes that while meaningful support looks different for everyone, the key is to be attuned to a couple’s needs and preferences and follow their lead.

“Generally, support means staying connected and present, keeping the lines of communication open, and being willing to listen while respecting people’s privacy,” she notes. “It might mean sending an occasional text or card, continuing to include them in your life, or acknowledging a medical procedure with a small gesture, such as leaving homemade muffins at their door. What matters isn’t the magnitude of the effort, but the message it conveys: I care about you, I’m here for you, and you’re not alone.”

Rabbis, rebbetzins, and other community leaders can help foster an environment where couples experiencing infertility feel valued, understood, and included.

“Rabbis and rebbetzins are encouraged to educate themselves about the many resources and organizations available to couples struggling with infertility,” Dr. Karasick says. “That way, if approached for help, they can connect them with appropriate support. Beyond providing referrals, sometimes the most valuable resource is the genuine, caring relationship that a rabbi or rebbetzin develops with a couple who is struggling.”

Dr. Baron notes that communities can foster greater awareness by including information about infertility resources in the shul bulletin or having the rabbi acknowledge the challenges of infertility from the bimah.

“Sefer Bereishit, with its many stories of infertility, provides natural opportunities to address the issue in a drasha. Additionally, small changes in language can make people feel much more welcome and included. For example, a morning walk advertised for mothers could instead be open to all women, while a musical ‘family davening’ could simply be called a ‘musical davening.’”

Equally important, she says, is offering practical, confidential assistance.

“Some shuls have dedicated email addresses where people can confidentially request meals, help with childcare, or accompaniment to medical appointments. Designated volunteers provide assistance without knowing the beneficiaries, allowing people to get the help they need while maintaining their privacy.”

The need for compassion and understanding doesn’t diminish over time, particularly when the journey to parenthood is long and unpredictable.

“We need to remember that grief and infertility don’t follow a timetable, and people continue to need our support,” Dr. Baron says. “There are no guarantees when or even whether someone will ultimately have a baby.”

And though we may wish to offer words of comfort that alleviate another person’s pain, even the best intentions can miss the mark. Dr. Baron points to the story of Chana and her husband, Elkanah, who sought to comfort her with the words, “Am I not better to you than ten sons?” Despite his love and concern, his words could not ease her anguish.

Perhaps the most meaningful thing we can offer those navigating infertility is not an answer or an explanation, but the reassurance that they are seen, valued, and never alone.