The Dutch Health Ministry says that it is cracking down on Jews who perform circumcisions without a medical degree. Two of the country’s most popular mohels were the target of a probe by the ministry.
“It is not correct that anyone may perform circumcision because circumcision is a religious freedom or because they are proficient in it,” a spokesperson said. “Of course, we will hold to account the people who break the law.”
Jaap Sijmons, a lecturer on medical law, said that the law prohibits any operation, including circumcision, by anyone not registered as a medical professional. However, this appears to be an interpretation since the law does not explicitly forbid such practices. Rather, it lists some non-medical professionals who are allowed to perform invasive treatments; mohels are not on the list.
In the Netherlands, the Health Ministry may issue directives forbidding certain practices but such directives may be challenged in court, where a judge will ultimately interpret the law.
The Royal Dutch Medical Association called to ban non-medical circumcision in 2010, on the basis that it introduced unnecessary risks and violated the rights of underage patients.
Read more on JTA
Like this article?
Sign up for our Shabbat Shalom e-newsletter, a weekly roundup of inspirational thoughts, insight into current events, divrei torah, relationship advice, recipes and so much more!