Shabbat Parshat TO-L'DOT
TT #595 - November 28-29, '03, 4 Kislev
5764
This Shabbat is the 64th day (of 355); the
10th (of 51) Shabbat of 5764
GUR B'AARETZ HAZOT V'E'HEYA IMCHA V'AV'ARACHEKA...
Halachic Times for Jerusalem
Israel Standard (Winter) Time
Correct for TT #595 • Ranges are for THU-THU, 2-9 Kislev - November
27-December 4
Candle lighting - 4:00pm
Havdala - 5:15pm (Rabbeinu Tam - 5:51pm)
Earliest Shacharit 5:24-5:29am
Sunrise - 6:17-6:23am
Sof Z'man Kri'at Sh'ma - 8:51-8:56am (8:04-8:08am)
Sof Z'man Shacharit - 9:43-9:47am (9:12-9:15am)
Chatzot (halachic noon) - 11:26½ -11:29pm
Mincha Gedola (earliest Mincha) - 11:57-11:59pm
Plag Mincha - 3:31 - 3:31pm
Sunset - 4:41 - 4:40pm (4:35½-4:35pm)
Shabbat times for other cities:
Candles city Havdala
4:16pm Raanana 5:16pm
4:16pm Beit Shemesh 5:16pm
4:15pm Netanya 5:15pm
4:15pm Rehovot 5:16pm
3:56pm Petach Tikva 5:16pm
4:15pm Modi'in area 5:14pm
4:18pm Be'er Sheva 5:17pm
4:15pm Gush Etzion 5:15pm
4:15pm Ginot Shomron 5:15pm
4:00pm Maale Adumim 5:14pm
4:07pm Tzfat 5:12pm
4:16pm K4 & Hevron 5:16pm
Jerusalem lights candles 40 minutes before sunset. (Except for those
who don’t follow that custom.) Which sunset? Important question. The
standard practice is to count 40 minutes before “sunset of
elevation”. Jerusalem is a little over 800m above sea level. If one
could see the sun set over a horizon at sea level (which
can be
done from some parts of J’lem), it would
set about 5 minutes later than someone watching from sea level, or
seeing the sun set beyond mountains that are approx. the same height
as Jerusalem is. Since the sunset on the same plane is 5 minutes
earlier, and for Shabbat purposes is the sunset we would have to
consider because
of the
strictness of Shabbat, then J’lem candle lighting time is really
only 35 minutes before “the other” sunset.
All other places at some height
above sea level have similar problems.
Tzfat lights candles 30 minutes
before sunset. Official candle lighting for Petach Tikva is 40
minutes before sunset, just like Jerusalem. Not everybody holds by
that timing.
Some communities calculate
Shabbat out at 33 minutes after sunset. Some use the angle of the
sun below the horizon to “end Shabbat” (8.5 deg).
Bottom line for now: until we get
the chart running smoothly, don’t rely on it exclusively.
Cross-check times with calendars and charts. Please report
discrepancies to us, so that we can improve our time table.
Also realize that Sfardim and
Ashkenazim often has differences in minhag.
Explanation of the Z'manim
Sunrise for Jerusalem does not take into account elevation, since
the eastern horizon (where the sun rises) consists of the Hills of
Moav across the Jordan River, which are approx. at the same
elevation as Jerusalem
Sunset, on the other hand, is
given for an elevation of 825m and, in parentheses, as if at sea
level. There are different opinions as to which sunset time should
be used for halachic purposes. We present both times.
The deadlines for the SH'MA and
the Shacharit Amida can be calculated in two ways. Either
considering the day to be from sunrise to sunset or from dawn to
stars out. The first way of reckoning is known as the opinion of the
GR"A, and is the first time given in each case. The second method is
known as the Magen Avraham, and
is presented
in parentheses.
Aside from candle lighting and
havdala, the times are presented as a range, from the current
Thursday of the issue of Torah Tidbits until the coming Thursday, a
span of 8 days. Days between the two Thursdays can be determined by
interpolation (which means: a method by which to estimate a value of
between two known values-this is
something that people above a certain age might remember from
high school trigonometry and logarithms, but younger people who went
to school during the calculator era might not be familiar with).
It is usually wise to "pad" the
times with a minute or two in the "play it safe" direction. E.g.
Plag Mincha. Better to finish Mincha a minute or two before the
given time. But, better to not light candles until a minute or two
after the given time.
WORD OF THE MONTH
A weekly feature of Torah Tidbits to help clarify practical and
conceptual aspects of the Jewish Calendar, thereby better fulfilling
the mitzva of HaChodesh HaZeh Lachem...
As announced in shul last week
(and in Torah Tidbits), the molad of Kislev was early Monday (Nov.
24) morning. That makes the first opportunity for Kiddush L'vana
according to Minhag Yerushalayim, on Thursday night (Nov. 27). Most
people will wait until Motza'ei Shabbat, and the strict 7-days after
the molad people will have their first opportunity on Monday night
(Dec. 1). All of the above, of course, is weather-permitting.
Because of the variable length of Cheshvan (29 or 30 days), the days
of Kislev can each fall on any one of six of the seven days of the
week. This is in contrast to most calendar dates that have four
possible days of the week and a LO-AD"U type of situation. The 25th
of Kislev, for example, can be on any day except Tuesday. That means
the first (and last) candle can be any night except for Monday
night. Kislev's days are the only ones that are 6 yes - 1 no.
Lead Tidbit
It Makes a Difference
There's an old Western movie that has a scene of an Indian (Native
American) standing next to a "white girl",
behind a fallen tree (so you cannot see their feet).
The Indian pulls his knife out,
lunges in the direction of the girl, she falls down dead. The Indian
then notices that some white folks have seen him, so he runs to his
horse, jumps on it and rides away as fast as he can. The white
guysmount their horses and give chase (without bothering to check on
the girl). I don't remember most of the details, but it turned out
that there was a poisonous snake approaching the girl and the Indian
saved her life by stabbing the snake, and she fainted from fright
and was not dead at all. Lucky for the Indian that hestayed alive
long enough for the truth to be discovered. But I digress. Trust me
- there's a MASHAL brewing.
The written word of the Torah and
the plain meaning of the text often convey to the reader a false
picture of what is going on. Yaakov is cooking a lentil dish, Eisav
returns from the field exhausted and hungry and asks his brother for
some of the lentils. There is a fallen tree that is blocking our
view of what is really happening. Would
you believe that Yaakov was preparing a mourner's meal for Yitzchak,
because Avraham had just died? Would you believe that Eisav had just
murdered someone, worshiped an idol, and committed other sins,
making him totally unfit to serve as the pre-kohein (that was the
function of the B'chor) at his family's
altar? This aspect of the birthright needed to come to Yaakov. With
these details, we see the story from To-l'dot in a very different
light.
These details were NOT dreamed up
by an imaginative commentary who was looking to besmirch Eisav's
reputation and portray Yaakov in a favorable light. These details
are part of the Oral Tradition, which was revealed together with the
Written Word and past down through the generations. They (the
details) are part of the primary story.
This could be so even when there
are different opinions. When Rashi looks at the meaning of No'ach
was righteous in "his generation", he brings two points of view:
No'ach was so righteous that even in his wicked generation, he was
righteous, how much more so would he be in a "normal" generation.
Or, By comparison to his generation, he was righteous, but he would
not necessarily shine in a generation of good people. It is very
possible that the Oral Torah on the text contained both ways of
looking at it. And they don't contradict each other, even though
they are opposites. Because we need to look at No'ach's situation in
both ways. And apply lessons for ourselves from both perspectives.
To put it simply, if the Gemara
says it, then it is so. And whatever "it" is, it becomes part of the
Tradition. And this doesn't end with the Gemara. There are many
sources of Oral Torah that input into our Traditions.
All of the above is part of a
broader concept - namely, that it is IMPOSSIBLE to understand the
Written Word of the Torah without the Oral Tradition and Law. It
cannot be done.
Sedra-Stats
6th of the 54 sedras; 6th of 12 in B'reishit
Written on 172.7 lines in a Sefer Torah, ranks 36
4 Parshiyot; 2 open, 2 closed
106 p'sukim, ranks 29th (9th in B'reishit)Tied with Vayigash and Bo,
but shorter than both in words & letters and length
1432 words, ranks 34th (10th in B'reishit)
5426 letters, ranks 33rd (10th in B'reishit)
Its p'sukim are below average length
Mitzvot
None of the TARYAG are counted from TO-L'DOT
Aliya-by-Aliya Sedra Summary
[P> X:Y (Z)] and [S> X:Y (Z)] indicate start of a parsha p’tucha or
s’tuma respectively. X:Y is Perek:Pasuk of the beginning of the
parsha; (Z) is the number of p'sukim in the parsha.
Kohen - First Aliya - 16 p'sukim - 23:1-16
The parsha begins by telling us that Sara died in Kiryat Arba, which
is Hevron. But first it tells us that she Kohen - First Aliya - 21
p'sukim - 25:19-26:5
[P> 25:19 (16)] This is the history of Yitzchak b. Avraham; Avraham
fathered Yitzchak.
SDT Rashi quotes the Gemara that
tells that when Yitzchak was born, scoffers said that Avraham and
Sara, who were childless for so long, had found a baby and claimed
it as their own. Avraham invited the leaders of the nations, their
wives and infants, and Sara was miraculously able to wet-nurse all
the babies. (The Gemara points to the
plural "banim" in 21:7.) Then the scoffers accepted that Sara bore
Yitzchak, but chided Avraham that Avimelech was the father (since
Yitzchak's birth followed Sara's abduction). A miracle occurred and
baby Yitzchak was the very image of his father Avraham, until the
scoffers proclaimed, "Avraham fathered
Yitzchak".
SDT Earlier, the Torah tells us
of the generations of Yishmael b. Avraham. That seems to be in
balance with the beginning of this sedra, which speaks of Yitzchak,
except: [1] the Torah makes a point that Yishmael is the son of
Hagar the Egyptian, the maidservant of Sara. In other words,
Yishmael was NOT the real To'l'dotof Avraham; and [2] To'l'dot (in
the Yishmael context) is spelled without a vav, implying that
something was missing. To'l'dot of Yitzchak b. Avraham; it was
Avraham who fathered Yitzchak. And the word To'l'dot is spelled with
its vav.
Yitzchak is 40 years old when he
marries Rivka (3 years after the Akeida). The Torah emphasizes
Rivka's family background.
After 20 years of childlessness
(10 until Rivka was of child-bearing age plus an additional 10 years
without a child), Yitzchak and Rivka pray to G-d. G-d hears their
(actually his) prayer and Rivka becomes pregnant. She is having a
"rough time" and goes to Shem b. Noach (who outlived Avraham, by the
way) who tells herG-d's message, that she will give birth to twins
who will go in very different ways and become great adversarial
nations.
SDT Commentaries say that Rivka
was unaware that she was carrying twins; she thought the turmoil
within her existed in a single baby - this had her very upset; she
was somewhat calmed by the Divine message of her carrying twins.
Another commentator suggests that Rivka knew she'd have twins but
did not see the benefit of bringing a
Yaakov into this world if it meant also having an Eisav. Part of the
reply to her question "why do I need this", is that her conclusion
was wrong.
Take a look at Rashi. Two great nations - these are Antoninus and
Rabbi (Yehuda HaNasi)... It can be suggested that the Divine message
to Rivka, was that even though there will great tension and friction
between the descendants of the twins she was carrying, Yaakov and
Eisav, there will be an example of a Roman (from Eisav)and a Jew who
will truly get along and that is the hope for the future when the
nations of the world will all recognize Israel's role in the world
and their special relationship with the One G-d Who will then be
universally recognized.
Eisav and Yaakov are born, Yaakov
clutching the heel of Eisav. The boys grow and develop different
personalities - Eisav is the hunter and outdoorsman; Yaakov, the
mild, studious "tent-dweller". Yitzchak loves Eisav; Rivka loves
Yaakov.
SDT There are many different
commentaries on these relationships. Note that Yitzchak's love is
based on Eisav's providing food for him. Rivka's love is
unconditional. Pirkei Avot says that only an unconditional love will
endure forever.
Yaakov is preparing a lentil stew
for his father. (The Gemara tell us that this was the day of
Avraham's death; Yaakov was preparing the traditional mourner's meal
for Yitzchak.)
Eisav returns from the field in a
state of exhaustion. He asks Yaakov for some of the food. In
exchange for the food, Yaakov acquires the birthright, which is
insignificant in Eisav's eyes, but mean- ingful to Yaakov.
[P> 26:1 (33)] A famine hits the
Land (like the one in Avraham's time - this is one of the many
similarities between the lives of Avraham and Yitzchak) and Yitzchak
goes to Avimelech in Gerar. G-d appears to Yitzchak and reminds him
that he must not leave the Land. G-d also repeats his promises of
the Land and of the large nation that will
descend from him.
Levi - Second Aliya - 7 p'sukim - 26:6-12
Yitzchak dwells in Gerar. (This is one of the three word p’sukim in
the Torah.) Yitzchak and Rivka pose as brother and sister (as did
Avraham and Sara, and for the same two reasons). After a while
Avimelech discovers that they are actually husband and wife and
complains to Yitzchak about the deception. Avimelech ordershis
people to leave Yitzchak and Rivka alone. Yitzchak and family
flourish in Gerar and G-d blesses them.
TAKE A LOOK... The first famine
that drove Avraham and Sara to Egypt, when Par'o discovers their
true relationship, he sends then away. The second time, when they
went to Gerar and said they were brother and sister, and then they
were “found out”, Avimelech gives them many things and invites them
to stay. (Par'o had givenAvraham great wealth, but it was before he
knew.) Yitzchak and Rivka also say they are siblings, but no one
takes Rivka. When they are "found out", they stick around.
Shlishi - Third Aliya - 10 p'sukim - 26:13-22
Yitzchak thrives in Gerar, which creates jealousy among the locals
who fill in the wells that Yitzchak has dug. (There is great
symbolism in the Torah's account of the wells, their names, their
failures, and then their successes.) Yitzchak is driven away from
Gerar. A new well that Yitzchak digs is taken over by the
shepherdsof Gerar, as is yet another well. Only the third well
called Rehovot permits Yitzchak to live in relative peace.
(Some see this as a hidden
reference to the 1st and 2nd Beit HaMikdash, which fell, and the 3rd
which will stand forever. May we see it soon in our time.)
SDT Brachot 56: Rabbi Chanina said, he who sees a well in a dream,
he will see peace... Yitzchak's servants dug and found a live
spring, B'EIR MAYIM CHAYIM. This is immediately followed by the
peace treaty between Avimelech and Yitzchak. Rabbi Natan continues
in the same Gemara. He who sees a well in his dream has foundTorah,
as it says in Mishlei: He who finds me, finds life... an equation is
made between G-d, Torah, and Life.
R'vi'i - Fourth Aliya - 7 p'sukim - 26:23-29
Yitzchak sets himself up in Be'er Sheva. G-d appears to him and
reiterates the promises for prosperity made to Avraham. Yitzchak
builds an altar to G-d and continues to prosper. Avimelech,
realizing that his own prosperity was due to the presence of
Yitzchak, comes with a delegation to Yitzchak in order to enter into
acovenant with him.
(Not a rare experience through
the generations - Jews are expelled from a country, which
subsequently regrets its actions because of the decline they
experienced without the Jews in their midst. And we, somehow, kept
going back. One of the puzzles of Jewish History.)
Chamishi - Fifth Aliya - 33 p'sukim - 26:30-27:27
Yitzchak and Avimelech partake of a meal and exchange oaths. Be'er
Sheva is reaffirmed as "the city of the Avot" by Yitzchak's actions.
Another example of the similarity between Yitzchak's life and
Avraham's.
[S> 26:34 (2)] Eisav marries at
40 years of age - a (sub)conscious attempt to emulate his father.
However wicked Eisav is, he is genuinely respectful and loving of
his father. On the other hand, Eisav's choice of a wife disgusts
both Yitzchak and Rivka.
[S> 27:1 (55)] Yitzchak is old
and blind and calls to Eisav to prepare for him a special meal and
then receive a special blessing. While Eisav is in the fields doing
his father's bidding, Rivka prepares Yaakov to receive the blessing
instead of Eisav. She tells Yaakov to bring her two goats and she
would prepare the dishesthat Yitzchak loved. Yaakov hesitates for
fear that Yitzchak will feel his smooth skin and realize that Yaakov
has come to deceive him. Rivka dresses Yaakov in Eisav's garments
and places a goat-skin on his neck to give it a rough feel. She
gives Yaakov the food to bring to his father.
It seems obvious that Yaakov was
punished measure for measure for his deception of Yitzchak. The
Brothers not only deceived Yaakov concerning the fate of Yosef, but
they used a goat and a garment (exactly the two items that Yaakov
used to deceive his father) to bring about their deception. If we
accept the idea that Yaakov was supposed
to get the bracha that Yitzchak was going to give to Eisav, that it
was G-d's will, and even G-d's command according to Onkeles, to
Rivka to “set it up”, then why was Yaakov punished so severely? An
answer might be suggested in the form of an analogy. When one has to
take drastic, life-saving treatments -"serious" medication,
radiation, etc., what is done might be absolutely necessary, but
there are often harsh side-effects.
Shishi - Sixth Aliya -23 p'sukim - 27:28-28:4
The blessing invoked by Yitzchak upon Yaakov, for bountiful produce
and respected status among nations, has been borrowed by us to be
recited on Motzaei Shabbat - V'YITEN L'CHA HA-ELOKIM...
As Yitzchak finishes blessing
Yaakov, Eisav returns from the hunt. He prepares food for his father
and presents it with a request (demand) of the blessing. Yitzchak
trembles when he realizes that the bracha went to Yaakov. When
Yitzchak explains to Eisav that Yaakov received (and rightly so) the
blessing, Eisav bitterly cries out and
asks his father for a blessing too. Yitzchak gives Eisav a blessing
(not as exalted as Yaakov's). Eisav decides to kill Yaakov for this,
the second time he has taken something away from him. Rivka hears
(how? Ru’ach HaKodesh again, perhaps?) of Eisav's plans and
encourages Yaakov to flee to Rivka's hometown
until Eisav's wrath subsides. Rivka suggests to Yitzchak that
he send Yaakov away to find a proper wife.
Note that Rivka did NOT tell
Yitzchak that Eisav wanted to kill Yaakov. Perhaps she felt that it
would pain him to much to learn of Eisav's true character. Perhaps,
Yitzchak would have refused to believe that his Eisav would
contemplate such a thing. Instead, Rivka expresses another concern
(legitimate) as her reason for wanting
Yitzchak to send Yaakov away.
Yitzchak calls for Yaakov and
gives him another blessing and sends him off to Padan Aram to find a
wife among Rivka's family. He gives Yaakov "the blessing of
Avraham", thus providing for the continuity of the Chain that
becomes Judaism.
Sh'vi'i - Seventh Aliya - 5 p'sukim - 28:5-9
Yitzchak sends Yaakov off to Padan Aram to Lavan b. B'tu'el, the
brother of Rivka who is the mother of Yaakov and Eisav. (Unusual
ID). Eisav sees that their father has sent Yaakov to find a wife,
because he does not want him to take a Canaanite wife. Yaakov goes
on his way and Eisav takes as another wife, the daughter of
Yishmael. And Eisav takes Machalat b. Yishmael...
Talmud Yerushalmi exclaims that
this is Bosmat, and asks why her name was changed. The astonishing
answer is that all Eisav's sins were forgiven when he took a wife
intended to please his parents. The Talmud generalizes and gives
this as the source that the sins of a CHATAN (and KALLA) are
forgiven when they marry. Strangesource for an important concept.
The final 3 p’sukim are reread for the Maftir.
Haftara - 21 p'sukim -Mal-achi - 1:1-2:7
There is speculation as to whether Mal'achi is the name of an
individual, or a description of "My messenger". Some say that
Mal'achi was Ezra. Mal'achi is known as the last of the prophets.
Mal'achi brings G-d's message to the people that He loves Yaakov
(and his descendants), and hates Eisav, even though Yaakov and Eisav
are brothers. Thus, the Haftara echoes the rivalry and
relationship between the two brothers that is the substance of the
sedra To'l'dot. The haftara refers to the respect a son has for his
father. In this regard, Eisav was exemplary.
Mal'achi criticizes the kohanim
of the time for not being careful in the offering of korbanot. We
can see this as a preparation for the building of the new Beit
HaMikdash in the hopes that it will function properly and be a true
honor to G-d.
THE JERUSALEM INSTITUTE OF JEWISH LAW - Rabbi Emanuel Quint, Dean
Lesson # 211 (part 3 - Gifts - part XIII) • Words Indicating a Gift
Reuven, who is critically ill, makes a single declaration, orally or
in writing, without pausing between the gifts, stating that he gives
the following gifts made in apprehension of imminent death or as
gifts causa mortis: $200 to Shimon, $300 to Levi, and $400 to Yehuda.
There is no priority among the donees in this case
either since Reuven did not pause while making the oral
declaration or since they were all included in the same memorandum
of the gift. Reuven dies of this critical illness and leaves assets
totaling only $700, which is $200 short of the total of his gifts.
The donees must proportionately share the $700. Shimon will
receive$155, Levi will receive $233, and Yehuda will receive $312.
Assume the same gifts and that
Reuven dies leaving an estate of $900, sufficient to pay them all.
Reuven also leaves a debt of $450, exactly fifty percent of the
assets that he gave away as gifts. The gifts are subject to the
payment of the donor's debt. Each of the donees will pay his
proportionate share of the debt: Shimonwill pay $100, Levi will pay
$150, and Yehuda will pay $200.
Reuven, being critically ill,
makes three separate declarations of gifts causa mortis or in
apprehension of imminent death. First he declares that he gives $200
to Shimon. Some time thereafter, he declares that he gives $300 to
Levi. Finally, some time thereafter, he declares that he gives $400
to Yehuda. These are treatedas giving priority in the order in which
the gifts were declared, with Shimon's gift having the most
priority, Levi's gift having the second highest priority, and
Yehuda's gift having the lowest priority. If Reuven dies of the same
illness and leaves assets of only $600, Shimon will receive $200,
Levi will receive $300,and Yehuda will receive only $100. If Reuven
leaves only $400, Shimon will receive $200, Levi will receive $200,
and Yehuda will receive nothing.
Assume Reuven makes the same
gifts as stated in the prior paragraph and leaves assets of $900,
enough to pay all three gifts. Reuven also leaves a creditor to whom
he owed $800. Yehuda will lose his $400 gift, Levi will lose his
$300 gift, and Shimon will lose $100 from his gift.
If the debt was $500, Yehuda
would lose his $400 gift, Levi would lose $100 from his gift, and
Shimon would not lose anything.
Assume that Reuven gives a gift
causa mortis to Shimon of $400 and leaves an estate of $300 after
the gift to Shimon is paid. Reuven's son Yaakov inherits the $300.
Assume that when Reuven dies, he owes $200 to Avraham. The entire
$200 will be paid by his son Yaakov who stands in the place of his
father. However, if Reuven declares, "Give
my son Yaakov $300," and then declares, "Give Shimon $400," the
entire debt of $200 to Avraham will be paid by Shimon.
As in all aspects of the gift
causa mortis, the witnesses must present the words of the critically
ill donor as precisely as they can remember, and therefore they
must, when possible, put in writing as quickly as possible the
donor's exact words, since they may be controlling to show the
donor's intent. As seen in thislesson, the words can determine
whether to decrease the gift if there are losses or shortfalls in
the estate. In all cases of doubt, the law will side with the heirs
since the distribution of the assets of the estate to them is
mandated by the Torah; the gift causa mortis is Rabbinically
ordained, and must, in cases ofdoubt, yield to the Torah heirs.
When Reuven, the donor who is
critically ill, declares a gift causa mortis of "$200 for Shimon" or
"$200 from my [Reuven's] assets," even if Reuven suffers losses
after the gift is declared the estate must pay the $200 to Shimon.
If the estate does not have cash to pay the gift to Shimon, it must
sell assets to pay the$200. However, if the losses occur after the
death of Reuven, then Shimon shares in the losses.
Assume that Reuven, before making
the gift causa mortis to Shimon, enumerates all of his assets and
then states that the $200 gift is to be given to Shimon. When the
assets are gathered, it is evident that the assets were worth less
than Reuven had stated. In that case, the gift to Shimon will be
reduced proportionately.
There are times when the donor wants the gift causa mortis to be
given to the donee from a specific source; there are times when he
intends that the gift come from his general estate after he dies.
There are different legal results depending upon the intent of the
donor. If the gift is from a specific source, what if the
source is lost, stolen, or destroyed? If not from a specific
source, what if part of the estate is lost, stolen, or destroyed?
Does the donee have to share such a loss with the donor's heirs?
Reuven, who is critically ill,
declares that he wants Shimon to be given $200 as a gift causa
mortis or as a gift in apprehension of imminent death. Since the
$200 represents less than all of the assets of Reuven, it cannot
qualify as a gift causa mortis unless the donor specifically
designates it as such or as a gift madein appre- hension of imminent
death. This gift is both general and specific. This is a general
gift insofar as not designating specific assets from which it should
be given; it is specific as to being one of money only. Shimon will
receive the $200 from the general assets of Reuven.
Reuven declares that he wants a
gift causa mortis of $200 to be given to Shimon from the money that
is in the vault in the former's study. Although this is specific in
two ways, being of money only and being money from a specified
source, the gift to Shimon can nevertheless be given from any of
Reuven's moneys. However, if the money is
stolen from the vault or the money in the vault is lost in any other
manner, Shimon will not be given the $200 gift.
Reuven declares that he wants
Shimon to be given a gift causa mortis of $200. Reuven's entire
estate, upon his death from that same critical illness, is $500,
which means that Shimon will be given $200, and the heirs of Reuven
will receive the remaining $300. However, Shimon will receive $200
only if there is at least $200cash among the assets of Reuven. If
there is less than $200, Shimon will receive a lesser amount, and if
there is no cash, he will receive nothing. If Reuven is owed money
by debtors, it is not included as money for the purpose of the gift.
The situation is different if the gift is not of cash but rather
refers to $200worth of Reuven's assets. If, of the $500 estate, $100
is stolen or lost in some other way, Shimon will bear two-fifths of
the $100 loss and the heirs of Reuven will bear three-fifths of the
$100 loss.
The subject matter of this lesson
is more fully presented in Volume VII Chapters 253 of"A Restatement
of Rabbinic Civil Law" by E. Quint,
published by Jason Aronson, Inc. and on sale at local Judaica
bookstores.
Questions to quint@inter.net.il
MEANING IN MITZVOT by Rabbi Asher Meir
Each week we discuss one familiar halakhic practice and try to show
its beauty and meaning. The columns are based on Rabbi Meir's
Meaning in Mitzvot on Kitzur Shulchan Arukh
Shabbat Enjoyment and the Limitations of Social Justice
If we read chapter 58 of Yishayahu in its entirety, we encounter a
surprising and even jarring juxtaposition. The beginning of the
chapter is a searing admonition not to be hypocritical in serving
G-d. The prophet laments how despicable it is that we act with
external piety while we oppress the unfortunate. Our fasts
are of no interest to HaShem if they are not accompanied by
sincere repentance.
What HaShem really wants from us
is to "untangle the snarls of wickedness, and open the ties of
perverted justice; to set free the oppressed and undo the
miscarriage of justice"; "to give food to the hungry, and bring the
impoverished into your home; if you see the naked then clothe him,
and don't neglect your kin".
The chapter then continues with a passage that commands honoring and
indulging the Shabbat! No mention whatsoever is made of helping the
unfortunate, yet the envisioned reward is similar to the one made in
the first part of the chapter!
It seems that our fasts are
despicable to G-d if they are not accompanied by social concern; but
our "feasts" are acceptable to Him even without such concern!
We find a parallel contrast implicit in a similar admonition of the
prophet Malachi. Malachi bewails the fact that the Kohanim in the
Temple are bringing the sacrifices in a perfunctory way, without
proper awe towards the One to Whom the offerings are brought. HaShem
warns them, "Behold, I rebuke you with [shortage of]
seed, and I smear excrement on your faces - the excrement of
your holidays [Yom Tov offerings]; and it will draw you near to it"
(Malachi 2:3).
The Zohar (Yitro II:88b) points
out that this exhortation refers specifically to Yom Tov offerings,
implying that lack of concern for others is a much greater problem
on Yom Tov than it is on Shabbat.
This doesn't mean that Shabbat
observance is unrelated to social concern. On the contrary, the
Torah repeatedly connects the observance with Shabbat with the
message of equality and concern for the needy. For instance, in the
passage introducing the manna, which is the first place we encounter
the Shabbat, we learn that each person
received an equal amount (Shemot 16:18). And on Mount Sinai, HaShem
commands us to give rest to our servants on Shabbat "so that your
manservant and maidservant should rest like you", so that we should
remember that we also were slaves in Egypt until HaShem freed us (Devarim
5:14-15).
However, social concern as a monolithic religious ideal is
inherently limited. Consider the paradox of the man who has a
respectable job and a comfortable house. Yet despite the fact that
he has "everything", he feels a spiritual vacuum, because his life
revolves around his own needs. He decides to devote himself to
others, and fights for social equality. His minor loss of
economic well-being is more than made up for by his newly-acquired
sense of mission. What will happen if his quest is successful?
Everyone will attain a respectable job and a comfortable house - and
everyone will feel the same spiritual emptiness he started with!
We see that an exclusive focus on social concern is just a
more enlightened form of materialism.
Concern for others is certainly
an essential value in Judaism. It is despicable hypocrisy to fast in
order to demonstrate that material enjoyments are meaningless to us,
if at the same time we rapaciously strive to increase our material
well-being at the expense of the downtrodden. This is the theme of
the first half ofchapter 58 of Yishayahu.
But even after we feed the hungry
and clothe the naked, after we free ourselves from obsession with
material gain, our material natures remain with us. We cannot fast
the year round! We have to find a way for rich and poor alike to
maintain their connection to material possessions, but to enjoy
these possessions in an elevated way -
elevated in the sense of "dignified", and elevated in the sense of
"sanctified". This is accomplished through the mitzva of honoring
and enjoying Shabbat. In this way we bestow an inner meaning on our
accomplishments in social justice, as the prophet Yishayahu
concludes in the second half of the chapter.
“Meaning in Mitzvot” is undergoing intensive editing, and BE"H and
the help of loyal supporters, we hope to have the book out soon. If
you would be interested in helping with publication, please contact
Rabbi Meir about making a dedication or subscription (advance
purchase):
mail@asherandattara.com, fax 02-642-3141
Rabbi Meir authors a popular weekly on-line Q&A column, "The Jewish
Ethicist", which gives Jewish guidance on everyday ethical dilemmas
in the workplace. The column is a joint project of the JCT Center
for Business Ethics, Jerusalem College of Technology - Machon Lev;
and Aish HaTorah. You can see the Jewish Ethicist, and
submit your own Qs — www.jewishethicist.com or www. aish.com
Spiritual and Ethical Issues in the Historical Books of Tanach;
JOSHUA, JUDGES, SAMUEL, KINGS (Nevi’im Rishonim) by Dr. Meir Tamari
Saul, the Troubled King
How is it that Saul, who was amongst the prophets, the first king of
Israel, and whom Bible calls, 'the anointed messiah of G-d', could
become the relentless hunter of David and one consumed by an evil
spirit, described in chapter 18 and further on? How are we to
explain the many incidents of his fury at David such as the
casting of the spear at him while he was playing the harp
before Saul or the slaughter of the priest of Nov for giving David
sanctuary or the pursuit after him in the wilds of EIn Gedi and
Midbar Yehuda?
Many Jewish and non-Jewish
artists have portrayed him as madman like Lear; authors and
playwrights have depicted him in the web of depression; and
academics have described his pursuit as the necessary acts of a man
frightened for his political life. However, all those surrounding
him seem to have had no inkling of any depression,
instability or insanity. To his son Jonathan, he was a father
to be respected and a king worthy of obeying; Michal his daughter
was faithful to his wishes; and his generals and troops loyally
followed him into battle both against the Philistines and against
David. Furthermore, had they been told in the Books of Chronicles,
that are in essence history, just like the archives of kings
and states, perhaps the explanations of mental instability would
have been appropriate, but in the prophetic books that are concerned
with religiosity-spirituality, morality and ethics, they have no
place. Even though the text tells us that, "An evil spirit from
G-d came upon Saul" (18:10), that could easily account for
such explanations, still there is no place for them.
This spirit came upon Saul after
Samuel had spoken his traumatic words; "The Lord has torn the
Kingdom of Israel from you …and given it to your neighbor that is
better than you" (15: 28). Not only the merit of kingship of the
kingdom of priests was torn from him, but the spirit of HaShem left
him (16:13-14); instead his soul was
filled by the evil spirit of despair and rejection caused by the
realization of the enormity of his sin. We should bear in mind that
all of Saul's sins were connected to his role as king; there was not
even a hint of any personal wrongdoing.
Abarbanel explained that because
of this imagination and self-examination, he no longer was like
other people, rather he was constantly busy with his sin and with
the sorrow that he had failed in his allotted messianic duty.
According to the Malbim, the knowledge that the evil spirit that had
come upon him was from the Lord, led to
the thought that now G-d was his enemy. We hear echoes of the same
idea in the prayer of Jonah from the depths of the sea.
It was this utter despair and
feeling of complete rejection arising out of the obsession with his
sin, that our sages saw as the cause of the loss of prophecy, of his
pursuit of David and of his inability to repent and thus achieve
spiritual peace.
"Prophecy does not come in
laziness, nor in sorrow and sadness; rather through simcha" (Shabbat
30b). Sorrow, worry and concern caused prophecy to depart from Saul.
"Because of the sighing, concern and worry of Jacob all the time of
his mourning over Joseph, the Divine Spirit left him. Then when he
heard that Joseph was alive, it is
written, 'And the spirit of Jacob revived'; which Onkelos translates
as, 'and the spirit of prophecy dwelt on Jacob'." (Rambam Shmoneh
Perakim 7).
Sorrow and despair of themselves
are actually a sin and they lead us easily into further evil. Devoid
of hope and a future, people are easily led to continue and even
expand the evil that led to their wrongdoing in the first place,
since they feel powerless to change anything. "That is why there are
three reminders in the daily mincha
offering [that was brought by the soul as homage]; one to atone for
sin, the other cure the soul [that is sick with despair] and the
third for the sin that will come because of that sickness " (HaEmek
Davar, Vayikra 2:2).
The process of repentance and the
confession that is a prerequisite thereof, should not be a morbid
involvement with the dark recesses of the human soul and thought, as
Saul allowed it to become. Rather, "It is the great mercy that the
Almighty has given to His creatures. [Hashem himself taught us the
13 Divine Attributes which form the core
of our selichot (penitential prayers)]. He has thereby prepared for
them a pathway out of the guilt-filled pit and an escape out of the
conscience-racked trap [of remorse yet inaction at] their offenses.
[It is this Divine gift of repentance that enables people] to save
themselves from spiritual destruction….Even if they have offended,
rebelled and corrupted, He has not closed before them the gates of
repentance" (Rabbi Jonah of Gerondi, Shaarei Teshuva, First Gate,
section 1).
"Adam asked Cain why he was no
longer downcast and sad at the murder of Hevel. Cain replied, 'Hashem
showed me that one can repent and I did'. When Adam heard this he
exclaimed, 'All these long years and only now have I understood how
easy that is'. Immediately, he stood and sung, 'A Song of praise to
the Shabbat Day" (BereishitRabba).
Saul's inability to understand
and assimilate this Divine Mercy of the possibility of teshuva,
caused the black spirit that corrupted his very being and led to the
relentless pursuit of David, even to the massacre of the priests of
Nob.
This is the fourteenth
installment in Dr. Tamari’s series on “Tanach and its messages for
our times”
MISC section - contents:
[1] Vebbe Rebbe
[2] Words of Wisdom; Words of Wit
[3] Candle by Day
[4] MicroUlpan
[5] Various Divrei Torah
[6] Torah from Nature
[7] From Aloh Naaleh
[8] From the desk of the director
[1] From the virtual desk of the OU VEBBE REBBE
The Orthodox Union – via its website – fields questions of all types
in areas of kashrut, Jewish law and values. Some of them are
answered by Eretz Hemdah, the Institute for Advanced Jewish Studies,
Jerusalem, headed by Rav Yosef Carmel and Rav Moshe Ehrenreich,
founded by HaRav Shaul Yisraeli zt"l, to prepare rabbanim
and dayanim
to serve the National Religious community in Israel and
abroad. Ask the Rabbi is a joint venture of the OU, Yerushalayim
Network, Eretz Hemdah... and the Israel Center.
The following is a Q&A from Eretz Hemdah...
Q I often am asked to go to a
significantly later minyan than I like in order to ensure a minyan
in a house of mourning. On those days, I do not have time for
breakfast between davening and work. To further com- plicate
matters, in the morning, I have to take medicines that cannot be
eaten on an empty stomach. May I have
breakfast before davening under these circumstances?
A The gemara (Berachot 10b)
brings two p'sukim as the basis for the prohibition on eating before
Shacharit. While the first one seems to indicate an objective
problem, Chazal interpret the second in a manner that implies that
it is an act of haughtiness to involve oneself in eating before
addressing Hashem, his Creator and King.
The Beit Yosef (Orach Chayim 89) understands that the prohibition is
rabbinic and the p'sukim are only asmachta (an informal basis within
Tanach for a rabbinic law). He explains that Chazal formulated the
derivation in a way that would imply that they forbade eating only
when it, subjectively, displays haughtiness.What are some examples
where eating before Shacharit is permitted under these guidelines?
The Avi Haezri (cited by Rosh,
Berachot 1:10 and accepted by Shulchan Aruch (OC 89:3)) says that
drinking water is not indulging enough to be considered haughty.
Mahari Abuhav (accepted by Shulchan Aruch, ibid.) says that, by the
same logic, one can eat foods whose purpose is medicinal. The Biur
Halacha (ad loc.), basedon the Pri Chadash and Pri Megadim, says
that in a medicinal context, it is permitted to eat even if one is
capable of waiting until after Shacharit. Another scenario is where
one is too thirsty or hungry to daven with proper concentration.
According to the strict letter of the law, one should not pray in
such a stateof mind (Rambam, Tefilla 5:2). Even though we are
resigned to sufficing with a lower than proper level of
concentration, one has the right to eat or drink as necessary to
enable better concentration (Beit Yosef, ibid.). The Pri Megadim (Eshel
Avraham 89:13) says that this too is not considered an act of
haughtiness andwas never included in the prohibition.
The question, in your case, is
whether eating which is not medicinal, but is preparatory for taking
medicine, is permitted before Shacharit? Pri Chadash (89:4) is
bothered by the need for special permission given to one who is
thirsty to drink before davening. After all, one can drink water
even if he is not particularly thirsty. He
re-reads the Shulchan Aruch to say that if one is thirsty but
considers it unhealthy to drink water on an empty stomach, he can
even eat to enable him to drink. So we see that any eating which is
necessary to enable an activity which halacha deems important before
davening (including taking medicine) is permitted.
The Biur Halacha (ibid.) suggests that before eating, one
should at least say Kriat Shma (first paragraph), which needs to be
preceded by Birchot Hatorah. Others add a suggestion to say a prayer
that contains an element of supplication and/or Birchot Hashachar.
Since these anyway need to be said before P'sukei D'zimra,it is not
a big deal to say them a little earlier, before eating.
The only limitation is that the
poskim are strict about extending these leniencies beyond the
necessary minimum. (See, for example, the Mishna Berura (89: 21)
regarding what one who needs to drink tea in order to concentrate
can put into it and many other sources.) Thus, while you are
permitted to eat the amount necessary to
prevent the medicine from having a detrimental effect on your health
(consult your doctor), that would not permit you to take the
opportunity to have a full breakfast at that time.
It is wonderful that you are
willing to arrange your schedule in order to accommodate mourners.
We hope you can find a way to start the morning with the nutrition
and calm needed to get a good start, but without compromising the
primacy of tefilla as the beginning of one's activities. We assume
that, with further planningand continued dedication to doing things
right, you can work out the situation in the best possible way.
Ask the Rabbi Q&A is part of
Hemdat Yamim, the weekly parsha sheet published by Eretz Hemdah. You
can read this section or the entire Hemdat Yamim at www.ou.org or
www.eretzhemdah.org. And/or you can receive Hemdat Yamim by email
weekly, by sending an email to info@eretzhemdah.org with the
message: Subscribe/English (fortheEnglishversion) or
Subscribe/Hebrew (for the hebrew version). Please leave the subject
blank. Ask the Vebbe Rebbe is partially funded by the Jewish Agency
for Israel
[2] ArtScroll Series • Mesorah Publications Ltd.
WORDS OF WISDOM WORDS OF WIT by Shmuel Himelstein
Chassidim of the Vizhnitzer came to him. "Rebbi", they told him, "we
are in need of a Rav for our town. Could you suggest one for us?"
The Vizhnitzer immediately gave them the name of one of his
students, a truly brilliant talmid chacham. A few days later, the
chassidim returned. "Rebbi," they said, "we asked him to come for an
interview, and when we came we saw that he is little more than a boy
- and a very frail one at that. Could you suggest someone else?"
"Now that I know your
requirements," said the Rebbi, "I have the perfect candidate for
you. Here is his name and address," he said, as he handed them the
name of a man living in an adjoining town. When they finally
approached the second man, they found that he was the local butcher
of that town, a middle-aged man who was as strong as an ox but
completely unlearned.
If you’ve enjoyed these stories, look for Shmuel Himelstein's new
book, "Wisdom and Wit", at your local Jewish bookstore - an entirely
new collection.
[3] Candle by Day
It would seem that just as there are colds and diseases of the body,
so there are corresponding states of the mind which periodically
impair its thought outpoint... And just as in the case of the body,
rest and a mild food diet are the factors which often effect a cure,
so in the case of the mind, mental rest and an easily digestible
mental fare may be the wisest regimen to pursue. - From A Candle by
Day by Rabbi Shraga Silverstein
[4] Micro Ulpan - a word (or two) from HaAcademiya LaLashon Ha-Ivrit
Try this one on your favorite Hebrew speaker: You can ask in either
direction - what's a YOMEIM?or how do you say commuter in Hebrew?
Don't ask both at the same time; commuter - YOMEM; commuters -
YO'MIM'EIM; commuting - YOMEMUT
[5] Various Divrei Torah
Eisav
The following comments about Eisav from the Talmud and Midrash are
taken from the book ISHEI HATANACH by Yisrael Yitzchak Chasida
The Midrash says that Eisav greatly resembled Yitzchak physically.
The Gemara says that Eisav did not rebel during Avraham's lifetime
(which was cut short by 5 years - 175 and not the 180 that Yizchak
reached so that Avraham would not see Eisav's wickedness).
Targum Yonatan says that Eisav killed Nimrod (and took his special
garment - some say it was the leather garment made by G-d for Adam &
Chava).
The Midrash says that Eisav encouraged his grandson Amalek to take
revenge against the children of Yaakov, since he did not succeed in
vanquishing Yaakov.
The Zohar says that there was never a person who so honored his
father as did Eisav to Yitzchak. This earned him domination in this
world. Targum Yonatan adds that Eisav's honoring of Yizchak is what
caused Yaakov to fear him, especially since he (Yaakov) spent so
many years away from his father.
The Zohar says that Eisav's tears at losing the bracha caused Bnei
Yisrael to go into Galut.
When Rivka was experiencing difficulty in her pregnancy, she went to
ask G-d about it. "And G-d said to her..." - on these words Rashi
says, G-d spoke to her through SHEIM, to whom G-d communicated via
RU'ACH HAKODESH. Rashi seems compelled to say that because Rivka is
not a prophetess. The Talmud mentions 7 prophetesses: Sara, Miriam,
Chana, D'vora, Chulda, Avigayil, and Esther.
On the other hand, Onkeles states that Rivka's instructions to
Yaakov as to how to receive the bracha from Yitzchak came to her via
prophecy.
Later, Rivka finds out what Eisav said only in his heart. Prophecy?
Communication from G-d comes in different forms: prophecy, visions,
dreams, Ru'ach HaKodesh, and more. There are subtle differences
between the different ways that G-d communicates with people. Did
Rivka receive prophecy?
SDT When Rivka finds out that Eisav wants to kill Yaakov, she tells
him of her plan for his leaving the scene and spending some time in
her hometown. She says: "...why should I be bereaved of both of you
in one day?" The Gemara tells us that on the day that Yaakov was
being buried in Me'arat HaMachpeila, Eisav tried toblock entrance to
the body. Chushim, son of Dan, grandson of Yaakov killed Eisav and
his dead body (or part of it) fell upon Yaakov's body. At that
moment, says the Gemara, the "prophecy" of Rivka came true. Torah
Temima (the original TT) explains that it wasn't actual prophecy, be
it was K'ILU, like she said somethingand it came true, even though
she did not at all intend it to be so when she uttered those fateful
words. This is considered on of several examples of the power of the
words of certain individ- uals. There is an implied warning.
[6] MA RABU MA'ASECH HASHEM KULAM B'CHOCHMA ASITA MAL'AH HA'ARETZ
KINYANECHA
As we've explained in the past, the letters in the arch above the
turtle are the initial letters of the words in T'hilim 104:24, which
proclaims the wonders of nature as G-d's magnificent handiwork. MRMH
is the English acronym for the pasuk: MA RABU MAASECHA HASHEM... The
column is part of TT because the wonders of nature are part of G-d's
world. Expanding our knowledge of nature, adds to our knowledge of
G-d and our love for Him.
Hippopotamus
Large, herbivorous, river-living mammal of tropical Africa...
short-legged, broad body with a tough gray or brown hide... weighs
about 5 tons; female is slightly smaller. The mouth is wide, and the
incisors and lower canines are large ivory tusks that grow
throughout life. The eyes are near the top of the head, so the
animal can see when nearly submerged. Hippos usually live in herds
of about 15 animals. Much of their time is spent standing or
swimming under- water, where they feed on aquatic plants; they must
rise to breathe every 5 minutes or so. At night groups of animals
feed on shore... Recent DNA studies indicate that whales are most
closely related to hippos... name literally means river horse... but
there is very little that is horse-like about a hippo. The animal is
truly amphibious... stout, but dispropor- tionately short, legs.
Nevertheless, the hippo can run at fast speed on land... not a good
swimmer... cannot float... Underwater activity is rarely seen, as
the hippo is usually in muddy water... calves often climb onto their
mothers' backs if the water is too deep for them to stand up in
it... reflex action ensures that the nostrils and ears are closed by
muscular valves as soon as they come in contact with water. Air in
the lungs is expelled in an explosive burst on surfacing, sending a
miniature water-spout into the air. At the same time the ears are
waggled furiously to clear them of water... very sensitive skin...
hence its fondness for mud... a subcutaneous mucous gland secretes a
pinkish to reddish oily liquid that helps in keeping the hippos skin
from drying out... huge canine teeth are the principal weapons of
hippos, promi- nently displayed during the incorrectly termed
"yawning", which is really a warning signal... Court- ship is a
rough affair... Hippos mate in the water and usually give birth
there as well. Suckling also takes place under water... deep
resonant call that would be menacing were it not preceded by a near
falsetto squeal... hippos vocalise under water as well as on land...
Hippos are long-lived animals although by 40, they are decidedly
geriatric and not many live beyond that age in the wild. (BTW,
either hippopotamuses or hippopotami is acceptable for plural.)
[7] CHIZUK and IDUD (for Olim & not-yet-Olim respectively)
Parshat Toledot tells us of Yitzchak, who is now happily married,
living in Israel and involved in providing for his young family.
Unfortunately, how- ever, financial conditions begin to worsen,
affecting not only Yitzchak, but the entire region. What is a
responsible husband and father to do? Yitzchak decides to do
precisely what his father did - pick up and move to another country
where life is easier, where he will be able to enjoy prosperity and
financial security. Not only does Yitzchak make up his mind to
leave, but he is already on the road when Hashem appears to him and
says: "Don't go... sojourn in this land... and I will be with you
and bless you..."
Rashi explains that Hashem tells
Yitzchak ein chutz l'aaretz k'dai lecha- it doesn't befit you to be
in chutz la'aretz. It isn't "kedai" - worthwhile, fitting, proper,
or appropriate for you. While it is true that Yitzchak enjoyed a
special status after the Akeida, knowing how to choose what is "kedai"
is a lesson that must be learned by every observant Jew. It is true
that there may be many reasons - economic, professional, and
familial - to live outside of Israel. But Hashem tells Yitzchak -
and through him He tells all of us - that any decision on this
matter must be based not on what is most comfortable, but on what is
really "kedai."
Rabbi Eliezer Langer , Jerusalem
TORAH THOUGHTS as contributed by Aloh Naaleh members for publication
in the Orthodox Union's 'Torah Insights', a weekly Torah publication
on Parshat Ha'Shavuah
[8] Divrei Menachem
The episode of the Birthright in parshat Toldot provides us with a
piercing insight into the life of Ya'akov Avinu. Ya'akov is faced
with the dilemma of whether or not to accede to his mother's design
to outwit his firstborn brother and deceive his father Yitzchak.
In her commentary, Nechama Leibo-
witz helps us to understand that Ya'akov was definitely hesitant to
comply with the plan. For example, when we contrast the ponderous
manner by which Ya'akov approached Yitzchak with delicacies - "he
went, took and brought" - with the haste with which Avraham and
Rachel are described as performing mitvzot,
we discern the depth of Ya'akov's distaste for the stratagem.
Nevertheless, the text in the
Tanach implies disapproval of Ya'akov's supplanting of Esav (cf.
Yirmiyahu 9:3). The Torah teaches that Ya'akov was paid back at
every step: his sons deceived him with a bloodstained coat; Leah,
the "Bechora" (firstborn) "replaced" the younger Rachel.
The ultimate test for Ya'akov is
that he must reconcile himself with Esav, despite all that the
latter stands for, before the pronouncement of the angel (Breishit
32:27-29) can come to fruition. Only after Ya'akov implores Esav to
take his blessing (ibid 33:11) can Hashem now dispense with the name
associated with deceitfor the elevated name of Yisrael, a prince of
G-d.
Shabbat Shalom,
Menachem Persoff
SHEYIBANEH BEIT HAMIKDASH...
A series of articles on Beit HaMikdash-related topics by Catriel
Sugarman intended to increase the knowledge, interest,
and anticipation of the reader, thereby hastening
the realization of our hopes and prayers for the rebuilding
of Jerusalem and the Beit HaMikdash.
Where did all the Blood Go?
Lately I've received a number of emails asking this excellent
question, and in fact, this is a favorite question on the lecture
circuit as well. After all, vast numbers of animals were slaughtered
and offered as Korbanot in the Mikdash; ergo, lots of blood. How was
it removed?
One of our main sources on the
Mikdash drainage system is the Letter of Aristeas, written
ostensibly by a non-Jewish officer of King Ptolemy II Philadelphius
of Egypt (285-246 BCE) named Aristeas to his brother Philocrates.
Most scholars agree that this apologetic work is greatly
romanticized and consequently must be taken
with the proverbial "grain of salt" (a topic, by the way, for
a future column - salt, that is). The author, a true enthusiast,
loses no opportunity to glorify the Jewish people, the perspicacious
philosophy of Yahadut, the uniqueness and authenticity of its
ancient traditions and of course, the incredible magnificence
of the Beit HaMikdash. It is thought that the author was an
Alexandrian Jew, and that the Letter was written between 250-100
BCE. The Letter recounts how at least some of the blood was removed.
"And the whole floor (of the Azara) is paved with stone and it is
sloped leading to the appropriate places to allow for the flushing
of water which occurs so as to cleanse the blood from the
sacrifices. For many tens of thousands of beasts are brought for
sacrifice on the days of the festivals… There were also many
openings at the base (of the Mizbei'ach) which were invisible to all
except those (Kohanim) who have the duty of carrying out the
service,so all the blood of the sacrifices, which is collected in
huge amounts, is cleansed by the downward momentum and slope"
(ch.90). The Mishna (Pesachim 5:8) - describes how the Kohanim
cleaned the Azara after the crowds offered their Korban Pesach. "As
the ritual was performed on a weekday, so was it performed on
Shabbat except that then, despite the
displeasure of the Sages, the Kohanim would wash down the Azara."
Tif'eret Yisrael (ibid.) explains, "The flow (of the running water
in the plumbing system under the floor of the Azara - T.Y. Midot
3:2) would be stopped, and as a result, the water (would surge up
through the holes in the floor) and flood
the Azara. Then they would scrub down the marble floor washing off
any (remaining) spilled blood and they would unplug the stoppers
thus re-opening the drains and all the (dirty) water would flow
out."
As a result of Zerikat HaDam of
vast numbers of Korbanot, especially during the Shalosh Regalim,
quite a bit of blood was "thrown", poured or "placed" on the
Mizbei'ach as well. Where did that blood go? Was the Mizbei'ach also
designed and constructed in such a way as to facilitate the draining
of this sacrificial blood? According to
Tif'eret Yisrael, the answer is "yes". Perhaps more cognizant than
any other traditional commentator of the many practical difficulties
presented by "Mikdash- logistics", Tif'eret Yisrael offers a
possible solution. First he addresses the question of how the
Kohanim managed to consistently pour the excess
blood remaining in the Mizrak (sacred vessel) after Zerikat
HaDam, exactly into the "two holes like two narrow nostrils" located
at the south-western corner of the Yesod (base) of the Mizbei'ach (Midot
3:2). Tif'eret Yisrael writes, "…there were two holes there, one for
'inner sin-offerings' (e.g. Yom Kippur Avoda) and
one for 'outer offerings' (all other Korbanot)… it is
impossible to say that they spilled the blood exactly on the holes
because the Mishna tells us that the holes were like 'narrow
nostrils'. How would they be able to pour the thick blood directly
on these narrow holes? It might be possible if the Kohanim poured
blood on that part of the Yesod which was
to the south (where the holes were located). But what are we to say
when the Kohanim poured blood on the western (or northern) side?
Obviously the blood was poured on the Yesod and not directly on the
holes. And from the place where the blood was poured, it flowed down
to the designated hole. Also around the
outer edge of the Yesod was a lip which actually made it into sort
of open drainpipe which facilitated the flow of the blood and
prevented it from spilling down to the Azara floor" (ibid). We may
add that the Yesod would of necessity have to have been built with a
steep enough gradient to allow the blood
to flow swiftly enough so it would not coagulate. In addition, the
surface of the Yesod would have to be smooth and cleaned constantly
to prevent impediments from collecting which would tend to obstruct
the blood flow. The Mishna in describing part of the Yom Kippur
service relates: "The Kohein Gadol sprinkled the
blood on the cleansed surface of the Mizbach HaZahav (golden
incense altar) seven times and then poured out the rest of the blood
on the western base of the outer Mizbei'ach. The rest (of the blood
sprinkled on the outer Mizbei'ach) he poured on the southern base.
Both bloods mingled in the channel (the plumbing system
under the floor of the Azara) and flowed down to the Kidron
Valley (south and southeast of Jerusalem). And it was sold to
gardeners as fertilizer and the law of sacrilege applied to it…" (Yoma
5:6) Such a modern concept! The sacrificial blood from the Temple
Sacrifices was recycled!
And a note to M.C. from Teaneck
about the Bamah. Often translated as "high place" or "field altar",
the Bamah in Yahadut has a fascinating history. "Before the (desert)
Mishkan was set up, Bamot were permitted and Avoda was done by the
first born (of each family), but once the Mishkan was set up, the
Avoda was done by the Kohanim and Bamot
were forbidden... After they came to Gilgal (where the Mishkan was
located while Eretz Yisrael was being conquered and apportioned),
Bamot were again permitted... After they came to Shilo (and set up
the Mishkan there), Bamot were forbidden… After they came to Nov and
Giv'on, Bamot were again permitted...After they came to Jerusalem,
Bamot were forbidden and never again permitted… (Zevachim 14:4-8).
In the period when the central sanctuary did not house the Aron
HaBrit, such as in the days of Gilgal, Nov and Giv'on, Bamot were
permitted. "For you have not come to the resting place or to the
heritage" (Devarim 12:9). The sanctuary at
Shilo (which did house the Aron) was considered the "resting place"
and the Beit HaMikdash was considered the "inheritance". A Bamah
Ketana (small Bamah) was a private altar upon which voluntary
sacrifices (such as Shelamim, peace offerings) could be offered. The
altars at Gilgal, Nov and Giv'on were consideredBamot Gedolot, and
while suitable for most public Korbanot, they did not have the
status of the Shilo sanctuary or the Beit Hamikdash since they
lacked the Aron. It took many generations for the idea of the
necessity of centralized worship in the one Beit HaMikdash in
Jerusalem on one hand, and the internalization of theprohibition of
offering Korbanot at Bamot on the other, to percolate into the
consciousness of the people. In the days of Bayit Rishon, with the
exception of Kings Chezkiyahu and Yoshiyahu, even during the reigns
of the righteous kings of Yehuda, "…the Bamot were not taken away".
Their continued existence was one of thecauses of the exile Melachim
Bet 17:9).
Catriel Sugarman (acatriel@netvision.net.il,
02-652-7531) gives illustrated lectures on the Beit Hamikdash and
related topics. Catriel is in the process of writing a book: The
Temple of Jerusalem, A Pilgrim's Perspective: A Guided Tour through
the Temple and the Divine Service.
Towards Better Davening and Torah Reading
Column #94. Contents of this weekly column are (mostly) based on the
sefer: EIM LAMIKRA HASHALEIM, by R' Nissan Sharoni, Ashdod, a guide
to correct pronunciation of Hebrew, specifically in davening and
Torah reading.
Concerning Birkat Kohanim...
Last week we wrote about the correct accenting of the words of this
three-pasuk, 15-word blessing. DK/BE would like to apologize if his
words sounded critical of Kohanim; his intentions were educational
and not meant to sound sharp.
None of the words change meaning if the wrong syllable is accented.
So we are not talking of a serious flaw. "Just" the beauty of
correct Hebrew. And maybe a little more because of the command in
the Torah: KO T'VORACHU ET BNEI YISRAEL, EMOR LAHEM - Thus you shall
bless the people - say to them: It is as if G-d was thefirst One to
call out the words that Kohanim throughout the generations are to
repeat. We see it each day as repeating after the Shaliach Tzibur,
but it is really repeating after G-d. If He said to say ei-LE-cha,
then the Sha"tz should say ei-LE-cha and the Kohanim should say ei-LE-cha.
Not ei-le-CHAAAA. yi-SA, not YI-sa.It just seems important to get
right.
Since we presented DK/BE's understanding of the role of an ALEF, we
now present YL's. We've got a real, old-fashioned MACHLOKET. Who's
right? We'll see. Here's what YL writes...
The twenty-two letters of the Hebrew alphabet all represent
consonants, i.e. the sounds we make when we block (completely or
partially) the air flow from our lungs. For example: we pronounce
[b] ] - represented in writing by BET - by pressing our lips
together, thus blocking the air flow at the lips. Similarly, we
pronounce [g] - written as GIMMEL by pressing the back of our tongue
against the palate and blocking the air flow there. Precisely in
this manner we pronounce a glottal stop (or "catch") by blocking the
air flow at the vocal cords, and we represent it with an ALEF.
It is not true that an ALEF contributes "no sound at all". Thus
YA'-DIR very definitely has an ALEF-sound before the DALET, just as
YAF-GISH has a FEI-sound before the GIMEL. When is it true that an
ALEF is silent? Only when it has no NIKUD whatever, as in the word
M'LACHA or in the word B'REISHIT (just like the second SHIN/SIN in
the name YISSACHAR - it has no NIKUD whatever, and so remains
silent.) And so you do not lengthen the YA in any way in the word
YAADIR you pronounce a glottal stop after the A and get two closed
syllables: YA' and DIR.
Of course, we all know that ALEF is taught as a "silent letter" in
the Ashkenazi tradition. But this (actually) only relates to those
ALEFs without NIKUD. When an ALEF has a NIKUD-sign, it is supposed
to be pronounced as a glottal stop.
Dear reader, don't think you've heard the last word on the
pronunciation of ALEF.
On another note... In Parshat To-l'dot, we find a not-so-common
occurrence of a CHATAF-vowel under a letter that is not ALEF, HEI,
CHET, or AYIN (the usual letters that get CHATAFs). The Torah
describes Rivka's experience during pregnancy as VAYTROTZETZU
HABANIM B'KIRBAH - the children struggled inside her... There are
three different opinions (practices) as to how to pronounce the
TZADI with a CHATAF-PATACH.Some always pronounce these CHATAFs just
like a SH'VA NA (except for the ones under ALEF, HEI, CHET, AYIN).
Some pronounce then as CHATAFs, even though they are not the usual
four letters. And some will pronounce them with a CHATAF unless the
letter under which the CHATAF is, is the first of two-the-same
letters (which is the case here) or the word has to do with eating
or blessing - in which cases, the CHATAF is pronounced like a SH'VA
NA. Therefore, two of the three opinions go for VAYIT- RO-TZ'TZU
(rather than VAYIT-RO-TZA-TZU).
Parsha Pix
Classic ParshaPix again this week, with two additions which will be
PPPs (ParshaPixPuzzles, sort of like a visual TTriddle).
Top-left is Yaakov with his lentil stew.
Next to him is one of Yitzchak's workers on a break from digging
wells.
Continuing across the top, we come to a Seder plate. Rashi tells us
that it was the first night of (the future) Pesach that Yaakov
presented himself to Yitzchak for the bracha.
Rivka told Yaakov to bring her two goats. Just to feed Yitzchak, you
need two goats? Rashi answers that one was for the main dish and the
other for Korban Pesach.
Upper-right is a king on his father's back. The hand is pointing to
the father, who would be AVIMELECH.
This is not the only pun in this week's ParshaPix, as you will see.
The rain cloud ispart of the bracha that Yaakov received.
The sword is part of the bracha to Eisav.
The lion cub on the map of Israel is another pun - GUR BAARETZ HAZOT.
Actually, live in this Land...
The tow truck is another pun - Yitzchak lived in GERAR. Tow is also
a reminder of the first syllable of the name of the sedra. TO-L'DOT,rather
than the more common (but mistaken) TOL-DOT.
The passport is for Yaakov who is being sent abroad by both Yitzchak
and Rivka. Yitzchak never needed a passport, but Yaakov did.
The teddy bear is holding aloft the number 7 in one paw and an
upraised hand in the other. There are two meanings to the name Be'er
Sheva.One is from the seven sheep that Avraham gave Avimelech as a
token of the covenant between them, and the other is for the oath(s)
that were taken in that agreement. SHEVA has both connotations.
And in the lower-right is the Davka Judaica Graphic of Yaakov, the
studious ISH TAM, dweller in the tent of Torah study, and Eisav,the
ISH SADEH, the man of the field, the hunter.
That leaves the two new elements. Your mission, should you accept
it, is to find those two elements figure out their meaning. If
you... should be caught, the secretary will disavow... This tape...
TTRIDDLES...
are Torah Tidbits-style riddles on Parshat HaShavua (sometimes on
the calendar). They are found in the hard-copy of TT scattered
throughout, usually at the bottom of different columns. In the
electronic versions of TT, they are found all together at the end of
the ParshaPix-TTriddles section. Some TTriddles are
alsopresentedforcall-insolution on Torah Tidbits Audio (Arutz-7,
Thursday night). The best solution set submitted each week (there
isn't always a best) wins a double prize a CD from Noam Productions
and/or a gift (game, puzzle, book, etc.) from Big Deal
Last issue’s (Chayei Sara) TTriddles:
[1] Identical words ban whom from what?
[2] Avraham, Yishmael, Yitzchak, Yaakov, and who?
[3] Rivka and the Three Queens
[4] Eliezer, Yonah, Koresh, Nechemia
[5] x to find her; 3x from son to son
[6] People from here are early risers
[7] The arrow? (from the ParshaPix)
And the envelope, please...
[1] There were some good attempts at this one, but the “official”
(originally intended) answer is SIM NA YADCHA TACHAT Y’REICHI, the
words of the oath that Avraham administered to Eliezer, banning his
taking Yitzchak out of Eretz Yisrael. The same words were used by
Yaakov Avinu in the oath he administered to Yosef, banning
his (Yaakov’s) burial in Mitzrayim.
[2] VAYIGVA, and he died (breathed his last breath - the word
obviously has a slightly different meaning than he died, because it
is sometimes followed by VAYAMOT, and he died). In addition to
Avraham, Yishmael, Yitzchak, and Yaakov, the word is used to
describe the demise from the Flood of every living thing.
[3] Rivka and Vashti (queen), Esther (queen), and Bat Sheva (queen,
although the word is not used for her, as it is for Vashti and
Esther) are all described as TOVAT MAR-EH, good looking. Although
only these four women are called TOVAT MAR-EH, there are other,
similar terms for beauty that describe other women (and men),e.g.
Y’FEI TO-AR, Y’FEI MAR-EH, YAFA.YAFEH. And, in some cases, the
superlative M’OD or AD M’OD is added - exceedingly beautiful.
[4] Here is an example of a TTriddle that contains a mistake, and
yet several people solved it. It was not Eliezer, but Avraham, when
he was instructing Eliezer, who referred to G-d as HASHEM ELOKEI
HASHAMAYIM. Curiosity, which is very often responsible for TTriddles,
led to a computer search of Tanach to find others who
referred to G-d in exactly the same way. The search yielded
three others: Yona, when his concerned shipmates asked him who he
was and what he was doing, etc. - this after the lottery had fallen
on him as the cause of the trouble at sea they were all
experiencing. He identified himself as a Jew who fears HaShem, the
G-dof the Heavens. Koresh, king of Persia, is quoted twice - once in
the book of Ezra and once in Divrei HaYamim - as acknowledging
HASHEM ELOKEI HASHAMAYIM for all the lands that he ruled, and for
charging him to build G-d’s House in Yerushalayim. And Nechemya used
the phrase in prayer on behalf of the people of Israel.
[5] x=10 camels. Avraham sent Eliezer with 10 camels to find Rivka.
And one of her sons, Yaakov, gave her other son, Eisav, 30 camels
(among other animals) as a gift of appeasement.
[6] ARAM NAHARAYIM occurs twice in the Torah, once as the hometown
of Avraham Avinu and once as the hometown of Bil’am HaRasha. Pirkei
Avot contrasts these two people and puts them at diametrically
opposed poles of personality traits. Commentaries explain
that when the Torah tells us about someone getting up early in the
morning, it indicates an enthusiasm towards some goal.
Avraham avinu rose early in the morning, saddled his own donkey
(another indication of enthusiasm), to set out at G-d’s command to
the Akeida. L’havdil, Bil’am is also described as rising (early) in
the morning and saddling his own donkey, to enthusiastically
accompany the delegation from Balak.
People from Aram Naharayim are early risers.
[7] The arrow in last week’s ParshaPix connected two elements of the
PP to produce this TTriddle. The gift package and the bull. This is
a play on words for the travels of of the family of Yishmel. They
traveled from CHAVILA (sound-alike, different spelling of the word
for package) to SHUR (spelled like SHOR but the dot
of the VAV is in its middle rather than above its head).
This week's TTriddles:
[1] 3 boys, 3 teens, 5 adults, and...?
[2] Yitzchak's servants and who & who?
[3] Yitzchak to Yaakov, G-d to Moshe and [L] Bil'am
[4] Aside from many names, only three are called this way
[5] plus two elements from the ParshaPix
Israel Center Miscellany
Re: The Israel Center and Torah Tidbits
NOTICE: The OU Israel Center and Torah Tidbits do not necessarily
endorse the political or halachic opinions of its advertisers, nor
do we guarantee the quality of their service. Nor do we endorse any
party or candidate.
The Israel Center's Beth Din to adjudicate and arbitrate monetary
disputes, according to Jewish law There is a registration fee of
200nis per case No other charges for this service Please call
566-7787 ext. 204 for further information We have forms for two
types of cases: Those where both parties agree to submit their
dispute to the
Beth Din, and those where a
complainant wants the Beth Din to summon the second party. Yitzhak
Fund, Esq. • Rabbi Emanuel Quint Chairpersons , Ita Rochel,
Administrator
Kashrut Questions: If you find a discrepancy between the Hebrew
labeling and the original packaging... or if you have any other OU
kashrut questions, call this toll-free number (from Israel to NY)
1-800-949-0123 From 4:00pm - midnight, you get a human; other times,
leave a voice- message OU Kashrut in Israel office at
theCenter:5667787
Israel Center Cafe: Delicious meals and snacks, soups, sandwiches,
salads...Under the supervision of <-Israel Mehadrin, Located on the
lower level of the Israel Center, Hours: Sun.-Thu. - 10:00am -
3:00pm, plus... Catering for all occasions by Schocketino Catering
on and off the premises • Home entertaining made easy with
our selection of beautiful
platters: cheese, fish, vegetable, fruit, deli, cake, OU and
Mehadrin hashgacha. To order call Chaim
at: 058-551-538
The Arnold Abroms Memorial Lending Library: Hours - SUN., MON & WED:
10-5, TUES: - 10-4; THURS: 1-3,MON & WED eve.: 5-8pm
Yankel Winet z”l Torah Tape Libraries including the Israel Center
Torah Tape Library and the Aish HaTorah Tape Library at the Center•
Sunday, 11:00am-1:00pm, 3:00-5:00pm; Monday - Wednesday,
10:00am-1:00pm
ANNOUNCEMENT • to all community organizations in Jerusalem • To help
avoid clashes of major events among different organizations, please
call Ita Rochel at the Israel Center, (02)
566-7787, ext. 204
OU Israel Center Family Counseling Service, For appointment call:
066-443-532
For your information: Over the years of Torah Tidbits, the typing
and layout have been done with several different programs. For more
than a year now, TT has been prepared with DavkaWriter, and the
program just gets better and better. Davka’s contact in Israel:
991-2718.
Torah Tidbits are available on the internet on the OU’s website
www.ou.org/torah/tt. You can download all of it at once or whatever
sections you want. Palm version too.
The OU Israel Center on the internet! Torah Tidbits has been on the
internet for a few years. Its pages are part of the OU’s website,
and can be found at www.ou.org/torah/tt; We are pleased to announce
the newest addition to the OU website The OU Israel Center; This new
site is part of the OU’s website too.You can accessthematwww.ou.org/israel/ic;
Please note: You can go from the Torah Tidbits site to the
Israel Center site and vice versa. You can go from either Israel
Center site to the OU’s homepage and vice versa. Here’s your
assignment, should you choose to accept it. Check out the OU Israel
Center’s website. Check out the TorahTidbitswebsite.And check out
theOU’s main site (www.ou.org) where you can explore the many facets
of OU activities and programs,access dozens of Torah shiurim and
sites, Kashrut, audio, video... and much more.
If you are a member of the Israel Center...Thank you; If you were a
member and your membership lapsed...Please renew; If you’ve never
been a member...Please join
As of Rosh HaShana 5764, yearly membership for couples (even if one
of the two does not frequent the Center) is 250NIS. Membership for a
single person is 180NIS per year. Life membership remains at $500,
with payments possible. Contact the Center for details of membership
benefits. • Membership includes lower rates
forallIsraelCenterprograms, tiyulim, etc.and a subscription to
Jewish Action, the Orthodox Union’s popular quarterly magazine - You
can cut and send this form to us atP.O.B. 37015, Jerusalem 91370 or
call us (566-7787 ext. 204) with the details and arrange credit card
payment by phone or email to trochel@netvision.net.il;Specialnoteto
TTreaders who do not regularly participate in Israel Center
activities (or never): You actually do participate in an Israel
Center activity... called: Torah Tidbits; Many people feel that just
for Torah Tidbits alone, it’s “worth it” to become members of the
Israel Center.We hope you feel that way too.
Sundry
Your tax-deductible support for the Malki Foundation / Keren Malki
helps us enable quality home-care for seriously disabled children in
Israel. Ph. 058 853317 • www.kerenmalki.org
• In loving memory of Malka Chana Roth HY"D murdered in the Sbarro
bombing, 9 Aug. ‘01
Religious senior couple need to rent Kosher apartment in Riverdale,
NY vicinity - Chanukah to end of January. references available.
Also want to rent our Kosher deluxe 2 bedroom, 2 bath apt. in
Rechavia, Jerusalem. Private heating, all AMerican appliances.
Swimming pool in building. at the same time as above.
Call: 02-561 7590, ritansy@netvision.net.il. In New York:
718-884-4259 (leave message)
Tiyulim and Shabbatonim
THE TRAVEL DESK for making registration and receiving info of Israel
Center tiyulim. And, to help you - whether you live in Israel or are
visiting - plan private tiyulim and make in-Israel travel
arrangements. We will be happy to assist you from 9:00am-1:00pm on
Sundays, Mondays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays. Call Batya
atTheTravelDeskof the Israel Center, 566-7787 ext. 249; fax:
566-7876 • tiyul@israelcenter.co.il
THE TIYUL HOTLINE Dial the Israel Center's number 5-66-77-87, then
press 211. You'll hear "thank you, one moment please", and then the
phone system's music for 15 seconds (or less). Then the Tiyul
Hotline message begins. You can listen to the whole message and then
press 2 to leave your message, or you can interrupt
bypressing2rightaway and leaving your message sooner.
What’s for lunch? When a tiyul says “bring your own lunch”, you can
buy one instead from the Israel Center Cafe. Call the TRAVEL DESK or
TIYUL HOTLINE up to the day before the TIYUL and request a box
lunch. 18š will get you a delicious sandwich (specify your
preference), a refreshing drink (specify regular or diet)
andadessert.Yourbox will be ready for you when you board the bus.
TIYUL POLICIES Please note: We reserve the right to charge a
cancellation fee in case of last-minute cancellations. (Please speak
to Batya at the Travel Desk when making reservations.) Also... Price
of tiyul is based on a minimum number of participants.
Students from Abroad Are your parents planning on visiting you some
time this year? If so, you want to speak to us! (566-7787 ext. 211
or 249). We have many attractive deals for them... and you. Let us
turn an ordinary “been there, did it” visit into an unforgettable,
special one!
KASHRUT POLICY Food for Israel Center In-House programs is
supervised by OU-in-Israel - Mehadrin. Israel Center sponsored trips
and programs are under Mehadrin Hashgacha. Hotels, restaurants, and
tiyulim advertised by the Travel Desk or by outside parties are not
necessarily Mehadrin and are not endorsed by the OU or the
Israel Center.
Israel Center Tiyulim are partially subsidized by the Jewish Agency
for Israel
Thursday, December 11th, Leaving the Israel Center at 7:45pm; Rare &
Special Opportunity; Private showing of a magnificent Judaica
Collection • This collection has not been shown in many years, and
might not be for more to come. Among the many exquisitesilver
ceremonial objects are: Chanukiyot, SederPlates, Mezuzot,
candlesticks,Kiddush Cups, Havdala Sets and many more treasured
works of art lovingly gathered from all over the world over a period
of many years; Hear the fascinating and intriguing stories behind
this amazing collection • Limit: 25 participants; Donation 75NIS •
Coffee & Cake • Proceeds of the evening will go towards the
purchaseof Tefillin for the Israel Center's Gesharim Bar Mitzva
Program, Join us for this unique evening • Participants will be led
on a short walk to our special destination
EIN GEDI • A Dream Vacation Come True; 4 days - 3 nights: MON-THU,
December 15-18, '03 (Leaving Monday 9:30am • returning Thursday
afternoon), Free bathing at the Spa including mineral & mud baths;
Magnificent Magical Botanical gardens on premises; Covered Sweet
Water Pool; Full and varied program – Tiyulim - shiurimincl.tourof
the cactus garden, health lectures, exercising • Mehadrin with Eida
Chareidis and Rav Landau productsand a full-time Mashgiach on the
premises • 249NIS p.p. per night (if you stay 3 nights); 269NIS p.p.
per night (for 2 nights); 279NIS p.p. for a one night stay •
Exclusive beautiful deluxe room 299NIS p.p. pernight• Prices are for
double occupancy – half board (breakfast and dinner - lunch 30NIS
extra) • For Monday’s lunch, you must order this meal when you sign
up, or it will cost 35NIS., Single supplement available • Price
includes transportation from & to the Centerfor those who sign up
for the whole tiyul; Rooms have fridge,"kumkum",coffee, tea,
cookies, crackers; Ein Gedi Botanical Gardens are the only national
botanical gardens in the world that have people living in them! •
Shulamit’s tiyulim are always treats; Come! You will surely enjoy
her delicious sweets
TRAVEL DESK SPECIALS
For reservations at the hotels listed below or any other Israeli
hotels, please call Batya directly at the Travel Desk 566 7787, ext.
249. She'll be happy to accommodate you with any of your requests.
Astoria, Tiberias, valid DEC 5-7, 12-14
Shabbat and Sunday: 650NIS per couple, h/b
Blue Weiss Spa, Netanya, valid Nov. 30-Ded 4
MIDWEEK: 435NIS per couple per night, H/B
Habat HaBaron, Zichron, valid Nov. 30 - Dec. 4, Dec. 7-11
MIDWEEK: 350NIS per couple per night, B/B
Kinar Classic Hotel, valid Dec 4 - 7, 11-14
SHABBAT, F/B + Thursday night or Motza'ei Shabbat, H/B:
Deluxe room: 1310NIS per couple
Rimonim Galei Kinneret, valid Nov. 30 - Dec. 4
Includes 1 treatment per person, 1075NIS per couple per night, H/B
Carmel Forest Spa, Tzfat, valid Nov. 30 - Dec. 4, Dec. 7-11
2-night MIDWEEK package: 1470NIS per couple, F/B
Canaan Spa, Tzfat, Valid Nov 30-Dec. 3, Dec. 7-10
2 night midweek package: 1855NIS per couple, dinner and brunch
Eden Inn Zichron, Valid Nov 30-Dec. 4, Dec. 7-11
midweek: 310NIS per couple per night, B/B
Chanuka specials
Inbal, J'lem Dec. 19-21, Friday to Sunday morning
1650NIS per couple, H/B,
Sheraton-Plaza, Jerusalem, valid Dec. 19-20
First SHABBAT CHANUKA, 1265NIS per couple, F/B
Eden Inn, Zichron, valid Dec. 21-24
CHANUKA MIDWEEK 3-night package: 1635NIS per couple, H/B
Discounted rates for children • Special Chanuka programs
Sheraton-Moriah, Dead Sea, valid Dec. 21-25
4-night CHANUKA package: 3990NIS per couple, H/B
Ramot Resort Hotel, Tiberias, valid Dec. 21-25
420NIS per couple per night, H/B
Discounted rates for children
B/B = Bed & Breakfast • H/B = Half Board (breakfast + one meal) •
F/B (3 meals a day) Midweek = SUN, MON, TUE, WED nights • Weekends =
THU, FRI, Motza"Sh nights
The Back Page of TT595
The Avrom Silver Jerusalem College for Adults is the educational
component of the Seymour J. Abrams • Orthodox Union • Jerusalem
World Center and incorporates classes & lectures
of the OU Israel Center's Project Yedid, JCA, and the Jewish
Values Education Institute.
"Regular" classes & lectures - 20NIS members, 25NIS non- members.
Life members, 5NIS (except for programs of/with other
organizations). No one will be turned away for inability to pay.
Membership 250NIS couple, 180NIS single. Programs of the Center are
partially funded by the Jewish Agency for Israel or the UJC
Shabbaton this week: people in the neighborhood are invited to join
us for davening and/or shiurim, as follows...
Friday nite
4:05pm Mincha, Kabbalat Shabbat & Maariv, Carlebach-style with a
flavor of Chazanut with Chazan Binyamin Munk and the B'nevel Quartet
8:30pm (approx.) Shiur by Rabbi Shmuel Klitzner "Parental Love &
Tangled Webs", Oneg Shabbat
Shabbat DAY
7:30am Pre-davening mini-shiur by Phil
8:00am Shacharit, etc. with Chazan Binyamin Munk and sons11:45pm
(approx.) Shiur by Rabbi Emanuel Quint: "Yaakov & Eisav and the Beth
Din"
3:00pm Shiur by Rabbi Shmuel Klitzner: "Injuries that Enable",
Mincha follows at 4:00pm
4:25pm Drinks & Nosh, Q&A and discussion
5:05pm Maariv & Havdala (Shabbat is out at 5:16pm)
Motza”Sh
Motza'ei Shabbat (a.k.a. Sat. nite), November 29th, 8:00pm • Why
does the Beilin Geneva Plan dominate the media limelight? A special
session on the indiscretions of the Beilin GenevaPlan and how to
respond to it in the media, David BedeinIsrael Resource News Agency
<www.israelbehindthenews.com>
Motza’ei Shabbat, November 29th, 8:30pm; Redeeming Captives even at
the cost of Releasing Terrorists: A Halachic/Torah perspective on
this sensitive issue by Rabbi Efraim Sprecher
Sunday thru Thursday
10:00am The Weekly Mitzvot and Concepts fromMinchat Chinuch by Rabbi
Dovid Zitter
resume Jan. 21 Wednesday & Thursday mornings (Masechet Avoda Zara)
Gemara Shiur with Rabbi Moshe Gorelik
1:20pm Mincha (this time stays the same throughout the year)
3:00pm Daf Yomi by Rabbi Shmuel Halpern
4:30pm Shiur in Masechet Beitza by Rabbi Hillel Ruvel
5:30 Maariv (thru Tevet)
Shiurim are in English and take place in the Ganchrow Beit Midrash
For men who want to do some serious learning...
Gentlemen: Watch for details of an expanded Beit Midrash program for
men to include Chavruta learning and additional shiurim to run from
9:00am to Mincha at 1:20pm (or parts thereof). If you'd be
interested, call us at 566-7787 ext. 207.
Sunday
N'SHEI LIBRARY 10:30-12:45
9:30am (women) • Mystical Insights into the Months of the Year with
Golda Warhaftig
10:30am (women) •L et's Learn Chumash with Tonia Frohwein
11:30am (men & women) Parshat HaShavua with Shprintzee Herskovits
Sunday, November 30th, 4:00pm • Healing & the 10 S'firot by Yaakov
Gerlitz, Dipl. Ac, Practitioner of Chinese Medicine, Shaarei Zedek
Hospital
7:30pm •Jewish Thought as it emerges from the Torah with the help of
Ramban's Commentary, Now studying: From Adam to No'ach & the Bnei
Elokim with Rabbi Chaim Eisen
Sunday, November 30th, 8:00pm - • Book Month lecture by Rabbi David
Aaron
Monday
N'SHEI LIBRARY - 10:00-12:30
9:15am (men & women) • Excursions into the world of Nevi'im with
Mrs. Pearl Borow
10:30am (men &women) • Rambam’s 13 Principles • Rabbi Zev Leff
11:36am (men and women) • Jewish History series: The War of Quietus
with Dr. Henry Goldblum
11:36am (women) • Rabbi Yissocher Frand on the Truth will set you
free followed by discussion with Aviva Nissim
SLIM FOR LIFE Group weight-loss program for women, No obligation for
the first session • Qualified nutritional advisor on hand; Mondays,
from 11:35am • Elisheva 999-6479
Monday, December 1, 12:30pm • Lunch and Video: “Parshat Toldot" by
Avivah Gottlieb Zornberg
Fit Forever: Look & Feel your Best! Exercise class for women of all
ages at the Israel Center, Gentle exercises to improve your
flexibility, circulation, posture, etc.Breathing and relaxation
skills to use every day. Satisfaction guaranteed! Mondays,
12:45-1:45pm Call Sura Faecher, 9932524
Mondays (and Wednesdays) 2:00pm, Hebrew-reading Ulpan with Chani
Abramson
Women's Beit Midrash • Acquire study skills and knowledge crucial to
your life as a Jew - join us! Guided Chavruta study with Pearl Borow,
In-Depth study of Chumash B’reishit with Rashi, - Shiur by Rabbi
David Derovan
Pri Chadash Women's Writing Workshop • Mondays: 5:20-7:20pm with
Ruth Fogelman (628-7359) & Mindy Aber Barad (643-5276)
Mondays at 7:30pm (and Wednesdays at 9:00am) • The Avrom Silver
Jerusalem College for Adults presents...Parshat HaShavua with Dr.
Avivah Gottlieb Zornberg
NEW! Mondays 7:00-8:30pm • Jerusalem Congressional Task Force, Meet
and discuss ways in which to communicate with U.S. Congress people
abroad concerning vital issues of the day in Israel of which they
may not be aware
MASK - Mothers & Fathers Aligned Saving Kids • J'lem Chapter at the
OU Israel Center • Dr. Judy Belsky, PhD - Group Facilitator; Join us
at our next bi-weekly meeting - MONDAY, Dec. 1, 7:30-9:00pm •
http://maskjerusalem.cjb.net • Also in Ramat Beit Shemesh: Call (02)
999-6686 or 999-6162
8:30pm • AM SEGULA; “Curing the Jewish Heart” series with Eli Yosef,
Historical overview of the Exile and Redemption
Tuesday
N'SHEI LIBRARY - CLOSED
The Israel Center and the Old City Free Loan Association 14th year •
over 3000 loans granted, Gemach - Free Loan Society to provide
interest-free loans for people in financial distress. Interviews at
the Center on Tuesdays from 10:00-12:00 • Please bring ID
Yad Yaakov Center for Jewish Education classes at the Israel Center,
Tuesdays, 9:00-10:30am, Call 054-690-330 for further information
9:00-10:00am • The World of Mishna; Halacha, Hashkafa and History
with Rabbi Aharon Adler
10:15-11:15am • Parshat HaShavua with Rabbi Sholom Gold
9:00am • Haftara: "Haftara: "Reconciliation between Am Yisrael and
G-d: As Dew to the Lily of the Valley"" with Dr. Hayim Abramson
9:55am • Mashiach in Rabbinic Thought with Dr. Hayim Abramson
10:50am • Parshat HaShavua with Rabbi Mordechai Spiegelman
11:55• Chabad insights into Parshat HaShavua and the Actualia of Our
Time (women only) with Raizel Zisk
Jewish Values Education Institute presents Wellsprings of
Creativity; Come & discover your own writing ability! Each of us is
a wellspringof thoughts, memories, stories & poetry. Let your inner
voice emerge...12 1½-hr. sessions with Esther Sutton; Tuesdays,
12:00-1:30pm
Video and Lunch • Tuesday, December 2nd, 12:30pm • “Hillel Kook
Memorial Evening”, Hon. Moshe Arens and others
Tuesday, December 2nd, 7:30pm • Who angers or disappoints you? How
should they change? Learn The Work of Byron Katie a simple method of
self-inquiry that can change your life. Workshop facilitated by Dr.
Moshe Dann For more information: www.thework.org
Tuesday, December 2nd, 8:00pm • Panel Discussion: Are we still "The
People of the Book"
Wednesday
9:00am • Dr. Aviva Zornberg on Parshat Hashavua
10:45am • Rabbi Macy Gordon on Do ends Justify the Means in Business
On Dec. 10, 17, and 31 Rabbi Gordon will be giving his lecture on
Wednesdays at 9:00am and Rabbi Gold will be giving a class on the
Kuzari - Adventures in Jewish Thought
9:30am • Towards More Meaningful Davening with Dr. Joel Luber
Wednesday, December 3rd, 12:30pm • Guest speaker: Dr. Morris Mandel,
Pyschologist, Prolific author, long-time Jewish Press columnist
(Mondays and) Wednesdays 2:00pm; Hebrew-reading Ulpan with Chani
Abramson
Women's Beit Midrash, Acquire study skills and knowledge crucial to
your life as a Jew - join us!
3:00pm • women in Tanach; Guided Chavruta study with Pearl Borow
7:30pm •Jewish Philosophy • Road Map to the Prophets - Rambam's
Guide for the Perplexed, Now studying: Taamei HaMitzvot - Criminal
Law with Rabbi Chaim Eisen
Root & Branch Association (in cooperation with the Israel Center)and
in collaboration with the Raoul Wallenberg Honorary Citizen
Committee
Wednesday, December 3rd, from 18:00 • Rabbi Michael Ber Weissmandel
z"l Memorial Evening
Info: rb@rb.org.il • NIS25 per person, members NIS20, students NIS10
(for any and all lectures)
Rabbi Michael Ber Weissmandel z"l Memorial Evening
18:00 Introduction • Greetings by the Israel Center,the Raoul
Wallenberg Honorary Citizen Committee and other organizations
"Beacons in the Dark" as expressed in the art of Yitzchak Greenbaum
"Missed opportunities to reduce the Holocaust's Magnitude" by Yacov
Fuchs
"Some personal reflections on the Politics of the History of Rescue
"by Dr. Becky Kook, Ben Gurion University; Daughter of Hillel
Kook (Peter Bergson)
"The Bratislava Working Group" by Professor Yeshayahu Yellineck
"Reflections on our history of the past and history of the future"
by Larry Pfeffer
20:00 INTERMISSION (Snacks and meals on sale at Israel Center Cafe)
20:30" Torat Chemed and Hidden Messages in the Torah" by Dr. Moshe
Katz
Rabbi Weissmandl pioneered the field of Torah Code analysis
"Rabbi Weissmandl's Letters Pleading for Help for the Doomed Jews of
Europe"by Yacov Fuchs
Video taped interviews
THERE MAY BE SLIGHT CHANGES IN THE PROGRAMFinal program will be
listed on Web site: www.geocities.com/eProceeding
8-10pm • Aliya Counseling with Miriam Bass
Thursday
10:30am • Shiur while you fold...New topic: Chassidut with Rabbi
David J. Derovan
Shmooze while you fold • Divrei Torah, verbal tidbits, Q&A, and...
with Phil; Some time IY”H, sometimes B”N
8:00pm • Legends from the Gemara with Reb Yosef Schreiber
Friday
9:00am • In-Depth Pirkei Avot with Rabbi Chaim Eisen
upcomings at the Israel Center
Motza'ei Shabbat, Dec. 6th, 8:30pm • Rabbi Yaakov Moshe Poupko on
Taking the Menorah from the Mikdash into the Great Outdoors
Sunday, Dec. 7th, 8:00pm • Macrobiotics: What is it? Dr. Michael
Feinerman
Monday, Dec. 8th, 8:00pm • Discover Ohr HaBinah
Jewish, Hands-On and Distance Healing: Developed and taught
by Rabbis, Gain concrete tools to feel better and more capable to
help others, grow spiritually, and find a new, happy, healthy
profession, Lecture byRabbi Legomsky MA Neurotherapist
Tuesday, Dec. 16th, 7:00pm • KISS your fears, anxieties, sadness,
physical pains, and overeating/smoking GOODBYE! and Rebuild your
marriageor succeed now finding your match! Practical demonstration
lecture by Rabbi Legomsky MA
Neurotherapist Immediate results - this is not talking psychology!
Tuesday, Dec. 23rd, 8:00pm • An Evening of Music & ArtSurprise
Slides on a Special Subject
Watch upcoming Torah Tidbits for details
of our special Chanuka programs
Mondays Dec. 8 & 15; 12:30-1:45pm • Jewish Arts and Crafts. Call
5667787 x 261 to register
SINGLES in their 20's & 30's - TUE Dec 9, 7pm: "Must I Forfeit My
Individuality to be a Good Mate?" Insights by best-selling author,
Gila Manolson at the Israel Center, 35NIS incl. refreshments • Ezer
Kenegdo Matchmaking (02) 566-6039
Hold this date: January 10th
Special Shiur byHaRav Hershel Schachter on the halacha of "End of
Life Situations and Decisions" at Yeshurun Synagogue, Watch for
further details • Jointly sponsored bythe OU Israel Center, RCA,
Israel Council of Young Israel, Council of Young Israel Rabbis in
Israel, and Yeshiva University Alumni
OU ISRAEL CENTER
Seymour J. Abrams Orthodox Union Jerusalem World Center
Yitzchak Fund, President
Rabbi Emanuel Quint, Senior Vice President
Prof. Meni Koslowsky, Vice President
Sandy Kestenbaum, Vaad member
Rabbi Dovid Cohen, Vaad Member
Menachem Persoff, Director, Israel Center
Phil Chernofsky, Educational Director and TT editor
Ita Rochel Russek, Production Assistant and Advertising Manager,
Torah Tidbits
22 Keren Ha'Yesod POB 37015 Jerusalem 91370
Phone: (02) 566 7787 Fax: (02) 561-7432 email: tt@ou.org
websites: www.ou.org/torah/tt and www.ou.org/israel/ic
Orthodox Union • National Conference of Synagogue Youth
This publication and many of the programs of the Israel Center and
NCSY b'Yisrael are assisted by grants from The Jewish Agency for
Israel
TT is published and printed "in house" at the Israel Center
[The
Parshat To-l'dot Homepage]
[The TORAH tidbits Homepage] [How to use TORAH tidbits]
[About The OU/NCSY Israel Center] [About TORAH tidbits]
[www.ou.org]
