Torah tidbits
Special Features

Sukkot

What happened on the 15th?
Pesach is on the 15th of Nissan because on that day we left Egypt. Shavuot is 50 days later because on that day we received the Torah. Rosh HaShana corresponds to the sixth day of Creation, the day human beings were created. On Yom Kippur, Moshe brought G-d's message of forgiveness for the Sin of the Golden Calf. On the 25th of Kislev, we rested from our fight against the Greek enemy. Hence, we celebrate Chanuka from that date.

Purim is the 14th of Adar because something happened on that day. The same can be said for Tish'a b'Av and the other fast days related to the destruction of the Temples. Our modern dates of Yom HaAtzmaut and Yom Yerushalayim are on the dates that something momentous happened.
What happened on the 15th of Tishrei? And if there is nothing specific, then what is Sukkot doing specifically at this time of the year and on that date?
The Vilna Gaon gives a significance to the date. Later. Most others explain the time of the year, but not for the specific date.

Tur says that had the mitzva of Sukka been commanded at Pesach-time, it would not be noticeable that we are performing a mitzva; it would seem that we are merely seeking the comfortable environment of the Sukka in the warming springtime. On the other hand, when we leave our homes as others are returning to theirs in anticipation of cooler and wetter weather, the mitzva aspect of Sukka is manifest.

Rambam seems to take an opposite view, namely that the timing of Sukkot is a kind gesture by G-d - we dwell in the Sukka when it is neither too hot nor to cold to do so in an enjoyable manner. (A lot depends upon where you live - Eretz Yisrael is highly recommended.)

Ramban says that Sukkot is set at the other side of the year from Pesach to emphasize that we must appreciate G-d's having taken us out of Egypt and protecting us in the Wilderness - ALL YEAR ROUND. Pesach and Sukkot are each a 7-day commemoration of the Exodus, each begins on the 15th day of the first month of the year (both Nissan and Tishrei are first months).
Does the Sukka commemorate the Heavenly Clouds of Glory that protected Bnei Yisrael, or does it represent actual Sukkot in which the people dwelt...
If you say ACTUAL SUKKOT, then this is the season that the people would have begun to need them. Hence, Sukkot in the fall.

If you say CLOUDS OF GLORY, then, according to the Vilna Gaon, after Sin of the Golden Calf, the Clouds left the people. Only after the command to build the Mishkan, and after the materials were collected and the construction was about to begin, did the Clouds return. The GR"A says that this corresponded to the 15th of Tishrei, hence that date for Sukkot.

Menorat HaMaor suggests that the timing of Sukkot carries an important message for the (agrarian) Jew, who has just brought in the harvest and is about to tuck himself comfortably into his home for the winter. He would usually burst with pride at what he has accomplished. The mitzva of Sukka is perfect to bring the Jew out of his complacency and remind him - in the frail Sukka - of G-d's dominion over nature.

Chidushei HaRim explains the timing of Sukkot is "necessitated" by the reason given for the mitzva of Sukka - L'MAAN YEI'D'U DOROTEICHEM... In order that your generations shall KNOW... The level of KNOWLEDGE can be achieved best (or only) in an atmosphere that is sin-free, only immediately following the Yamim Nora'im. Our sources say that a person does not sin unless he is overcome by foolishness. Thus, we are capable of fulfilling the mitzva of Sukka best during the days following Yom Kippur.
One way or the other, we have the wonderful merit of celebrating Sukkot and fulfilling the mitzvot of Sukka the 4 species, and rejoicing on Yom Tov. May we celebrate the holiday with joy, may we fulfill the mitzvot of the Chag with proper kavana and motivations, and may we be privileged to rejoice in the rebuilding of Sukkat David HaNofelet.

What & Where

The Vilna Gaon points out that there are two mitzvot that a person fulfills with his whole self - Sukka and Eretz Yisrael. Both of these mitzvot are performed by "living", not just doing a specific act. One enters his Sukka and fulfills the mitzva. He makes Kiddush and HaMotzi and enjoys a sumptuous Yom Tov meal, and he continues to "get the mitzva". After Birkat HaMazon, he opens a sefer and learns in the Sukka and adds to the performance of the mitzva of Sukka. After learning for a while, he plays a game of chess with his child in the Sukka and is still performing the mitzva. Then he sits back in a comfortable chair and reads (a permitted) magazine article - and continues to fulfill the mitzva. And when he doses off and falls asleep, the person is still "getting" the mitzva. There is no other mitzva like this one. Except the mitzva of living in Eretz Yisrael. The Vilna Gaon cites the pasuk in T'hilim (76:3) as a "hint" to these two special, all-encompassing mitzvot. VAYEHI B'SHALEM" - What mitzvot are performed with "completeness"?, SUKO - the mitzva of Sukka, U'M'ONATO B'TZION - and when a person's place of residence is Eretz Yisrael. ASHREINU - happy and fortunate are we who are privileged to perform the mitzvot of Sukka and Yishuv Eretz Yisrael.

Simchat Beit Hasho'evah and Nisuch Hamayim by Catriel Sugarman
The popular celebrations of the Simchat Beit Hasho'evah - the Festival of the Water Drawing - were the most joyous times in the entire Temple calendar. The Talmud says, "He who has not seen the joy of the Simchat Beit Hasho'evah has never seen rejoicing in his life." These public celebrations were held during Chol Hamo'ed Sukkot in conjunction with Nisuch Hamayim (the water libation ritual). Nisuch Hamayim accompanied the Tamid (the morning daily sacrifice) and its obligatory Nisuch Hayayin (wine libation) every morning on Sukkot.

However, the festivities of the Simchat Beit Hasho'evah "override neither Shabbat nor Yom Tov"; they took place only during Chol Hamo'ed - the intermediate days of the festival. Therefore "on the eve of Shabbat, they used to fill a gold flagon… with water drawn from the Shiloach" (the spring south of Jerusalem) to use on Shabbat for Nisuch Hamayim without the usual festivities.

The validity of these two rites was a major point of contention between the Pharisaic Sages and the Sadducees who negated the authenticity of the Oral Tradition. During the course of the morning Tamid sacrifice, the Nisuch Hamayim was poured into one of two silver cups on the southwest corner of the top of the Altar. The Sages maintained that Nisuch Hamayim, even though it had no specific Biblical source, was an integral part of the Sukkot service and been orally revealed to Moses on Sinai. The Sadducees denied this. The Sadducees also opposed the accompanying celebrations of Simchat Beit Hasho'evah.

Nisuch Hamayim - coming right before the beginning of the rainy season - was seen as a silent entreaty for bountiful rain. The great Tanna R. Akiva, who lived after the Destruction of the Temple, conceived the water libation as a supplication. He pictured G-d saying, "Pour out water before Me on Sukkot, so your rains this year will be blessed." It is believed that the amount of rainfall for the coming year was determined on Sukkot.
Nisuch Hamayim - the Water Libation - was poured into one of two silver cups located on top of the southwest corner the Altar.

The celebrations of the Simchat Beit Hasho'evah started after the conclusion of the late afternoon daily Tamid - the last sacrifice of the day. Four colossal golden oil candelabra were positioned in the Temple Court; at night they shed enormous amounts of light. all over Jerusalem. The Mishna remarks that "There was not a courtyard in Jerusalem which was not illuminated by the light of the Simchat Beit Hasho'evah. The Gemara adds, "A woman could sift wheat" by the light of these candelabra.

The focus of the celebration was the fifteen semi-circular stairs and the open area immediately in front of them located on the western side of the Court of the Women. The Mishna in Midot describes these stairs, "Fifteen stairs led up from (The Court of the Women) to the Court of the Israelites, corresponding to the fifteen Songs of Ascents [Psalms 120-134] in T’hilim and upon them the Levites used to sing."

On either side of the stairs were rooms where the musical instruments were stored. (see picture)

While huge crowds watched the proceedings, only the spiritual leaders of the people - "men of piety and good deeds" were permitted to actually dance. They danced "with burning torches in their hands singing songs and praises" and were accompanied by "countless Levites with harps, lyres, cymbals, trumpets, and other musical instruments" who stood behind them on the stairs.

"They said of R. Simeon ben Gamliel that when he rejoiced at the time of the Simchat Beit Hasho'evah, he used to take eight lit torches (and throw them into the air) and catch one and throw one and they did not touch."
And what did these great sages say? "Some of them used to say, 'Happy is our youth which did not disgrace our old age." These were the men of piety and good deeds. Others used to say, "Happy is our old age which has atoned for (the sins of) our youth." These were the Ba'alei Teshuvah - the penitents. And all of them said, "Happy is he who has not sinned but let him who has sinned repent and He will forgive them."

Very early - at "cock-crow", kohanim opened the Nicanor Gates and sounded the trumpets (chatzotzrot); this signaled the conclusion of that night's celebrations. The kohanim descended the stairs and sounded the trumpet when they reached the tenth step and once again when they reached the level of the Court of the Women. As they continued eastward, the enormous crowd followed them.

"When they reached the Gate (of the Women's Court) which leads to the east, they turned their faces to the west (facing the Temple) and said, 'Our fathers when they were in this place stood with their backs towards the Temple of the Lord and their faces towards the east, and they worshiped the sun towards the east (Ez. 8: 16), but as for us, our eyes are turned towards the Lord."

When the procession reached the Shiloach, the kohanim sounded the trumpets and drew water into a golden flagon. When they returned to the Temple, they did not enter through the Court of the Women; instead they entered through the Sha'ar Hamayim - the Water Gate. Sha'ar Hamayim, usually closed, was located in close proximity to the Altar and was opened especially for these occasions to facilitate the entrance of the kohanim.

During the course of the morning Tamid sacrifice, to the accompaniment of trumpets, the kohein gadol (though it was not a requirement that he personally perform the rite) ceremoniously poured the water into the western of the two silver cups on the southwestern corner of the Altar. At the same, another kohein poured the daily Nisuch Hayayin (the wine libation) into the eastern cup.

The kohein gadol was required to hold the pitcher of water high above his head so the gathered assemblage could see that the libation was done properly. The people called out to the ministering kohein, "Raise your hand high!" This was necessary because once a Sadducee kohein gadol, who wanted to show his disdain for the Oral Traditions, beloved by the people, spilled the water on his feet instead of pouring it into the silver cup on the Altar. Both the Gemara and Josephus describe how the angry crowd pelted the contemptuous kohein gadol with their etrogim causing a riot! One may assume that afterwards Sadducean kohanim were more respectful!
May we be found worthy to participate in the celebrations of the Simchat Beit Hasho'evah and witness the Nisuch Hamayim in the rebuilt Beit Hamikdash. Amen.

Catriel gives illustrated lectures on the Beit Hamikdash and related topics. Call him at (02) 652-7531 or acatriel@netvision.net.il


[The Sukkot Homepage]
[The TORAH tidbits Homepage] [How to use TORAH tidbits]
[About The OU/NCSY Israel Center] [About TORAH tidbits]


The Torah Tidbits Archive