
SHABBAT PARSHAT
MATOT-MAS'EI (M'VORCHIM)
TT 526 -
26 TAMMUZ 5762 - July 5-6, '02
Pirkei Avot - Second Perek
| Last week
Pinchas was read all over the world. This week we all read
Matot-Mas’ei. Chutz LaAretz is still one behind us in Pirkei Avot;
they read the first perek |
Halachic Times for Jerusalem Israel Summer Time -
a.k.a. Daylight Savings Time
Correct for TT #526
Ranges are for THU-THU, 24 Tammuz - 2 Av, July 4-11
Candle lighting - 7:13pm
(Earliest (Plag) - 6:20pm)
Havdala - 8:32pm (Rabbeinu Tam - 9:15pm)
Earliest Shacharit 4:39-4:44am
Sunrise - 5:38-5:42
Sof Z'man Kri'at Sh'ma 9:10-9:13am (8:15-8:18am)
Sof Z'man Shacharit - 10:21-10:23am (9:44-9:47am)
Chatzot (halachic noon) • 12:43½-12:44½pm
Mincha Gedola (earliest Mincha) 1:20-1:20pm
Plag Mincha 6:20-6:19pm
Sunset 7:54-7:52pm (7:48½-7:47pm)
WORD OF THE MONTH
A weekly feature of Torah Tidbits to help clarify practical and conceptual
aspects of the Jewish Calendar, thereby better fulfilling the mitzva of
HaChodesh HaZeh Lachem...
We bench Rosh Chodesh AV on Shabbat Parshat MATOT-MA'SEI, June 6, '02
HAMOLAD Y'H'YEH B'YOM R'VI'I, ESRIM VASHEISH DAKOT U'SHEMONA CHALAKIM
ACHAREI CHAMEISH BABOKER
That's Wednesday, 26 minutes and 8 parts after 5 in the morning.
The Molad is on Wednesday (July 10th) 5h 26m 8p
In Rambam notation: R'VI'I • 11h • 476 chalakim
On the Clock WED July. 10, 6:05½pm (summer time)
Astronomical (actual) Molad (IST) - WED, July 10, 13:26:46
ROSH CHODESH MENACHEM AV Y'H'YEH B'YOM R'VI'I HABA ALEINU V'AL KOL YISRA'EL
L'TOVA
Rosh Chodesh Menachem Av will be on Wednesday
Let’s Get Back into Sync
We’re not referring to Parshat HaShavua. That’s a minor issue, and we took
care of it a couple of weeks ago. The bigger out-of-sync issue should be of
concern to each of us as individual Jews and as members of Klal Yisrael.
Parshat Pinchas (last week’s reading) represents a new
era in the early history of DOR HAMIDBAR, the generation of the Wilderness.
The “bad stuff” is behind them. The Meraglim Disaster, Korach’s rebellion,
repeated complaints about water and food, the Baal Peor episode — it’s all
behind them (us). Pinchas had good things in it: Pinchas’ reward, daughters
of Tzelafchad, daily korbanot and Musafim of Rosh Chodesh and the Holy days.
Matot and Mas’ei continue on the upswing: Successful war against Midyan,
cooperation between the people and the army, good news and wonderful gesture
by the officers, first stage of entry into Eretz Yisrael (before actual
entry) in the arrangement for the terri- tory on the east side of the
Jordan. (Even though Moshe’s first reaction was disappointment and anger
directed against the leaders of Reuven and Gad, the situation worked out
well in G-d’s eyes as well as for Moshe and the people.) Then, in Mas’ei, we
have the travelogue of the people, the exciting announcement of impending
entry into Eretz Yisrael, the description of the boundaries of Eretz Yisrael,
the list of the new leaders who will help settle the people in the Land, the
details of the cities for Levi, (IR MIKLAT, cities of refuge - not the most
pleasant of topics, but another indication of the practical living that
awaits the people when they will emerge from the cocoon of the Midbar), then
the amicable arrange- ment between the daughters of Tzelaf- chad and the
members of their Tribe.
Mas’ei and the book of Bamidbar end with the people of Israel armed with
Torah and mitzvot on the threshold of Eretz Yisrael.
But we are grossly out-of-sync with all of the above.
Look at the calendar. As we read these sedras, we enter the Three Weeks of
mourning for the destruction of Jerusalem and the Beit HaMikdash. We mark
the Sin of the Golden Calf and the Sin of the Spies, and the multitude of
sins that caused the Destructions and Exiles. And most significantly, our
apparent continued “devotion” to the same things that brought about our
downfalls.
So, in short, that is our challenge. Not just to mourn
the CHURBAN, but to become the people - individually and communally that
will bring us back in sync.
Sedra-Stats
Matot and Mas’ei are the most combined of the 7 sedra-pairs we have.They are
read separately in 13-month years which begin on Thursday. That accounts for
only 10.6% of years. In Eretz Yisrael (but not abroad), they are also
separated in 13-month years when Pesach begins on Shabbat. This happens 9.9%
of the years.
Matot Mas'ei M&M
of 54 sedras 42nd 43rd —
of 10 in Bamidbar 9th 10th —
lines in a Torah 190 189 379
rank 29 30 1
Parshiyot 9 8 17
P'tuchot 4 6 10
S'tumot 5 2 7
P'sukim 112 132 244
rank (Torah/Bam.) 24/7 12/5 1/1
Words 1484 1461 2945
rank 29/6 32/7 1/1
Letters 5652 5773 11425
rank 30/7 28/6 1/1
MITZVOT 2 6 8
positive 1 2 3
prohibitions 1 4 5
Drop in rank - p'sukim to words & letters - noticeable for Matot, severe for
Mas'ei - results from short p'sukim. P'sukim of Mas'ei are the shortest in
the whole Torah.
Aliya-by-Aliya Sedra Summary
[Numbers] refer to Sefer HaChinuch's mitzva-count
Kohen - First Aliya - 16+12=28 p'sukim - 30:2-31:12
"And Moshe spoke to the leaders of the Tribes of Israel..." The first
principle of the topic is that a person must fulfill the terms of a vow and
it is prohibited to "profane one's word" [407].
On the other hand, built into the Torah's laws are
procedures for release from vows. These procedures also constitute a mitzva,
known as HAFARAT N'DARIM [406]. A girl (12- 12½ yrs.) who vows can have her
vows nullified by her father (only on the day he hears of them). Similarly
(but with differences), a wife's vows can be nullified by her husband. (In
this case, only some vows, those which affect the husband are subject to his
nullification.)
MITZVA WATCH
In addition to HAFARAT N'DARIM, the nullification of a wife's or daughter's
vow by husband or father, there is another aspect of the mitzva, known as
HATARAT N'DARIM. This is the nullification of one's vows (those that
halachically CAN be nullified) by a Rav-expert in the laws of N'darim or a
panel of three dayanim (even laymen). Hatarat N'darim is a rare example of a
mitzva that is considered Torah law, although there is no clear supporting
text in the Written Word. The Mishna in Chagiga assures us that Hatarat
N'darim is no less a Torah concept because of the lack of a written source.
This is but another in a long series of demonstrations of the absolute
inseparableness of the Written Word and the Oral Torah.
G-d next commands Moshe to do battle against Midyan,
and then to prepare to die. Moshe drafts 1000 men from each tribe for the
task.
[SDT] Commentaries point out that the People were
reluctant to comply because they knew that Moshe would die shortly after
successful completion of the battle. Moshe, on the other hand,
enthusiastically complies with G-d's command, his personal interests to the
contrary, notwithstanding.
[SDT] The Chatam Sofer notes that when G-d commands
the battle against Midyan, He calls it NIKMAT BNEI YISRAEL, a revenge for
Israel's sake. When Moshe calls the people to battle, he refers to revenge
for G-d's honor. If the people would be fighting for their own honor, they
might forgo the battle and not hasten Moshe's end. But to avenge G-d's
honor, they dare not refuse.
Pinchas is sent as "chaplain". The 12,000 strong army
succeeded in killing all male Midyanites including 5 kings and Bil'am. The
women, children, herds, flocks, and possessions of Midyan were taken as
booty. The cities and palaces were destroyed. The army returned to the
Israelite camp at Arvot Moav.
Note: There is confusion among commentaries as to
whether the tribe of Levi sent a contingent to fight this war or not. If
they did, did Menashe and Efrayim combine as the tribe of Yosef, thereby
keeping the total number at 12000, or were there actually 13000 who fought.
Levi's probable involvement is due to the fact that the war was NOT for the
purpose of conquest of territory; had it been, Levi would not be directly
involved. If so, Menashe and Efrayim probably fought as the tribe of Yosef.
Levi - Second Aliya - 12+17+13=42 p'sukim - 31:13-54
Moshe, Elazar, and the tribal leaders went out to greet the returning army.
Moshe was angry that the officers kept the women of Midyan alive since it
was they who were instrumental in the downfall of Israel in the Pe'or affair
and the consequent plague. The women and male children were killed; the
girls remained captive. The soldiers were told to remain outside the camp
for seven days because of their ritual impurity as a result of the war.
Elazar HaKohen sets down the laws of purification of vessels.
Many of the details of "kashering" and "toveling" of vessels are derived
from here.
G-d tells Moshe to order a counting of the spoils of
war. The booty is to be divided equally between the soldiers on the one hand
and the People on the other. Taxes of 1/500 were imposed upon the soldiers.
Detailed itemization takes up many p'sukim of this portion.
And then the half that went to the people is itemized.
A tax of 1/50 (the standard amount for T'ruma) is imposed upon the people.
These taxes were turned over to Elazar HaKohen. Detailed itemization takes
up many more p'sukim.
The officers approach Moshe with more gifts of gold in
thanks to G-d for not losing even one person in battle.
Shlishi - Third Aliya - 19 p'sukim - 32:1-19
The tribes of Reuven and Gad (later joined by half of Menashe), heavily
laden with flocks of sheep, requested permission to settle on the east bank
of the Jordan River - land particularly suitable for grazing (as opposed to
Eretz Yisrael, where extensive sheep-grazing is a problem). Moshe's initial
reaction is intense anger, fearing that the request of the two tribes would
discourage the People of Israel from wanting to proceed into the Land,
repeating the experience of the "spies" of almost 40 years earlier. The key
objection on Moshe's part seems to be the potential negative effect on the
rest of the People. To this, the tribes replied that they would surely
accompany their brethren into Eretz Yisrael and not return to the east bank
until all is settled in the Land.
[SDT] In addition to the main "dressing down" that
Moshe gives Reuven and Gad, there is a more subtle rebuke on another issue.
The tribes offer to build corrals for their flocks and homes for their
children. Later, when Moshe gives them permission to establish themselves on
the east bank, he tells them to build homes for their children and
accommodations for their animals. Your children go first. Then your
property.
R'VI'I - Fourth Aliya - 23+10+39=72 p'sukim - 32:20-33:49
The fourth Aliya is always the BRIDGE Aliya between two sedras when they are
combined. This particular R’VI’I is THE longest Aliya in the Torah.
Moshe's response is the administration of an oath
(many details of the proper form of "conditions" are derived from this
famous oath of the 2½ tribes) agreeing to the request to settle on the east
side of the Jordan iff (if and only if - it's a real word; look it up) the
2½ tribes fight side by side with the others.
The Torah describes the cities that the 2½ tribes
established to settle their families and flocks prior to their crossing the
Jordan.
Perhaps the seemingly unnecessary details give us the
message that we are dealing with part of Eretz Yisrael, and not just
something extraterritorial.
The sedra of Mas'ei begins with a summary listing of
the 42 places of encampment during the years of wandering in the Wilderness.
Most places are just listed; a few are anecdoted. The present day identity
of many of these places is in dispute. This portion covers the Exodus from
Egypt (the city of Ra'm'ses), the passage thru the Sea, and the 3-day
journey that brought the People to Mara, with its "water problem" (and
solution). From there it was back to Yam Suf, before continuing into the
Wilderness.
Travelog
These are the places of encampment and some comments...
From Ra'm'ses to Sukkot to Eitam to Pi HaChirot to Mara to Eilim to Yam Suf
to Midbar Sin to Dafka to Alush to R'fidim to Midbar Sinai to Kivrot HaTaava
to Chatzeirot Ritma to Rimon Peretz to Livna to Risa to K'heilata to Har
Shefer to Charada to Mak'heilot to Tachat to Terach to Mitka to Chashmona to
Moseirot to Bnei Yaakan to Chor HaGidgad to Yotvata to Avrona to Etzion
Gever to Midbar Tzin (= Kadesh) to Hor HaHar to Tzalmona to Punon to Ovot to
I'yei HaAvarim to Divon Gad to Almon Divlatayma to Harei HaAvarim to Arvot
Moav.
G’matriya of RAAMSES = 430, the number of years from
the original prophecy to Avraham Avinu in the BRIT BEIN HA'B'TARIM until the
EXODUS (as in Sh'mot 12:40-41). The first stop out of Raamses is SUKKOT,
G'matriya = 480, the number of years from the Exodus until the building of
the First Beit HaMikdash - the arrival of the People EL HAMENUCHA V'EL
HANACHALA (D'varim 12:9). So just the first leg of the wandering represents
(numerically) the major first (and second) leg of the journey of Jewish
History.
The Midrash says that it was at ALUSH that the People
first received the Manna and where we spent our very first Shabbat. The
Manna was given to the People of Israel in the merit of our mother Sarah,
who was asked by Avraham to knead and bake cakes for the angels/guests. Her
enthusiastic providing of food for others was repaid by G-d, Who provided
food for Sarah's children more than 400 years later. The name ALUSH is a
play on the word "I will knead".
RITMA was the place from which the spies were sent,
and therefore the place where the decree to wander the wilderness was
pronounced. One can imagine a qualitative difference in the mental attitude
during the first 14 encampments as compared to those following Ritma.
CHASHMONA was the 25th resting place of the People.
Centuries later, there was a resting (from battle) on the 25th (of Kislev).
The people through whom G-d wrought the miracles of Chanuka were the
Chashmona'im. This is considered one of the "hints" to Chanuka from the
Torah.
Rashi points out that with 14 places before the decree
to wander, and with 8 places in the final year, there were only 20 places
that the People moved to and from in 38 years or so. That is not really all
that much. G-d was merciful with the People even as He was punishing them.
Chamishi - Fifth Aliya - 22 p'sukim - 33:50-34:15
G-d speaks to Moshe in Arvot Moav and commands the People to enter, conquer,
acquire, and settle the Land. The boundaries of the Land are detailed. These
boundaries are now for the 9½ tribes, since Reuven, Gad and half of Menashe
have claimed their allotments on the East Bank.
In G-d's original promise to Avraham Avinu, the land
to be given to his descendants was to be "from the Egyptian River until the
great river, P'rat". The boundaries described in this week's sedra contain a
territory significantly smaller than that which was promised. Our Sages tell
us that the original promise includes territory to be added to Eretz Yisrael
in the future, in the times of the Moshiach.
Shishi - Sixth Aliya - 14+8=22 p'sukim - 34:16-35:8
Next the Torah lists the new leaders of the tribes who will be in charge of
the "Divine lottery" by which the Land will be apportioned.
[SDT] Note that the first 3 tribes mentioned do not
have the word NASI (leader) mentioned - the others all do. One commen- tary
suggests that it was unnecessary to identify Calev b. Yefuneh as a leader -
that is well- known. The tribe of Shimon does not deserve to have a leader
with the title NASI because of the Zimri affair. Binyamin's leader was Eldad
(here called Elidad - according to the Baal HaTurim, the extra YUD
represents Prophecy, which has 10 different names), a person who already had
the higher title of Prophet.
Following the general plans for dividing the Land, the
People are instructed to provide cities for the Leviyim [408], since they (Leviyim)
do not receive Land as inheritance. The cities and their surrounding areas
number 48, including the 6 cities of refuge.
Note that the measure of 2000 amot as "city limit" was
subsequently borrowed by the Sages in fixing the distance outside the
dwelling place that a person may walk on Shabbat, known as T'CHUM SHABBAT.
These cities, to be given by the tribes to the Leviyim,
were given proportional to the populations of the tribes.
Sh'vi'i - Seventh Aliya - 26+13=39 p'sukim - 35:9-36:13
The cities of refuge (and the other 42 Levite cities,with some differences)
serve to protect the inadvertent killer. Even a murderer flees to a
protecting city pending trial.
It is forbidden to kill a murderer until he stands trial and is found guilty
[409].
The inadvertent killer is sent - or he flees - to a
city of refuge [410]. The Torah presents guidelines for defining murder and
inadvertent killing and sets down some of the court procedures, such as the
prohibition of a witness also acting as judge in a criminal case [411]. We
are also warned not to permit substitute punishments for a murderer [412]
and the inadvertent killer [413]. Strict adherence to all rules of justice
assure us continued "quality living" in Eretz Yisrael, accompanied by the
Divine Presence.
MITZVA WATCH
Mitzvot 412 and 413 basically command us to follow other mitzvot in the
Torah that require a convicted murder to be executed and a convicted SHOGEG-
killer to be exiles to a City of Refuge. How unusual for the Torah to do
that. The small Sanhedrins of 23 judges, whose jurisdiction it is to carry
out the commands of the Torah in matters of “sentencing” for certain
crimes/sins are duty-bound to comply with halacha.
Why does the Torah feel, so to speak, that it must
reinforce (if that is what 412 and 413 are doing) these two areas of court-mitzvot?
The answer can be illustrated by the absurd story of
the Wise Men of Chelm who were about to convict the town’s tailor to a term
of imprisonment when someone raised the question of who would do the
tailoring in the town during his absence. After due deliberation, the Wise
Men decided to send one of the town’s two shoemakers to prison instead of
the tailor. This way, the different needs of the townsfolk would be seen to.
Although we see the absurdity in that whimsical story,
the following scenario is much less absurd. A city’s leading surgeon was
playing golf (no doubt on a Wednesday) in Caesaria. He missed a crucial putt
and in utter frustration, he throws his putter high in the air. It falls
right on an onlooker’s head and kills him instantly. The golfer-doctor is
brought before a Beit Din (23 judges, remember) and after thorough examina-
tion of the witnesses, it is deter- mined that the good doctor is a
ROTZEI’ACH B’SHOGEG, an inadvertant, but contrib- utorily negligent, killer.
The “proper” pro- cedure according to the Law of the Torah is to send the
doctor to a City of Refuge until the death of the Kohein Gadol. The mayor
and city council members approach the judges and express their great
concern. The doctor has a world-famous reputation for his skill as a
surgeon. So much so, that the doctor has been a tremendous asset to the
city, drawing patients and their families to the city from all over Israel
and the world. The city would lose a good deal of prestige, not to mention
financial income if they lose the doctor.
Okay, how about this. He was respon- sible for the
death of another human being. He didn’t kill him on purpose, but he was
reckless. And he must be punished. So I suggest, says the mayor with the
backing of most council members, that we put the doctor under house arrest
right here in our city. We’ll provide him with an apartment on the grounds
of the hospital and we will further require him to donate his fees from
surgery to charity.
Logical. Reasonable. Very tempting. Afterall, he won’t
get away free for what he did. He will be punished. But in a way that will
benefit the city, rather than hurt it. So why not?
Mitzva 413 is WHY NOT. G-d, so to speak, anticipated
these temptations to be a little self-servingly “flexible”. No go. There are
discretionary powers given to our human courts, but not this time. We don’t
have the whole picture; only G-d does. We might not understand to effect of
specific punishments on the soul of the person. But the soul is involved,
and we are forbidden to tamper with matters that we cannot understand. This
is part of why the Torah has to command the court these “extra” mitzvot.
Leaders of the family of Menashe to which the daughters of Zelofchad belong,
approach Moshe and raise the problem of potential erosion of their tribal
allotment if Zelofchad's daughters marry outside their tribe, taking their
land with them. Moshe issues a ruling restricting them from marrying outside
their tribe. This is not a law in perpetuity; it applies only in this case.
In compliance, Machla, Tirza, Chogla, Milka, and No'a marry Menashe-ites.
The Book of BaMidbar ends with the statement, "These
are the Mitzvot and the Laws that G-d commanded Moshe to (transmit to) Bnei
Yisrael, in Arvot Mo'av on the Jordan (Jericho) River."
MITZVA WATCH
Ramban sites Bamidbar 34:52,53 as the source of the mitzva in the Torah to
dwell in Israel - a mitzva that he says applies today, even in times of
exile. Ramban counts this mitzva as one of the 613 mitzvot of the Torah. (It
is known as Ramban's Fourth Mitzva.) Rambam does not count Yishuv Eretz
Yisra'el among the Taryag. This does not mean that Rambam does not consider
it a mitzva to live in Eretz Yisrael. He echoes the Talmud in saying that "a
person should always choose to live in Israel, even in a city with a
majority of idol worshippers, rather than live outside of Israel, even in a
predominantly Jewish city". He writes that a person who lives elsewhere is
like one who has no G-d. Some commentaries explain that since living in
Eretz Yisrael is the necessary basis of fulfilling a whole category of
mitzvot, then one would not count living in Israel as one of the 613. It
includes many other mitzvot; therefore it does not fulfill the specific
criteria for being numbered among Taryag. It is, nonetheless, an imperative
of the Torah.
Ramban adds that not only are there mitzvot that
"depend upon the Land", but ALL mitzvot are able to be completely fulfilled
ONLY in Eretz Yisrael. One must do mitzvot elsewhere, primarily as practice
to the proper performance of mitzvot in Eretz Yisrael.
In Ramban's treatment of the mitzva to live in Eretz
Yisrael, there is another factor, which is an integral part of the mitzva.
And that is, that we are forbidden to allow any part of the Land to be
uninhabited, nor may we leave it in the hands of non-Jews.
Last 3 p'sukim are reread for the Maftir.
Haftara - 28 p'sukim - Yirmiyahu 2:4-28, 3:4, (4:1-2)
This is the second of the three Tragic Haftaras read between the 17th of
Tammuz and Tish'a b'Av. It is the continuation of last week's haftara. In
fact, these two haftaras are the only continuous portions of the Prophets
read as haftaras on consecutive weeks. G-d, speaking through the prophet,
chastises the People of Israel for the terrible double sin of forsaking Him
AND turning to gods who are nothing- ness. Repeatedly, we are asked how it
was possible that we turned away from G-d so. Terrible punishment for this
betrayal of G-d is prophesied. The haftara ends on the hopeful note that if
we return to G-d, then He will return to us and restore His special
relationship with us.
THE JERUSALEM INSTITUTE OF JEWISH LAW
Rabbi Emanuel Quint, Dean
Lesson # 143 • PARTNERS (part 1)
With this lesson we embark on a new topic, a topic with which so many people
have been involved in during their lives, a partnership. Many professionals
and businessmen have conducted their practices and businesses as
partnerships. The average consumer is also very often involved with
partnerships, since the store where she shops may be owned by a partnership
and if there are any claims against the seller it may be against a
partnership. The medical practice where the person is treated may be owned
by a partnership. A person's stockbroker may advise him to invest in a
limited type partnership that invests in real estate. The possibilities are
many.
How does halachah treat a partnership? This lesson and
some of the following lessons shall try to explain how halachah relates to
the partnership. Following the requests that I receive by email and in
person from the readers of this column, I shall proceed slowly and simply in
these lessons, without taking anything for granted.
The author of the Shulhan Aruch, Rabbi Yosef Karo
(1488-1575) in Shulhan Aruch Hoshen haMishpat. begins the laws of
partnership with chapter 176, and these laws continue there through chapter
181. We thus see that he devotes six chapters to this topic.
This lesson commences with a discussion of how a
partnership is organized, that is, what binds Reuven and Shimon, the
partners, to each other in the partnership so that neither partner may state
that the partnership never existed or that he no longer wants to be in the
partnership.
Some of the questions that we will be discussing are:
If the parties have failed to stipulate their share in the profits and
losses and they invested disproportionate amounts, how do they share the
profits and losses? What if Shimon delays his investment and Reuven has
commenced operations, does Shimon share in the profits? What fiduciary duty
does each partner owe to the other or to the partnership? What actions may
each partner take on behalf of the partnership, and what if there is a
dispute as to actions to be taken? How is a partnership terminated and how
are the assets divided? What is to be done with accounts receivable and
accounts payable? How should the partners collect debts from third-party
debtors; may one partner sue on behalf of all the partners? These are but a
few of the topic to be covered by these lessons. Some of these questions can
and should be answered by written agreements between the partners,
preferably written by lawyers. (As an aside, I get lots of calls from people
seeking legal advice and I usually tell them all that they should consult a
lawyer. But the thing that they find most startling is when I say that each
party should have his or her own lawyer. A lawyer should not represent both
parties, although this absurd situation does sometimes exist in Israel.)
Some of the questions that I shall IYH deal with in
these lessons are matters that occasionally come before our Beth Din.
As is seen in lessons 50, 51 and 52 (Torah Tidbits
432, 433, and 434) there are definite procedures to be followed to make a
contract binding on the parties to the contract. There are similar
procedures to bind the partners to each other. Otherwise. any partner could
at any time leave the partnership.
The great codifiers and authorities describe three
primary methods to bind partners to each other, and several subsidiary
methods.
There is the view of Maimonides (Rabbi Moses b. Maimon.
Rambam. Spain, Egypt, 1135-1204) that mere words, even accompanied by a
kinyan, cannot bind persons to each other, whether in a contract or in a
partnership. The words of Maimonides (herein loosely translated) appear in
his Laws of Agents and Partners, chapter 4, law #1.
"When people desire to form a partnership, in what
manner does each partner acquire title to the money of the other partner so
that he also has an ownership in the money? If the partnership is one
entailing the investment of money, each places his money into one purse and
both lift the purse. However, if they [merely] write a document and [even
if] witnesses testify regarding it, and even if a kinyan was made whereby
each bound himself to bring 100 [coins of the realm] and the other will
bring 100 [coins of the realm] and that they will thereby become joint
owners, they have not acquired [each the money of the other] and they are
still not partners, because money cannot be acquired by a kinyan. If they
enter into a partnership with chattels, then they can bind each other by
each performing a kinyan; for example, one binds himself that he will bring
to the partnership a barrel of wine and the other that he will bring to the
partnership a jug of honey. Also if they mix their produce or if they
jointly rent a place and one partner places his barrel of wine there and the
other places his jug of honey there, they become partners in the business of
selling wine and honey. If craftsmen enter into a partnership in their craft
they are not partners even if each binds himself with a kinyan. Therefore,
if two tailors or weavers agree that whatever each one makes will be owned
by them as partners, they are not partners since a person cannot transfer
title to things not yet in existence. However, if they purchase cloth with
their funds and sew it into garments and sell the garments, or if they
purchase thread with their funds and weave it into cloth and sell it, they
are partners.
Even according to the view of Maimonides, once a
partnership has been properly organized it continues without having to make
a proper kinyan for each new transaction."
The term "kinyan" has been mentioned by Maimonides
here and I have used the term in many of the lessons and I did from time to
time define the term "kinyan". I was at a wedding a few weeks ago and was
asked by the rabbi performing the wedding to be a witness to the kethubah. I
asked the rabbi if the groom knew the contents of the kethubah since he was
undertaking to be bound by its terms. The rabbi said it was late and mumbled
something about shekiah and he didn't have the time to tell the groom. I
respectfully declined to serve as a witness to say that the groom when, he
made a kinyan, knew what he was doing. A few weeks after that I was asked to
be a witness to the tena'im document at a wedding. The officiating rabbi was
Rav Wollici and he did everything according to what was required. The
respective fathers were told by him the contents of the tena'im document and
they each performed a kinyan binding themselves to its terms.
In simple terms the term "kinyan" be defined as
follows:
A kinyan is a method whereby an obligor or a person
who undertakes to do something legally obligates himself. For example. A, a
painter undertakes to paint the house of B the home owner, and B obligates
to pay A $100 if he paints his house. In halachah these mutual promises are
not binding. Thus even if A paints the house, B need not pay for it. (He may
have to pay a smaller amount for benefit received) However, if a kinyan is
made, then the promises are binding on the parties. The easiest and most
common method of kinyan is the transference to the obligor (the person
making the promise) of a handkerchief belonging to the obligee (the person
to whom the promise is made), or belonging to some other person present,
such as the lawyer or witness. Thus when A gives his handkerchief to Band B
accepts it, B undertakes to pay to A $100 when A paints B's house. When B
gives his handkerchief to A and A accepts it. A undertakes to paint B's
house. Both are bound. "Kinyan" is also a method of acquiring things real
estate of chattels, but that is not within the scope of this lesson.
The subject matter of this lesson is more fully
discussed in Volume VI Chapter 176 of "A Restatement of Rabbinic Civil Law"
byE. Quint, published by Jason Aronson, Inc. and on sale at local Judaica
bookstores.
Questions to quint@inter.net.il
MEANING IN MITZVOT by Rabbi Asher Meir
Each week we discuss one familiar halakhic practice and try to show its
beauty and meaning. The columns are based on Rabbi Meir's Meaning in Mitzvot
on Kitzur Shulchan Arukh.
Avoiding Litigation during AV
The Shulchan Arukh states that since the beginning of Av is a time of bad
fortune for the Jews, it is best to put off litigation with non-Jews until
after the ninth of Av, at the very least (Orach Chaim 551:1). We can easily
see why days of ill fortune are a bad time to travel or engage in some other
dangerous activity, as we explained last week. But regarding a court case,
shouldn't the bad luck balance out? Why does our bad fortune translate into
good fortune for the non-Jewish litigant? Conversely, since Adar is a month
of good fortune, it is a good time to adjudicate with a Gentile (Mishna
Berura 686:8), hinting that our good fortune is correlated with our
opponent's bad fortune.
We can find the source for this "see-saw" idea in the Torah. When Rivka
suffers from her pregnancy, she learns through prophecy that each of her
twins will found a great nation, and "nation will contend with nation" (Bereshit
25:23). Rashi (based on Megilla 6a) explains that "they will never be equal
in greatness; when one rises up the other falls".
Yet there is another source that suggests the
opposite. The Torah says that HaShem is solicitous of the land of Israel,
that He seeks out its good (Devarim 11:12). Rashi (based on Sifri) explains
that when blessing the world, God blesses first the Land of Israel, and via
the land of Israel He blesses the rest of the world. The Sifri goes on to
mention that when the Psalm says that HaShem watches over the people of
Israel (Tehillim 121:4), it means He first watches over us, but for our sake
He watches all of mankind. Not only does our good fortune not contradict the
fortune of the nations - it is the basis for it!
We can resolve this paradox by distinguishing between
greatness and blessing. Any number of nations can each be blessed or
protected, but only one can have greatness or leadership. Each individual,
and each nation, has a special contribution - artistic, scientific,
political, etc. - to make to humanity. These contributions are very
important, but they can not give meaning to life on the level of mankind as
a whole.
When Israel is exalted - when the greatness, the
direction in which humanity is going, is defined by spirituality - then all
of these faculties are blessed through the blessing of Israel, and humanity
ascends spiritually and materially. But when mankind is drawn to worship
something else, worshiping power, or wealth, or beauty, then spirituality
will necessarily be in decline. A person can serve God and wield power, but
he can not serve God and serve power.
Av, the month when the power-hungry Babylonians and
later Romans destroyed our Temple, symbolizes for us the ascendancy of
material concerns over spiritual ones. This is a time for avoiding
confrontation, which then takes on the character of petty rivalry.
Adar, the month when the faith and integrity of Esther
and Mordekhai and the Jewish people who united to pray for them overcame the
evil designs of the gluttonous Persians, symbolizes the ascendancy of spirit
over matter.
Then we are confident that even our petty legal
matters are subservient to a higher spiritual purpose.
Rabbi Meir has completed writing a monumental
companion to Kitzur Shulchan Aruch which beautifully presents the meanings
in our mitzvot and halacha. It will hopefully be published in the near
future.
Rabbi Meir authors a popular weekly on-line Q&A
column, "The Jewish Ethicist", which gives Jewish guidance on everyday
ethical dilemmas in the workplace. The column is a joint project of the JCT
Center for Business Ethics, Jerusalem College of Technology - Machon Lev;
and Aish HaTorah. You can see the Jewish Ethicist, and submit your own Qs —
www.jewishethicist.com or www.aish.com
From the virtual desk of the OU VEBBE REBBE
The Orthodox Union – via its website – fields questions of all types in
areas of kashrut, Jewish law and values. Some of them are answered by Eretz
Hemdah, the Institute for Advanced Jewish Studies, Jerusalem, founded by
HaRav Shaul Yisraeli, zt"l to prepare rabbanim and dayanim to serve the
National Religious community in Israel and abroad. Ask the Rabbi is a joint
venture of the OU, Yerushalayim Network, Eretz Hemdah... and the Israel
Center. The following is a Q&A from Eretz Hemdah...
Q Is it permitted to make a bar-mitzva during the Nine Days (before Tisha
B'Av )?
A The meal held in honor of a bar-mitzva is considered
a seudat mitzva (a meal of which it is a mitzva to partake) (Yam Shel
Shalom, Bava Kama, ch. 7, siman 37). His main source is Kiddushin 31a, in
reference to a statement by the blind amora, Rav Yosef. Rav Yosef said that
if he would be convinced that the blind are obligated in mitzvot, he would
make a seuda for his colleagues, because one who is commanded in mitzvot
receives more reward for their fulfillment. If a celebration is in place
just for finding out that one has always been obligated, all the more so is
it appropriate when the obligations begin, when one becomes a bar-mitzva.
Other sources in Chazal include Bereishit Rabba 53:10. This is certainly so
when the party is held on the Jewish birthday itself (assuming the boy is
sufficiently physically developed, which we are not required to check). The
Magen Avraham (225:4) rules that even a bar-mitzva that is not on the
birthday can be considered a seudat mitzva if the bar-mitzva boy publicly
says diveri Torah. The apparent logic is that those present are reminded
that this boy is indeed involved in the study of Torah, as he is now
commanded, and they feel the cause for celebration.
It is permitted to partake of meat and wine at a
seudat mitzva even during the week of Tisha B'Av (Rama, Orach Chaim 551:5),
and this ruling should apply to a bar-mitzva as well (Yad Ephraim, ad loc.).
Some want to learn from the Shulchan Aruch's silence on the matter that he
does not allow meat at a seudat mitzva during the week of Tisha B'Av (see
Kaf Hachaim, OC 551:33). However, most poskim are lenient in the matter even
for Sephardim. Even a delayed bar-mitzva with divrei Torah may be done
during the Nine Days, but it should not be delayed for that purpose (Yad
Ephraim, ibid; Kaf Hachaim. Ibid:158).
During the first part of the Nine Days, one may invite
whomever they would normally invite to the seuda, but people who just happen
to be around may not take part in the meat and wine. During the week of
Tisha B'Av, one should invite only reasonably close relatives and a small
group of friends (Rama, ibid; Taz, ad loc.: 12); Mishna Berura, ad loc: 77).
Some suggest serving fish and thereby removing the complication this
situation raises. Others are lenient with the guest list even on the week of
Tisha B'Av (Maharam, quoted in Taz, ibid; Yalkut Yosef pg. 568; see Aruch
Hashulchan 551:30), and there is room to rely upon those opinions.
Participants at permitted bar-mitzva celebrations at
this time may sing, but neither live nor recorded music should be played.
Receiving an aliya to the Torah and the accompanying
ceremonies in shul on Shabbat are not problematic (see Igrot Moshe, Orach
Chayim IV, 112.1).
This response is based on a teshuva in Bemareh Habazak III, 61.
Hasidic Wisdom from the book by Simcha Raz (Elkins/Elkins)
Every pleasure comes directly from Heaven — even jokes and quips — but only
if they are told out of honest joy.
— Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz
One must dance each and every day — whether in thought
or in action.
— Rabbi Nachman of Bratslav
It is easy for me to understand how a person without
income is able to survive. For such a one survives by Faith and Trust in
G-d.
But what I do not understand is: How does a person who has ample income
survive?
— Rabbi Simcha Bunam of Pshis’cha
Rite & Reason by Shmuel Pinchas Gelbard
It is the practice of Yemenite Jews (and in some circles of other EIDOT) to
read the SH’MA out loud and in unison.
Reason: This is in accordance with the end of Midrash
Shir HaShirim Rabba: “The one who dwells in the gardens [Yisrael], collegues
who listen” (Shir HaShirim 8:13) — when Yisrael enters its shuls and reads
the Sh’ma with proper KAVANA (intention), in one voice (with one mind), G-d
says to them: “You who dwell in the gardens, when you read together as
friends, I and My holy host hearken to your voice.” But when Yisrael reads
the Sh’ma in a fragmented, torn state of mind, one preceding [the other],
one delaying, and are not reciting the Sh’ma harmoniously, the Holy Spirit
cries out and says: “Flee, you who love Me and become like a deer.” [A play
on the word TZVI (deer), here meaning TZAVA (army).] Become like a deer and
go to [and learn from] the Army above, who utters praise for HaShem’s glory
in one voice and in one melody.
ArtScroll Series • Mesorah Publications Ltd.
WORDS OF WISDOM WORDS OF WIT by Shmuel Himelstein
R’ Yisrael Salanter was once learning Torah when a man came in and to ask
him a halachic question. R’ Yisrael answered promptly and the man left.
Immediately after- wards, those present saw that R’ Yisrael was very
troubled. One of those close to him finally asked what was bothering him.
"As I was speaking to the man”, replied R’ Yisrael, “I
noticed that there was a tear in my jacket sleeve and that upset me. Then I
thought to myself, ‘If that is how I feel when I meet a fellow human being
when there is a tear in my sleeve, how much more humiliated will I feel when
I meet my Maker with all the tears and stains in my soul?’”
MA RABU MA'ASECH HASHEM KULAM B'CHOCHMA ASITA MAL'AH HA'ARETZ KINYANECHA
Several years ago, we had a MRMHKBAMHK feature in Torah Tidbits. The
unlikely title of the column was (and is) the initial letters of T’hilim
104:24, which marvels at the variety of G-d’s handiwork and acknowledges the
Divine Wisdom with which each one was created. For those who questioned the
“validity” of including the platypus, echidna, and pangolin in Torah
Tidbits, let me relate a story and a lesson I’ll never forget. About 35
years ago, I had the privilege of having a biology professor at Yeshiva
University by the name of William Etkin, z”l. One of the courses I took with
him was Comparative Vertebrate Anatomy. And it is at 6:00pm on some day,
sitting in the lab in the basement of Furst Hall, that this story takes
place. About 25 students are sitting over dissecting pans waiting to cut
into a 12-inch dogfish shark. Before each dissection, we studied the
external features of the specimen, and so Dr. Etkin was quizzing us on the
different kinds of fins: pectoral, lateral, caudal, and the famous (from
movies such as Jaws) dorsal fin. Then he calls our attention to that which
we all knew well from preparing for this lab session — the shark’s placoid
scales. “Wait a minute”, Dr. Etkin exclaimed in mock surprise, “If sharks
have fins and scales, then they must be kosher!” “No!”, we all protested as
one, “sharks aren’t kosher.” “But you can see for yourselves that this shark
has fins and scales”, he continued, “so what’s the story here?” After
several lame attempts to explain why sharks aren’t kosher, even though they
have scales and fins, Dr. Etkin Etkin proceeded to slam his fist on the lab
table and say, “Yeshiva boys! What happened to you at 2:45pm this afternoon
when you davened Mincha and finished your long morning of Judaic studies.
Tell me the truth — last night when you were studying the dissection manual
and you read the words SHARK, SCALES, FINS over and over again, did it dawn
on any of you to ask the question about the kashrut status of a shark?” He
wasn’t asking us to explain why a shark is not kosher even though it has
scales and fins. He was asking us if any of us thought of the question. None
of us had. And that turned Dr. Etkin’s question into a haskafa-indictment of
sorts. Why hadn’t any of us thought of the question? It was begging to be
asked. His point was that Jewish studies should never be compartmentalized.
A Jew’s mind should be open and tuned in to Torah ALL THE TIME, when he has
a Gemara in front of him as well as when he is studying science or history
or secular literature... anything. Other things can be organized into one’s
mental compartments, but not Torah.
Next part of the story. (We’ll get back to the answer
to the shark-question later; it’s less important that the hashkafa statement
being made.) Pirkei Avot, third chapter, a statement by R’ Yaakov or R’
Shimon (versions vary). HA-M’HALEICH BADERECH V’SHONEH... One who is walking
down the road and is involved in Torah learning (reviewing some Torah
material in his mind, perhaps), U’MAFSIK MIMISHNATO... and he interrupts his
learning... and says, What a beautiful tree, what a beautiful field — the
pasuk considers that he put his life in jeopardy. The basic explanation for
this statement is that Torah learning is paramount, and one thus engaged
must not be distracted, even to admire nature. Another understanding of this
mishna came to me in relation to my story with Prof. Etkin. The key word is
U’MAFSIK and he interrupts.
Admiration of nature as G-d’s handiwork is a positive
thing in life (though not during Torah learning). However, when the study
and appreciation of nature is an interruption of one’s Torah learning – and
living – then such a compartmentalizing does indeed put one’s life in
jeopardy. This spin on the mishna, although I thought it was my own, can be
found in Ethics from Sinai by Irving M. Bunim. I remember being a little
disappointed that my “original” thought wasn’t my own, but then it was nice
to find confirmation for it in such an outstanding commentary on Pirkei Avot.
And so, dear TT reader, that is why I will introduce
the echidna along side a Rashi on Chumash, the wombat together with a lesson
in Jewish Civil Law, the bandicoot with Meaning in Mitzvot, and even the
Fibonacci Series side-by-side a Ramban on Yishuv Eretz Yisrael. (Fibonacci
and the Ramban were late 12th and early 13th century contemporaries,
although it is unlikely – but not impossible – that they were aware of each
other’s existence.)
“Yes indeedee!” - William Etkin z”l Y'HIY ZICHRO BARUCH
In going from youth to adulthood, we sometimes barter elusive inspiration
for secure substantiality. This is yet another instance of the trading of
the birthright for the bowl of pottage. From A Candle by Day by Shraga
Silverstein
G'MATRIYA MATCH
As if to “confirm” the togetherness of Matot and Mas’ei (see page 23), it
happens to be that the G’matiriya of the first pasuk of each of these two
sedras is the same (3324).
From the Desk of the Director
Parshat Masei describes the journeys of Bnei Yisrael in the wilderness. In
all there were 42 encampments: fourteen in the first year, eight in the
fortieth year, and twenty in the intervening thirty-eight years - a sign,
notes Rashi, of Hashem's compassion on the people.
When Bnei Yisrael set off on their journeys, in what
spirit did they do so? For one can leave a place out of boredom and disdain
or see the move as a positive step forward on an ongoing spiritual mission.
These conflicting approaches are reflected in the strange repetitive
language of the passuk: "Moshe wrote their 'goings forth' according to their
journeys… and these were their 'journeys' according to their goings forth" (B'midbar
33:2).
The same idea is repeated but the order is reversed.
R. Hirsch observes that the first phrase "goings forth" expresses the
journeys as seen from on High: Hashem wanted Bnei Yisrael to progress to the
next stages in His Divine plan. However, from the impatient people's
perspective, what counted were "their journeys" and the attendant
adventures.
In truth, all the 42 journeys should be seen in their
entirety. Ramban notes that the number 42 alludes to the mystical 42-letter
name of G-d. 42 is MEM-BET. So when we say daily, "Vedirbata BaM...
Uv'lechtecha Vaderech" - 'Speak about them…when you are going on your way' -
we are really saying that our entire life is a journey filled with the
secrets of Hashem.
Shabbat Shalom, Menachem Persoff, Director, Israel Center
Towards better Davening and Torah reading
Column #34. Contents of this weekly column are based on the sefer: EIM
LAMIKRA HASHALEIM, by R' Nissan Sharoni, Ashdod, a guide to correct
pronunciation of Hebrew, specifically in davening and Torah reading.
Last week’s column ended thus:
BIRCHOT HASHACHAR: Here’s an interesting one. First bracha. la-SECH-vi (MIL’EIL),
not la-sech-VI. [Ed. note: Checked several Siddurim. Many don’t indicate
accents. Some do. Found la-SECH-vi a few times. Rinat Yisrael seems to
disagree. They have la-sech-VI. Waiting for reader feedback to enlighten or
further muddle the point.]
The word after la-SECH-vi is MILRA, bi-NA. It’s easier
to say it the Rinat Yisrael way (if it is correct) - la-sech-VI bi-NA (both
words MILRA). But that doesn’t mean it’s right that way. We’ll await the
final verdict.
First of all, the easy part. The second word in the
phrase loses the DAGESH in the BET and is vi-NA, not bi-NA. (And not VI-na
either.)
Now for the SECHVI issue. Thanks to two readers - YL
and SL - who pointed me in the right direction. The word SECHVI appears once
in Tanach, in Iyov 38:36 to be specific. In fact, the phrase in the first of
Birchot HaShachar, the morning brachot, comes from that pasuk, where it is
in the form of a rhetoric question: ...MI NATAN LASECHVI VINA? Who gave the
SECHVI understanding, reasoning, intuition (different translations of BINA).
Okay, what’s a SECHVI? Good question. Very good
question. Rashi and other commentaries say that SECHVI is the rooster, and
that it also is the person’s heart or mind, the place where thoughts are
formed. Targum on the pasuk has two versions: LIBA, heart and TARNIGOL,,
rooster. No help there. In the context of the pasuk in Iyov, it seems likely
to translate SECHVI as the mind or heart, rather than rooster. Who has put
wisdom in the inward parts (of the person) or who has given understanding to
the mind? Rooster doesn’t fit well there.
This does not yet relate to the morning bracha. But
we’ll get there soon. Pronunciation of SECHVI in the Iyov pasuk is MIL’EIL -
SECH-vi. And if you look in a modern Hebrew dictionary, where the “main”
definition is rooster (and some will refer to the other translation), the
pronunciation is MILRA, sech-VI.
If this is so, that rooster is sech-VI and heart/mind
is SECH-vi, then the pronunciation in the bracha will depend on what the
word means in that context. (And if the different accenting is not a
function of the meaning of the word, then we’re back to the proverbial
square one.)
Rambam, for example, says (in Hilchot T’fila) that
when one hears a rooster crow, he should say the bracha HANOTEIN LASECHVI
VINA... That’s pretty straightforward that SECHVI means rooster. On the
other hand, the TUR states clearly that SECHVI means HEART and that the
bracha acknowledges and thanks G-d for our powers of reasoning and
understanding, AND since SECH- VI also means rooster, our Sages connected
the bracha to hearing of the rooster in the morning.
R’ Chaim Donin (To Pray as a Jew) writes that the
bracha acknowledges our HEARING, just as POKEI’ACH IVRIM acknowledges SIGHT.
R’ Elie Munk (The World of Prayer) puts it this way:
“This bracha does not refer to the crowing of the cock... Therefore this
bracha should be recited even if one did not hear... for it is just an
expression of gratitude at enjoying the benefit of light... The break of day
awakens new faith and fresh initiative everywhere... To him (Adam HaRishon)
it meant that G-d had given him the chance to begin life all over again, and
to atone for the transgression (of yesterday)... This blessing really
expresses our gratitude for the gift of intelligence... not intelligence in
general, but to our ability to make distinctions... (the root of BINA is
related to BEIN, between), ...a thought process (the ability to distinguish
between things) without which no knowledge can exist... it is a blessing for
the first independent activity of the conscious mind. For it is man’s
highest bliss to become aware, upon awakening, that he retains full
possession of his mental faculties. His consciousness of the change from
night to day proves this to him.”
[Side comment: We see the value we attach to knowledge
and reasoning power in the first bracha of request in the weekday Amida. It
is into this bracha that acknowledges G-d as the Giver of knowledge and
understanding that we insert Havdala on Motza’ei Shabbat.]
Did we settle the issue of pronunciation? Is it SECH-vi or sech-VI? Rinat
Yisrael says the latter; everyone else seems to say the former.
But that is no longer the point. A column called TOWARDS BETTER DAV|ENING...
should not be just about MIL’EIL and MILRA. It should be about understanding
what we say, and meaning it. I hope this discussion (and others like it)
helped further that goal.
Parsha Pix
You have some real good stuff to work with together with your children
and/or Shabbat guests. PP is a fun way to go over the sedra and a
springboard to many discussions and Divrei Torah.
Upper-right. Father and daughter; husband and wife. The two pairs involved
in HAFARAT NEDARIM.
Five crown plus one with a sword under it refers to the five kings and
Bil’am who saw their end during the battle against Midyan.
The face-to-face sheep, cows, and donkeys represent to even split of the
spoils of war from Midyan, divided between the army and the rest of the
people.
The pot of gold (in the middle, sort of) refers to the contribution of the
officers of the battle in thanks to G-d for the zero casualty rate.
The Pyramids, the many arrows, and the outline of Israel, of course, stand
for the travels of the people from Exodus to Eretz Yisrael.
The quill (to the left of the donkeys) refers to the Torah’s statement that
Moshe wrote down the travelog of Bnei Yisrael.
The map above the Pyramids with a big 3 on each side of the Jordan River
refers to the Cities of Refuge to be designated in Eretz Yisrael.
The scales of justice are for the careful attention that the courts must pay
in cases of homicide (the example from this week’s sedra) in determining
culpability of the guilty party.
The road sign to Hebron is one of the requirements for Cities of Refuge.
Roads to them must be well-marked to facilitate the escape to them of one
who committed a homicide, regardless of the out- come of his trial.
By my count, that leaves three items in the ParshaPix unexplained. Purposely
so. They are PPP, ParshaPixPuzzles for you to solve. B’hatzlacha.
TTRIDDLES...
are Torah Tidbits-style riddles on Parshat HaShavua (sometimes on the
calendar). They are found in the hard-copy of TT scattered throughout,
usually at the bottom of different columns. In the electronic versions of TT,
they are found all together at the end of the ParshaPix-TTriddles section.
Some TTriddles are also presented for call-in
solution on Torah Tidbits Audio (Arutz-7, Thursday night). The best solution
set submitted each week (there isnt always a best) wins a double prize a CD
from Noam Productions and/or a gift (game, puzzle, book, etc.) from Big Deal
Last week’s (PINCHAS) TTriddle:
[1] He came in third
That’s it. There was only one TTriddle last week. It happens sometimes.
Plus...there was a PPP in the ParshaPix, specifically, two bowling pins and
a C.
And the envelope please...
[1] Several interesting attempts at this one, including the correct
solution. Pinchas was the third Kohen Gadol. Maybe so, but not the solution
to the TTriddle. Here’s a wild try: Win, place, show are the names for
first, second, and third in a horse race. Coming in third, then, means SHOW.
Who, mentioned in the sedra, is associated with a show? Why, Cosby, of
course. Really, now. DM finally came up with the correct answer. First,
se3cond, and third is also Gold, Silver, and Bronze, medal-wise. So who came
in third? ARAD is bronze in Hebrew. Binyamin’s son (among others) BELA had a
son (among others) named ARD. He’s the one that came in third, not-
withstanding the fact that he seems to have been BELA’s first son, and BELA
seems to have been Binyamin’s first. But thus is the nature of TTriddles.
RHM also got this one.
The PPP in the ParshaPix was at the top-middle of the
PP on page 3. The bowling pins formed a split (known as 7-10, but that is
irrelevant). The C as a mark in school is known as a HOOK. In Hebrew, VAV.
So we have the famous split VAV in the word SHALOM.
H(S)M got the split, and then got the VAV in a
different way. C is the chemical symbol for carbon. Carbon is element number
6. The 6th letter in the ALEF-BET, the letter with a G’MATRIYA of 6, is VAV.
Split VAV. I like it.
Prizes for this week to DM, RHM, and H(S)M for their
solutions of the TTriddle and the PPP respectively. Guys, please be in
touch. Honorable mention to the son-in-law of MM/Bklyn for his imaginative
attempt at the PPP.
This week's TTriddles:
[1] They went to Australia to visit grandfather
[2] Ashkenazis pronounciation relates the two
[3] 7 of 10 of 12 share 2 special letters
[4] The first is a window-fogger
[5] Although it worked ok in the sedra, this kind of thing is usually not a
good idea. Hebrew & Aramaic indicate this semantically.
Israel Center Notes: -
Re: The Israel Center and Torah Tidbits
NOTICE: The OU Israel Center and Torah Tidbits do not necessarily endorse
the political or halachic opinions of its advertisers, nor to we guarantee
their quality of service.
The Secret of the Wrong Sedra Name
At a certain point over Shabbat, I said to myself that if one more person
makes a comment about TT525 being labeled Balak instead of Pinchas, I would
write something about it in the next Torah Tidbits. So here it is.
Let’s start with some of the answers I’ve given this past several days to
“Hey, Phil, do you know that you had the wrong sedra on the front page of TT?”
“Duh!”
“Old kabalistic practice to shift the AYIN HARA away from Pinchas, by naming
his sedra Balak.”
“Many shuls did not read Balak well the week before, so they decided to try
again this week.”
“Accidentally used the Chutz LaAretz sedra. They’re one behind, remember?”
[Strike that one, Chutz LaAretz caught up last week.]
“It did say Pinchas, but a disgruntled descendant of Shimon sneaked into the
Print Room and changed it to Balak to embarrass his ancestor’s nemesis.”
“Hey, you’re the only person to have noticed the mistake — you win the
prize.”
“It was a TTriddle. Take the letters of BALAK BEN TZIPOR. There’s the PEI in
TZIPOR and the NUN in BEN. TZADI (90) - LAMED (30) = 60. That’s SAMACH. Add
a BET and the VAV to get 8, the CHET. That leaves REISH (200), KUF (100),
KAF (20) and BET (2). All you have to do is subtract 100 from 200 (100),
divide by 20 (5) and multiply by 2. That makes 10, the YUD. Put them all
together and it spells PINCHAS. And you thought it was a mistake.”
Okay. Got your answer? Oh, here’s one more: “My name is Pinchas and I was
too modest to put it on the front page. (Just at the bottom of all the other
pages).”
And you thought it was a mistake.
Well, of course it was. An embarrassing one. But not a
serious one. Unless some shul read Balak instead of Pinchas... because of TT.
That would be terrible. We once had a six minute error in Plag Mincha. And
that affected when people said Kabbalat Shabbat that week. That was bad.
Seriously, it’s the kind of thing that really scares me. Heavy
responsibility.
Here’s how this one happened. This is not an excuse,
just an explanation.
Each week, I take last week’s front page into DavkaWriter (the program that
now does all of TT) and change it into the new week’s. Upper-right has five
pieces of flexiText (that’s what it’s called in DW) which get changed, one
at a time. The Hebrew and English dates got changed, as did the Perek and
the TT number. I must have gotten distracted before changing the name of the
sedra. And no one else who saw the page before printing, caught the mistake.
We’ll try to be more careful in the future, but mistakes and typos will
happen.
Now tell the truth. Which did you like better? The
real answer or the list of phony answers created when I got tired of people
saying, “Hey, Phil, do you know what sedra we read this week?”
We’re looking for old Torah Tidbits for our archives. Numbers 1 to 100. If
you’ve got any of those and want to part with them, please let us know (02)
566-7787
TO: All the Volunteers (especially), but of course to all the Staff. FROM:
Aviva Nissim; I speak for many when I say the Luncheon was a tremendous
success and enjoyed by all - a real happening. The skits, the wonderful
synchronization, the speeches... how many long hours of preparation! Thank
you from myself and several of my friends. Ad 120!in simcha of course! Aviva
Kollel Program in Kharkov (that’s in the Ukraine, by the way) for boys 10th
to 12th grade. The group will be leaving IY”H on July 22nd and returning
August 12th. If you are interested in further details, give us a call. -
Call Chaim Pelzner at 056-564254
The Israel Center's Beth Din to adjudicate and arbitrate monetary disputes,
according to Jewish law There is a registration fee of 200nis per case No
other charges for this service Please call 566-7787 ext. 204 for further
information We have forms for two types of cases: Those where both parties
agree to submit their dispute to the Beth Din, and those where a complainant
wants the Beth Din to summon the second party. The first batch of cases have
been processed and "invitations" have been issued. The Beth Din is now in
full swing.. Yitzhak Fund, Esq. • Rabbi Emanuel Quint Chairpersons
Kashrut Questions
If you find a discrepancy between the Hebrew labeling and the original
packaging... or if you have any other OU kashrut questions, call this
toll-free number (from Israel to NY) 1-800-949-0123 From 4:00pm - midnight,
you get a human; other times, leave a voice- message OU Kashrut in Israel
office at the Center: 5667787
Israel Center Cafe
After nourishing the soul, come nourish the body serving coffee, sandwiches,
toasts, pizza, french fries, salads, eggs, stuffed potatoes, lasagna,
soups... and more Located on the lower level of the Israel Center Hours:
Sun.-Thu. - 10:00am - 3:00pm Ask about our catering services on or off the
Center premises
Thirsty? We now have a hot drinks machine with coffee, tea, & hot chocolate
located on the ground floor, anda cold drinks (cans) machine on the first
floor near the library.
Want to win a free Shabbat for two at Kibbutz Lavi?!*
All you have to do is fill out the form below and fax it to (02) 561-7432or
mail toLavi Shabbat, c/o Israel Center, P.O.B. 37015, Jerusalem, 91370 or
email to trochel@netvision.net.il and you will be entered in the drawing.
Please answer these questions:
• I visited the Israel Center approx. ____ times in the past year.
• I have been on an Israel Center Tiyul. Yes / No
• What is your favorite section of Torah Tidbits?
Full name:
Full address:
phone: cellphone:
fax: email:
In addition to a chance at the Lavi Shabbat,everyone who sends this form
back will receive an Israel Center gift
Shabbat for two at Kibbutz Lavi • With thanks to Modi’in Tours and Kibbutz
Lavi
*According to availability • Drawing at noon on the Sunday after Tisha B'Av
NESTO • Native English-Speaking Teen Olim
Limited number of placesstill available for the Junior NESTO Camp, 6th thru
8th grade, August 6-11; For more information,call: Chave 050-444 401
TIYULIM and SHABBATONIM
Call the TIYUL HOTLINE Dial the Israel Center's number 5-66-77-87, then
press 211. You'll hear "thank you, one moment please", and then the phone
system's music for 15 seconds. Then the Tiyul Hotline message begins. You
can listen to the whole message and then press 2 to leave your message, or
you can interrupt by pressing 2 right away and then leaving your message.
THE TRAVEL DESK The TRAVEL DESK of the Israel Center
exists... to make registration and detail-receiving for Israel Center
tiyulim more efficient and less head- achy for you. To help you - whether
you live in Israel or are visiting - plan private tiyulim and make in-Israel
travel arrangements Sarah will be happy to assist you on Sundays, Mondays,
Wednesdays, and Thursdays from 9:00am to 1:00pm. Call Sarah at the Center,
566-7787 ext. 249.
Note: When a tiyul says "Bring your own lunch", you
can do that... or this: Call the TRAVEL DESK or the TIYUL HOTLINE up to the
day before the TIYUL and order a box lunch from the Israel Center Cafe. 18
shekel will get you a delicious sandwich, a refreshing drink (specify
regular or diet) and a dessert. Your box lunch will be ready for you when
you board the bus.
KASHRUT POLICY: Food for Israel Center In-House programs is supervised by
OU-in-Israel - Mehadrin. Israel Center sponsored trips and programs are
under Mehadrin Hashgacha. Hotels, restaurants, and tiyulim advertised by the
Travel Desk or by outside parties are not necessarily Mehadrin and are not
endorsed by the OU or the Israel Center.
NOTE CHANGE OF DATE:
The next Israel Center In-House Shabbaton • Hold this Shabbat! Shabbat
Parshat R'ei, August 2-3 • Join us as we explore the World of Tanach (and
other topics); Guest speakers:Rabbi Aaron & Pearl BorowRabbi Neil Winkler •
This will be an exciting, learning-filled Shabbat with great food and great
people (guest speakers and participants intended) • Sign up NOW - limited
spaces - (maximum 80 participants) when you call, let us know your housing
arrangements or needs, dietary needs, seating requests etc. We'll be taking
Shabbat early - Mincha at 6:00, candles not before 6:10; price: 200NIS per
person (hotel accomodations extra), non-mem add 20NIS • The one after this
one. Shabbat Parshat Nitzavim-Vayeilech, August 30-31. Theme: Shlichot and
Rosh HaShana. Watch for further details.
Thursday, July 16 • The Holyland and the Model of the Second Temple;
10:45am: Slide show of the Holyland Model, 12:30pm, guided tour of the
Holyland Model with Ya'akov Billig; price: 65/60NIS
Friday, July 19• My Kotel and Wall Street; tour of the Western and Southern
Wall excavation and the Davidson Center with Ya'akov Billig; price: 45/50NIS
Travel Desk Specials For reservations at the hotels listed below or any
other Israeli hotels, please call Sarah directly at the Travel Desk 566
7787, ext. 249. She'll be happy to accomodate you with any of your requests.
Sharon, Herzliya, thru July • 2-night package: 975NIS per couple B/B
Inbal, Jerusalem, thru August • MIDWEEK 2-night package: 1150NIS per couple
B/B; WEEKEND: 1620NIS per couple, all Shabbat meals,, breakfast Sunday
morning
Mt. Zion Hotel, Jerusalem, thru August • MIDWEEK 2-night package: 960NIS per
couple, one night H/B; one night B/B
Sheraton-Moriah, Tel Aviv, thru July • MIDWEEK 2-night package: 868NIS per
couple B/B
Sheraton City Tower, Ramat Gan, thru July • THU-SUN, 3-night package:
1620NIS per couple, 2 nights B/B; F/B for Shabbat
Le Meridien, Haifa, valid from June 30 to July 17 • MIDWEEK 2-night package:
1100NIS per couple, one day H/B, one day B/B
Carlton, Nahariya , July 19-25 • GLATT-MEHADRIN • 780NIS per night per
couple H/B
Kibbutz Lavi, July 19-21, SHABBAT NACHAMU: 1400NIS per couple in new wing •
1300NIS per couple in main building • 1000NIS per couple in garden rooms;
full Shabbat meals plus breakfast on Sunday morning
For period of July 21-25, the Sheraton Moriah/Dead Sea will be Kosher
L’mehadrin
Separate swimming hours in the hotel’s indoor and outdoor pools; Separate
swimming hours at the Dead Sea Shore; Large Synagogue available; Appropriate
entertainment for the Dati/Charedi public; 799NIS H/B per couple/per night,
minimum: 4 nights
For additional information regarding children’s rates etc.please contact
Sarah at 5667787 ext. 249
B/B = Bed & Breakfast • H/B = Half Board (breakfast + one meal) • F/B (3
meals a day)
Midweek = SUN, MON, TUE, WED nights • Weekends = THU, FRI, Motza"sh nights
Attention Students from Abroad: Are your parents planning on visiting you
this year? If so, you want to speak to us (02-566-7787 ext. 249).We have
many attractive deals for them... and you. Let us turn an ordinary “been
there, did it” visit into an unforgettable, special one!
The Back Page of TT526
"Regular" Israel Center classes & lectures - 20NIS for members, 25NISfor
non-mem. Life members, 5NIS (except for programs of/with other
organizations). No one will be turned away for lack of ability to pay.
(Membership is 225NIS per year)
Many Israel Center programs are partially funded by the Jewish Agency for
Israel
Friday
6:00pm - New “Early Shabbat” minyan with Mincha before Plag and Kabbalat
Shabbat afterin the Wolinetz Family Shul - OHEL SHMUEL (at the Israel
Center)
Shabbat Day
Shabbat afternoon (Matot-Mas'ei), July 6th, 5:00pm • Shiur in Pirkei Avot by
Rabbi Eddie Abramson • Drinks • Mincha follows the shiur
Motza”Sh July 6th • 9:45pm, Maimonides’ Mas’ei; From Morality at Marah to
Sanctity at Sinai • Rabbi Yaakov Moshe Poupko
Hineni Jerusalem is very sorry to announce that Rebbetzin Esther Jungreis
has been forced to cancel her trip to Israel due to an injury. Therefore her
lecture that was scheduled for this Motzei Shabbat, July 6th, has been
postponed.
SUNDAY
9:30am (women) •Mystical Insights into theMonths of the Year • Golda
Warhaftig
10:30am (women) Let's Really Learn Some Chumash • Tonia Frohwein
N'SHEI LIBRARY 10:30-12:45
11:30am (men & women) Parshat HaShavua • Shprintee Herskovits
Men who are looking to do some serious learning...
Shiur in Gemara by Rabbi David Zitter, 10:00am, SUN-THU
Daf Yomi in English with Rabbi Shmuel Halpern, 3:00pm, SUN-THU
Shiur in Makot 2nd Perek by Rabbi Hillel Ruvel, 4:30pm, SUN-THU
All shiurim take place in the Israel Center's Ganchrow Beit Midrash one
flight up
Sundays July 7 & 14 • 8:00pm • Torah, Psychology and Self Control with Dr.
Baruch Shulem, Internationally known lecturer on religion and psychotherapy
MONDAY
9:15am • Excursions into the World of Nevi'im (the Prophets) Mrs. Pearl
Borow
N'SHEI LIBRARY 10:00-12:30
10:30am (men & women) • Rambam's 13 Principles of Faith • Rabbi Zev Leff
11:36am July 8 (men & women) • Jewish History - Bayit Sheni period; In the
Days of Pontius Pilate • Dr. Henry Goldblum
Women's Beit Midrash Program • Mondays 3:00-4:00pm: Guided Chevruta Study in
Tanach and Jewish Thought
4:00-5:00pm: Learning an Independent Chumash Study Method with Rabbi David
Derovan
Monday, July 8, 8:00pm • in cooperation with (and at) the Israel Center
Fourth of four Workshops for Singles; Good-Bye to Boredom, Hopelessness and
Shyness (or Longing): Hello to Confidence on Dates and at Singles’ Events
• Conducted by Ezer Kenegdo Matchmaking - Andy & Ayalah Haas (5666039)
8:00pm • Curing the Jewish Heart; Lecture series by AM SEGULA on Lessons
from History & Zionism
Monday, July 8, 8:00pm • Root & Branch Lecture, in cooperation with the
Israel Center: "ISLAM AND ISLAMIC PRACTICES IN THE EYES OF JEWISH LAW";
Special Guest Speaker:Rabbi Menachem Slae; nis25 per person • Information:
rb@rb.org.il
May a Jewish shochet slaughters meat for an Arab customer face Mecca and say
"Allah Akhbar"if the customer requests this? • May a Jewish shochet
slaughter meat for an Arab customer when he knows that the meat will be used
for the Hag HaKorban (Id el Adbach) celebration? How does Judaism view the
historic role of Islam? • Does Jewish Law permit the practice of customs
borrowed from Islam and Arab culture (or other religions and cultures)?
TUESDAY
9:00-9:50am Four Who Entered the Pardes (the deepest levels of Torah
secrets) • Dr. Hayim Abramson
9:55-10:45am Jewish Concepts, How to Say them in Hebrew; kASHRUT • Dr. Hayim
Abramson
10:50-11:40am • Parshat haShavua with Rabbi Yitzchak Rubenstein • Rabbi
Spiegelman will be back IY”H August 6th
The Israel Center and the Old City Free Loan Association Gemach - Free Loan
Society to provide interest-free loans for people in financial distress.
Interviews at the Center on Tuesdays from 10:00-12:00 Please bring ID
N'SHEI LIBRARY 11:15-12:45
11:45am • Chabad insights into Parshat HaShavua and the Actualia of Our Time
(women only) • Raizel Zisk
Tuesday, July 9, 8:00pm, Explaining the New Israeli Tax Law and explaining
the Halachic Basis for paying taxed to the State of Israel with Eli Clark,
Tax Attorney & Rabbi
WEDNESDAY
9:30am Towards a More Meaningful Davening Experience Dr. Joel Luber
10:30am Break the Fear Habit... And Live! with Alan Romm P.C.
Women's Beit Midrash Program
Wednesdays: 3:00-4:00pm • Women in Tanach with Pearl Borow (men & women)
4:00-5:00pm • Guided Chevruta Study in Tanach and Jewish Thought
8:00-10:00pm • Aliya Counselling with Miriam Bass
7:45-8:45pm Jewish Philosophy Road map to the Prophets - Rambam's Guide for
the Perplexed Now studying: "Oredering their Mitzvot and their "reasons"";
Ramban's Commentary on the Torah and its Wellsprings: Now studying: "The
Tree of Knowing Good and Evil and the Yetzer HaRa" with Rabbi Chaim Eisen •
alternating topics
WED, July 10, 8:00pm • Repeat program by popular demand: Know & Help Your
Eyes; Learn more about your eyes and vision; Learn exercises that can
alleviate eye fatigue and eye strain and possibly even improve your
eyesight; Learn about nutrition & eye health • Guest speaker:Yaakov Gerlitz
Dipl. Acpractitioner of Chinese Medicine(and an interesting fellow - PC)
THURSDAY
Sometime in the morning • Shiurim while you fold, Parshat HaShavua and/or
the Calendar • Various presenters
10:15am • SLIM FOR LIFE Group weight-loss program for women • No obligation
for the first session • Qualified nutritional advisor on hand • Elisheva
999-6479
Thursday, July 11th, 8:00pm; How to be disease-free and energetic with Irwin
Goldenberg, LCN
8:00pm • The Book of Sho'f'tim with Reb Yosef Schreiber
Note: The Men's & Boys' Choir led by Yisrael Shwarzstein is in recess until
after the "Chagim"
FRIDAY
9:00am • In-Depth Pirkei Avot • Rabbi Chaim Eisen
NEW - Mincha-KabbalatShabbat-Maariv - 6:00pm • Mincha before PLAG (time will
adjust in mid-August)
WILL RESUME TOWARDS THE END OF THE SUMMER • Avrom Silver Jerusalem College
for Adults Fall Program 5762 (2001 - 2002) At the Israel Center
ON SUMMER RECESS Also on TUESDAYS at the CENTER Two Tuesday morning classes
at the Israel Center by the Yad Yaakov Center for Jewish Education Separate
fees. Call (02) 652-4601 for further information 9:00-10:30am
Upcoming at the Israel Center
Thursday, July 18 • Tish’a b’Av day • from 8:30am Slow-paced Shacharit (we
will be in time for Sh’ma); KINOT: We will say selected Kinot in an unrushed
manner, explanations in English • A very meaningful experience; Layning &
Kinot leader: Rabbi Neil Winkler; Kinot introduction and explanations: Dr.
David Luchins • We will end around Chatzot (12:45pm approx.); There will be
a topical mini-shiur until Mincha at 1:20pm
Note: We are considering having Tish’a b’Av evening davening and Eicha on
Wednesday, July 17, beginning with Maariv at 8:10pm. We will do so only if
there is a request (demand), so please let us know if you’d be interested.
Final decision will appear in next week’s TT.
Motza’ei Shabbat Nachamu, July 20 • Who says you can't go back in time? Join
us at the Israel Centeron Motza’ei Shabbat Nachamu for a Pioneer/Pineview
Reunion with Ruach Uno a.k.a. Howie Kahn featuring Jewish music of the '60's
and '70's, Israeli classics and American folk songs • 35/40NIS • Even if you
don’t remember Motza’ei Shabbat Nachamuat the Pineview or Pioneer, even if
you never heard of them, you will thoroughly enjoy this musical event.
OU ISRAEL CENTER Seymour J. Abrams Orthodox
Union Jerusalem World Center
Yitzhak Fund, President
Rabbi Emanuel Quint, Senior Vice President
Prof. Meni Koslowsky, Vice President
Harvey Tannenbaum, Secretary/Treasurer
Sandy Kestenbaum, Vaad member
Rabbi Eddie Abramson, Vaad member
Rabbi David Cohen, Director General, OU in Israel
Menachem Persoff, Director, Israel Center
Phil Chernofsky, Educational Director and TT editor
22 Keren Ha'Yesod POB 37015 Jerusalem 91370
Phone: (02) 566 7787 Fax: (02) 561-7432
email: tt@ou.org - website: www.ou.org/torah/tt
Orthodox Union • National Conference of Synagogue Youth
This publication and many of the programs of the Israel Center and NCSY
b'Yisrael are assisted by grants from The Jewish Agency for Israel
TT is published and printed "in house" at the Israel Center
[The
Matot-Mas'ei Homepage]
[The TORAH tidbits Homepage] [How to use TORAH tidbits]
[About The OU/NCSY Israel Center] [About TORAH tidbits]

|