By Rabbi Avraham
Fischer. A publication of the Orthodox Union in cooperation with the Seymour
J. Abrams Orthodox Union Jerusalem World Center
October 24, 2003
When mankind’s doom is decided irreversibly, Hashem commands
Noach and his family to enter the Ark:
…And you will come to the Ark, you, and your sons, and your wife and your
sons’ wives with you (Bereishit 6:18)
As Rashi points out, that this command requires:
The men separately and the women separately.
Noach’s family obeys:
And Noach came with his sons, and his wife and his sons’ wives with him, to
the Ark, from before the waters of the Flood (7:7).
Rashi explains that the married couples were commanded to remain celibate
during the time that the Flood waters covered the earth. He takes this idea
from Bereishit Rabbah 31, 32 and Sanhedrin 108a.
When the earth is dry, Hashem permits them to resume marital life:
Leave the Ark, you and your wife, your sons, and your sons’ wives with you
However, they do not return to normal relations yet:
And Noach went out with his sons, and his wife and his sons’ wives with him
Bereishit Rabbah explains that they were waiting for Hashem’s blessings, and
His assurance that the world would not be destroyed again. After all, Noach’s
family was to be responsible for repopulating a destroyed world.
Hashem’s blessing comes after Noach’s sacrifice:
And G-d blessed Noach and his sons, and said to them, “Be fruitful and
multiply and fill the earth…And you, be fruitful and multiply, swarm on the
earth and multiply on it” (9:1,7).
Rashi (9:7) explains that the first statement is a blessing and the second is
a command. And Noach’s sons fulfill this command after the Flood, as we read
in chapter 10.
But, why were Noach and his family required to separate in the first place?
Malbim takes a practical approach: the population had to be controlled so as
to prevent overcrowding and food shortages in the Ark. Indeed, Sanhedrin 108b
states that the creatures in the Ark were forbidden to procreate.
The Zohar (Bereishit 204a) says that the Ark was “the tent of Hashem,” where
marital relations are inappropriate. Besides, it says, children conceived
while the world is cursed would be cursed as well.
However, most commentaries, beginning with Rashi (7:7) say that relations were
forbidden “because the world was immersed in sorrow.” As the Talmud (Ta’anit
One who pains himself with the community will merit to see the consolation of
It is insufficient to “feel sorry” that others are suffering. A
tragedy that strikes the community must be realized and appreciated by all,
including those individuals who are spared from the tragedy. One must identify
with the community, both in times of joy and in times of sorrow.
Thus, when the Children of Israel fought Amelek (Shemot 17:11-12), Moshe joined
them, although he was not a combatant. He raised his hands throughout the
battle, since Israel was “immersed in sorrow.” Also, it is recorded that “to
Yosef were born two sons before the years of famine” (Bereishit 41:50), because
during a famine, one should refrain from marital relations (Rashi). On the other
hand, Elimelech is punished for leaving the land of Israel during a famine (Ruth
1:1-3), because he separated himself from the community. One must identify with
the misfortunes of the community. Thus, Jewish law requires that, during times
of famine, even one who has food should eat sparingly, both in order to share
the food with others, as well as to feel the pain of those who have nothing (Shulchan
Aruch Orach Chaim 574:4; 240:12).
If a person cannot feel the community’s pain he is not truly a part of the
community. As Vladimir Jabotinsky (1881-1940), leader of the
Zionist-Revisionists, said: “When you cut a man’s foot and he doesn’t scream, it
means that the foot is paralyzed.”
Noach and his family were spared by Hashem from the waters of the Flood because
Noach remained a righteous man in a corrupt world. Still, they were a part of
that world, and needed to be reminded of this. Hashem teaches Noach: Although
the people of the world deserve destruction, and you and your family deserve to
be spared, you cannot consider yourselves detached from them; while your
community suffers, you must join in their hardship. These survivors were like
limbs of a corpus; they were not permitted to feel self-satisfied and turn their
backs upon the rest of humankind. They were obligated to share the pain of their
human family, if humankind was to deserve to survive. No community is without
its faults. Yet, the survival of the community depends on its most righteous
members feeling at one with its unrighteous members.
The Jewish community, as well, is a world-wide interdependent body. Some parts
of the Jewish world suffer from poverty, assimilation, anti-Semitism and
persecution while others are safe and prosperous. Jews in the land of Israel
are buffeted by international opposition, plagued by terror, burdened by
military service. Jews in the Diaspora face uncertainties in identity, the
flaring up of hatred, and blistering criticism.
And, throughout the Jewish world, there are more committed Jews and less
committed ones, righteous Jews and flawed Jews, Jews of every political stripe
and religious perspective. Despite the vast differences, the unity of the Jewish
world must be maintained. We are a body, a family. The suffering of some must be
felt by all.
It is hard to say, in our present-day world, which of us is “in the ark” and
which are “outside the ark”, but we are all in the same boat. Our survival
depends on each of us being committed to our unity.
Torah K'Torat Eretz Yisrael!"- Torah from Aloh Na'aleh*
“To everything there is a season
and a time to every purpose under the heavens ” Koheleth 3:1
“There was a time for Noah to enter the ark…and a time for him to leave…”
Koheleth Rabbah 3:1
Although Noah had advance warnings (120 years) and a precise forecast (7
days) of when the”mabul” would strike, he leaves his home and enters the
ark only after the floodwaters are lapping at his door. Perhaps Noah was
one of those of “little faith” who doubted that the catastrophe would
really occur (Rashi on Gen. 7:7). But it is quite understandable that
people become so attached to their surroundings that they are reluctant to
uproot themselves even in the face of credible threats. We have seen this
happen many times in our history as a people.
But if Noah’s entrance to the ark is instructive, his exit is even more
so. Once the rains cease and the waters recede, Noah tests to make sure
the outside is safe yet he does not leave the ark! Only after G-d
directly orders him to do so, does Noah go. Was this proper behavior?
Rabbi Yudan said: “If I was in Noah’s place I would have broken down the
door and left!” (Yalkut Shimoni)
Perhaps the ark can be seen as a metaphor for the lands of Exile where
Jews have taken refuge. Once the stormy waters have receded and the road
to home is open, do each of us really need a personal invitation from G-d
to leave the “galut”? Surely over 50 years of vibrant Jewish statehood,
with over 5 million Jews and Jerusalem the capital, is sign enough that
Jews are being called home. Indeed there seems to be a tone of impatience
in G-d’s curt call to Noah: “Tzai min hateiva!” (Gen 8:16) as if to say
“For heaven’s sake, what are you waiting for!!”
Rabbi Shubert Spero
*D’var Torah from Aloh Na'aleh:
an initiative of former North American Rabbis and laymen who successfully
made Aliyah, aimed at highlighting the centrality of Israel and promoting
Aliyah. They send emissaries – Rabbis, academicians, and others – on
speaking-tours throughout the U.S. and Canada.
Tel: 972-2-566-1181 ext. 320