OU Torah Insights

By Rabbi Avraham Fischer. A publication of the Orthodox Union in cooperation with the Seymour J. Abrams Orthodox Union Jerusalem World Center

Parshat Toldot
December 2, 2000

AND THERE WAS A FAMINE IN THE LAND, beside the first famine that had been in the days of Avraham.  And Yitzchak went to Avimelech, King of the Philistines in Gerar.  And Hashem appeared to him and He said:  “Do not go down to Egypt.  Remain in the land . . .” (Bereishit 26:1-2).

YITZCHAK AVINU intended to continue his journey southward beyond Gerar towards Egypt.  But Hashem instructs him to remain there and promises to protect and bless him.

CHAZAL EXPLAIN THAT YITZCHAK’S REQUIREMENT to remain in Eretz Yisrael stems from his designation as the olah temimah, the perfect burnt-offering, when he was bound and prepared as a sacrifice by his father Avraham at the Akeidah.  As Rashi says, “Chutz La-aretz [outside of Israel] is not fitting for you” (26:2).

IN THIS RESPECT, YITZCHAK is unique among the Avot:  Avraham originated from Ur Kasdim, and then traveled to, and throughout, Eretz Yisrael.  However, when the “first famine” struck the land, he descended to Egypt.  Yaakov was born in Eretz Yisrael, but when he was threatened by his twin brother Esav, he fled to Charan and lived there for 22 years.  The last 17 years of his life were spent in Egypt.

YITZCHAK WAS THE ONLY ONE OF THE AVOT who lived his entire life all 180 years in Eretz Yisrael.  True, his life there was marked by instability, moving from place to place, encountering challenge after challenge to his claims on the land, and subject to the whims of Avimelech and others. Yet, his feet never left the soil of Israel, because he was the olah temimah.

WHAT DOES it mean for Yitzchak Avinu to be, in effect, a living sacrifice?  

ACCORDING TO THE HALACHA it is forbidden to remove any sacrifice from its prescribed boundaries (mechitzot), and removal renders it unfit.  In fact, even the intention of removing it from its boundaries renders it pasul (invalid)!  Each type of sacrifice has its own defined area.  For example, the korban pesach (Passover sacrifice) must not be removed from the city of Jerusalem.  An olah must remain within the precincts of the Bet Hamikdash.  It would seem that, for Yitzchak, all of Eretz Yisrael was defined as his Bet Hamikdash, where he carried out his avodah (service to Hashem). In the words of one Midrash, when Hashem tells Yitzchak SH’CHON (26:2), to remain in Eretz Yisrael, this means “Cause the Divine Presence (SH’CHINAH) to reside in the Land.”

IT IS IMPORTANT to note that a korban may not be removed from its boundaries, but only from the moment the animal is slaughtered.  As long as the animal is alive there is no such restriction.  Therefore, a person can designate a living animal as a korban while yet on the farm.  When it is brought to the Bet Hamikdash, the animal may still be returned as desired.  Only after the animal is slaughtered does it become a korban, and must remain within its mechitzot.

THIS ASPECT OF KORBANOT puzzles me regarding Yitzchak Avinu’s designation as an olah temimah.  Although he was prepared, even bound, as a sacrifice, he was not slaughtered!  At the last moment, Hashem told Avraham, “ Do not send forth your hand against the young man, nor do anything to him” (Bereishit 22:12).

AN ANSWER to this problem is quoted in the name of the Chidushei HaRim (R.Yitzchak Meir Alter Rothenberg, the first Gerrer Rebbi, 1789-1866):  At first, it seems, that Yitzchak is to be offered as a sacrifice in the conventional manner. This is apparent from the words of the original directive:  V’HA’ALEHU ? “and bring him up there as an olah.”  However, Hashem then commands Avraham not to slaughter him.  Rashi explains that, since Hashem is Eternal and Perfect, He is not “changing His mind.”  Rather, His intention all along was to “bring him up” ? that is, prepare him and take him up the mountain as one would an olah ? but not actually slaughter and burn him.  HA’ALEHU means bring him up; now that he has been brought up, bring him down.

AT THIS POINT AVRAHAM understands that, unlike other olot that are slaughtered and burned, the manner of avodah for the olah temimah called Yitzchak was specifically to prepare him, not to slaughter him.  The preparation itself was the sum and substance of the maaseh hakravah (the act of offering), granting Yitzchak the status of olah temimah. Consequently, Eretz Yisrael became his arena of sanctity that defined him. After the act of offering, a korban must undergo hartza’ah, acceptance.  With  conventional  korbanot, this is accomplished by burning the required parts of the sacrifice on the altar.  How was the olah temimah called Yitzchak accepted?

SINCE YITZCHAK’S “Bet Hamikdash” was all of Eretz Yisrael, then the work he would do in the land would be his hartza’ah.  This is supported by another Midrash on the word SH’CHON:  “Make a dwelling (SH’CHUNAH) in the Land of Israel;  plant saplings, sow, dig wells.”  For the rest of his life, every contribution Yitzchak would make to Eretz Yisrael would be a fulfillment of his mission as the olah temimah.

WHAT ARE WE MEANT to learn from Yitzchak’s example?

OFTEN, IN TRYING TO LIVE a life of Torah, we tend to focus on what must be relinquished or rejected.  We dwell on the fact that our social connections and our physical outlets must be limited in many ways. While     it is true that sanctity requires self-discipline, that is not the totality of kedushah. The life of Torah is not one of negation; it is a life of elevation.  It is a life in which every arena of our activity ? not merely the synagogue and school, but the home, the media and the marketplace ? contains the potential for sanctification.

YITZCHAK LIVED AS AN OLAH TEMIMAH after the Akeidah, which is not to say that he regarded his life forfeit.  Quite the contrary:  Yitzchak’s avodah was such that everything he did was an act of devotion to Hashem. 

THIS WAS TRUE both when he went out to “meditate in the field towards evening” as well as when he dug wells to water his flocks.

OF COURSE, A LIFE OF TORAH requires some sacrifice;  certainly, we must take a firm stand against those values antithetical to Torah.  But what is truly demanded of us is what Hashem commanded Yitzchak Avinu: “Cause the Divine Presence to reside” ? “Plant, sow, dig” ? make the world our Sanctuary and imbue it with the values of Hashem’s Torah.  


OU Torah Insights Project Archives


Torah Insights is brought to you every week
as a service of the Community and Synagogue Services Department
of the Orthodox Union

Your comments are always welcome

www.ou.org