OU Torah Insights

By Rabbi Avraham Fischer. A publication of the Orthodox Union in cooperation with the Seymour J. Abrams Orthodox Union Jerusalem World Center

Parshat Beshalach
February 10, 2001

SO, THIS IS WHAT IT IS LIKE TO BE FREE.  After the glorious miracles at the Sea of Reeds – with generations of slavery and suffering finally and irrevocably behind them; with their erstwhile oppressors, the Egyptians, lying dead along the shore; with their unswerving trust in Hashem and in His servant Moshe confirmed; and with the clear evidence that Hashem, “the Master of war”, will champion their cause forever – no doubt it has begun to dawn upon the Children of Israel that a life of freedom has begun.

BUT HOW DOES A SLAVE PEOPLE ENVISAGE itself as a free people after so many years?  And, how can such a people be educated for a life of freedom?

THE FIRST STEPS WILL BE CRUCIAL; they will set the tone for how – and, in particular, for what purpose – freedom is to be achieved.  And this must be taught.

THE STORY IS TOLD OF A PRIVATE IN NAPOLEON’S army who saved the emperor’s life.  Napoleon offered to reward the private for his courageous service.  After thinking for a moment, the private said:  “I would like a transfer to another unit, because my sergeant is very hard on me.”

“FOOL!” REPLIED NAPOLEON.  “Why not ask to become a sergeant yourself?”  If not properly guided, people who have never known freedom can misuse it.

WHAT ARE THE FIRST STEPS THAT WILL successfully lead the Children of Israel from the euphoria of the Sea of Reeds to the foot of Mount Sinai?  Perhaps the first thing they need is a push.

And Moshe made Israel journey from the Sea of Reeds and they went out into the wilderness of Shur.  And they went for three days in the wilderness and they did not find water.  And they came to Marah [bitter] and they were not able to drink water from Marah, because they were bitter; therefore its name was called Marah.  And the people murmured against Moshe, saying “What shall we drink?”(Shemot 15:22-24). 

WHAT A RUDE AWAKENING!  The waters of freedom are bitter!  Freedom, it seems, is not the magical, trouble-free existence they may have once imagined.  It is demanding, and fraught with disappointments. 

AS LONG AS THEY WERE SLAVES, the Children of Israel never had to concern themselves with obtaining water.  Their forefathers, Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov – free men, responsible for families, servants and flocks – devoted much time to locating water.  Furthermore, by digging wells and naming them they demonstrated their ownership of the land.  The paradox of the unceasing preoccupation with water is that – arduous as it may be to attain – it is, nonetheless, the concern of free people only.

UNTIL NOW THE CHILDREN OF ISRAEL’S experiences with water was as a medium of suffering:  Their babies were thrown into the Nile.  Hashem transformed the Nile into blood.  And, just three days ago, Hashem destroyed the mighty Egyptian army under the waves of the Sea of Reeds.  Will they ever be able to see water as the medium of life and freedom?

And he cried out to Hashem, and Hashem instructed him about a tree which he cast into the waters, and the waters became sweet.  There He established for it [the nation] law and justice, and there He tested it.  And He said:  “If you will surely hearken to the voice of Hashem, your G-d, and will do that which is right in His eyes, and you will give ear to His commandments and you will keep all His laws, then all the maladies which I have put upon the Egyptians I will not put upon you, for I am Hashem your Healer” (vs. 25-26).

IBN EZRA NOTES THE SYMMETRY of comparing this miracle with the first of the Ten Plagues:  then, Hashem changed sweet water into blood; now, Hashem shows that He can also turn brackish water sweet.  Of course, this demonstrates Hashem’s mastery over the forces of nature. The midrash (Mechilta Beshalach) says that the tree itself was bitter, and only Hashem can use a bitter agent to turn the bitter sweet. 

BUT, EVEN MORE PROFOUNDLY, the people are learning a personal level of Hashem’s Providence: Hashem is the same One Who not only punishes, but rewards; He brings illness, but He also is the Healer; and He is the same One Who creates the bitter and then can make it sweet.

HOWEVER, TO ACCOMPLISH THIS, HASHEM demands the cooperation of the Children of Israel.  They must learn that it is only through the Torah – its law and justice, its commandments and laws – that their freedom will have meaning.

THE KLI YAKAR (R. SHLOMO EPHRAIM LUNSCHITZ, c.1550-1619), sees the key to understanding this passage in the root of the word instructed – VAYOREIHU (uvruhu) – which is Y.R.H. (vrh), the same as the root for TORAH.  More than just instructing Moshe where to find the tree, and how to use it, Hashem wanted Moshe to use the tree itself as a visual aid, an object lesson for the connection between Torah, human freedom and Hashem’s Providence:

THE SOUL CONTAINS ELEMENTS OF BITTERNESS, in the form of destructive passions, but the Torah, whose strictures often begin as bitter themselves, sweetens the waters of life.  It provides a framework in which freedom can flourish responsibly, creatively and purposefully.  When the Jewish people observed the Torah, Hashem enters into a partnership with them and showers them with healing blessings.


OU Torah Insights Project Archives


Torah Insights is brought to you every week
as a service of the Community and Synagogue Services Department
of the Orthodox Union

Your comments are always welcome

www.ou.org