Re-Counting the Prophets - Rabbi Pinchas Frankel

Haftarah of Parshat Vayera - 5761

The identity of the Haftarah this week for Parshat Vayera depends on the community that we are dealing with.  For Sephardim and the Kehillah of Frankfurt-am-Mein, embodied today basically by Kehilas K'hal Adas Yeshurun in Washington Heights and its branches, the Haftarah is taken from "Melachim"/Kings II, "Perek"/Chapter 4, Verses 1-23; other communities continue in Chapter 4, reading verses 24-37 as well.

Summary of the Haftarah

The Haftarah is in two sections.  Each section speaks of a miracle (actually, according to the Sephardim and Frankfurt-am-Mein, the second miracle is just set up) performed by the Prophet Elisha, the disciple of "Eliyahu HaNavi," Elijah the prophet.

Section I

An impoverished widow from the Community of Prophets (would that we still had this Community now) cried out for help to Elisha.  She had no means to pay a debt owed by her late husband to a creditor, and that creditor was threatening to take her two sons as slaves in lieu of her payment of the debt.

Elisha told her to borrow empty vessels from all her neighbors, to close the doors of her home, and to pour oil into them from the one remaining cruse of oil that she had.  She listened to the Prophet, poured the oil which miraculously continued to flow until all the borrowed vessels and the original cruse of oil were full.  Elisha instructed her to sell enough of the oil to pay the debt, and to live off the supply of remaining oil.

Section 2

It happened one day that Elisha happened to pass through Shunam in Eretz Yisrael.  A prominent woman, noticed him and invited him into her house to eat with herself and her husband.  Elisha listened to the woman and ate with this couple that time, and every time he passed that way.

One day, the woman said to her husband, "I know that this guest of ours is a holy man.  Let's make a special room for him, furnished with a bed, a table, a chair and a lamp."

In appreciation, Elisha asked her if there were anything he could do for her.  She declined the offer, saying, "I dwell among my People."  She meant that she had no need or desire for special treatment.

Gechazi, the servant of Elisha, had noticed that the couple was childless, and it was unlikely that the couple would be able to have children in the future, because the husband was elderly.  Elisha informed the woman, now realizing what her unexpressed desire was, that in a year, she would have a son; a promise that she initially refused to believe.

But the following year, a son was born.  As a young child, with his father in the fields, the son suddenly developed a terrible headache.  He was carried to his mother, but expired on her knees.  The woman put the lifeless body of the boy on the bed of the Prophet, and immediately set out on a journey to Elisha's residence, on Mt. Carmel.

When the Prophet saw her in the distance, he said to Gechazi to run to her and inquire what it was the woman wanted, but she would not disclose the purpose of her visit to Gechazi.  When she entered the house of the prophet, she grasped his legs and would not let go.  She said, "Did I ask you for a son?  Didn't I say, 'Don't lie to me?' "

Realizing what had happened, Elisha sent Gechazi before him with his staff, instructing him to use it to revive the boy.  Gechazi took the staff, but was unable to revive the child.

Elisha entered the house, went to his room, where he found the boy.  He lay on top of him, mouth-to-mouth, eye-to-eye, hand-to-hand, and, as it were, re-introduced the boy's soul into him, using himself as a conduit.  The boy sneezed seven times, and opened his eyes.  The mother opened the door, bowed at Elisha's feet, and took her son.

Haftarah Connections

Parshah-Haftarah Connections

A Possible Connection:

In the Parshah, Avraham displays his wonderful "midot," behavioral characteristics that resulted in his contribution  to "zechut avot," the "merit of the forefathers" (Yitzchak and Yaakov would make their contributions as well), an inexhaustible or nearly inexhaustible reservoir of "merit"  available to their descendants, upon which the generations would rely when their own supply of merit "ran dry."

In the Haftarah, Elisha provides the impoverished widow with a nearly inexhaustible supply of oil, which she relies on now that her regular supply of income has "run dry."

In the beginning of the Parshah, Avraham displays one of his famous "midot," "Hachnasat Orchim," "Hospitality," when he invites the three strangers (actually "Malachim," or Angels) into his tent (despite the fact that he is recovering from his "Brit Milah," Circumcision).

In the Haftarah, the Woman of Shunam also displays the characteristic of hospitality when she invites Elisha initially to be a guest for meals and, upon realizing who he is, constructs a private room for him.

In last week's Parshah, Avraham declines the offer of booty of war from the King of Sodom, saying (Bereshit 14:23), "And you shall not say, 'I enriched Avraham.' "

In the Haftarah, the Woman of Shunam initially declines Elisha's offer of remuneration for her kindness.  She truly feels no need for anything that he could provide, not imagining that he could help her in her greatest wish, to have a child.

The Main Connection:

In the Parshah, we find an Angel of G-d promising a child to Avraham and Sarah, after many years of childlessness.

In the Haftarah, Elisha promises a child to the Woman of Shunam and her husband, after many years of childlessness.

In the Parshah, Sarah does not believe the Blessing of the Angel, and laughs, saying (Bereshit 18:12), "After I have dried up, shall I again have the pleasure of youth, and furthermore, my husband is an old man?"

In the Haftarah, the Woman of Shunam also does not initially believe Elisha's promise, and she says (4:16), "… do not lie to your handmaiden."

In the Parshah, according to the Midrash, on the way to the Akeidah, there was a separation made by HaShem between Avraham and Yitzchak on one side, and  Yishmael and Eliezer on the other side, based on their ability to identify the Place of the "Akeidah" -  "Har HaMoriah," Mt. Moriah, the Temple Mount.  It could be identified by  the  presence of a Divine Cloud of Glory that hovered over the mountain at that time.  Avraham and Yitzchak could see it; Yishmael and Eliezer could not.

In the Chapter preceding the Hafatrah, Elisha is awarded his request of double the prophetic spirit of his Teacher, Eliyahu, based on his ability to see the departure of Eliyahu to heaven in the fiery chariot, pulled by the fiery horses.

Elisha-Eliyahu Connections

Our Haftarah appears in the Book of "Melachim II" in the Chapter immediately following the final separation between Elisha and his great mentor, Eliyahu HaNavi.  Before Eliyahu was taken to Heaven by fiery steed and chariot, he had asked his student to make a request, and Elisha had requested double the prophetic spirit that had rested upon Eliyahu.  Eliyahu had replied that his request would be fulfilled if and only if Elisha would be able to "see" his departure, and Elisha had indeed been able to see it.

This Chapter of "Melachim II" recounts how Elisha performs miracles nearly identical to those performed by Eliyahu in "Melachim I."  As recounted in "Melachim I," Chapter 17, Verses 8-16, Eliyahu performs a miracle in which a widow receives a supply of flour and of oil that is to continue until the time that HaShem ends the drought that He has imposed upon the Land.

There we also find Eliyahu restoring to life the son of the widow, who had suddenly died, thus providing the model for the miracles performed by his disciple, Elisha, in this Haftarah.

Promises of Motherhood Connections

Very often in the "TANACH," the Hebrew Bible, HaShem rewards virtuous women who have been childless with the ability to conceive and give birth.  This allows them to fulfill their G-dly potential as "mothers," whatever else they might do in their lives.

The Talmud says that these special women are made initially childless by HaShem, because He wishes to hear their pure prayers, unlike any other prayers uttered on earth.  Then He rewards them with children, as the One described in "Tehilim"/Psalms 113:9 as the "One Who makes the childless woman of the house into the joyous mother of children!"

In the "TANACH," the women in this category are Sarah, Rivkah, Leah (for a short while), Rachel, the Wife of Manoach (mother of Shimshon), Chanah, and the Woman of Shunam of our Haftarah.

Haftarah-Types of Miracles Connections

There are basically two types of miracles that are performed in the "TANACH," the Hebrew Bible.  These are the "Nes Nigleh," the "Open Miracle," and the "Nes Nistar," the "Hidden Miracle."

The "Nes Nigleh" is the type of miracle that cannot be explained by Natural Law or  which, in fact, violates Natural Law.  The miracles performed by Elisha in this Haftarah are "Nisim Niglim," "Open Miracles," because the first, the provision of the relatively  inexhaustible supply of oil violated the Law of Conservation of Matter and Energy and  the second, the Revival of the Dead Child, violated the Law that everywhere in Nature, Death is an irreversible process (see further discussion below of Revival of the Dead).

A "Nes Nistar" is generally a miracle where somehow events combine in such a manner that they bring Salvation to the Jewish People.  The classic example of the Hidden Miracle is the Purim Story, where HaShem, because of the fasting and prayers of the Jewish People, acting from behind the scenes, orchestrated events such that they  resulted in the effect of "vena'hafoch hu," essentially, the "tables were turned" on our enemies, and the Jewish People emerged victorious.

Haftarah-Chanukah Connection

The first miracle performed by Elisha in the Haftarah, the provision of a relatively  inexhaustible supply of oil to the impoverished widow is reminiscent of the Miracle of Chanukah.  At that time, when the Chashmonaim, the Priestly Family who were the Heroes of Chanukah, entered the Temple to rededicate it, they found only one cruse  of oil, sufficient to light the Menorah, the Holy Lamp in the Temple, for only one day.  Yet, the oil miraculously lasted for eight days, when a new supply could be prepared.

"Techiyat HaMetim" "Revival of the Dead" Connection

Both Elisha, in our Haftarah, and Eliyahu, his great teacher, in "Melachim I," revived the dead.  RASHI comments in the case of Eliyahu that in order to perform this, the Prophet had to be provided with the "Mafteach shel Techiyat HaMetim," the "Key to the Revival of the Dead."

Whatever that "Key" was and is, we see that the phenomenon of the Restoration of the Soul, or the "Neshamah," has already been done on the "local level," meaning for one specific individual.  Indeed, the Prophet Yechezkel, the Prophet of the Exiles in Babylonia, was shown in a prophetic vision, "Techiyat HaMetim" occurring to a whole "Valley of Bones."  Therefore, not a great "leap of faith" is required to imagine that in the time of the Mashiach, the Master of the Universe will perform the same process on a grand and global scale.

From this point of view, it may not even have been necessary for the RAMBAM to have included this Principle, that HaShem will perform "Techiyat HaMetim," as the last of his Thirteen Principles of Faith.

Selected Commentary on the Haftarah

Section I

Melachim II, 4:1

"A certain woman" 

RADAK: 

Our tradition says that she was the wife of the Prophet Ovadiah, one of the prophets of the "Trei Asar,” the twelve prophets who prophesied during the interval of time between the destruction of the First temple and the building of the Second Temple.

This particular Prophet lived during the reign of King Achav and Queen Izevel, two wicked individuals, she worse than he, who wished to exterminate all the Prophets of HaShem.  He hid one hundred of the Prophets of HaShem in a cave, and supported them with food and drink.  In order to do this he had to borrow money.  He did this from the son of Achav, Yehoram, who is the creditor referred to in this section.  Yehoram violated the Command of the Torah that a lender is not allowed to charge interest on a loan to a fellow Jew (even though it is a legitimate business practice, appropriate for dealings with other individuals, but not with people whom you are to think of as your "brothers").

"…who feared G-d…"

RADAK:

Ovadiah was one of four individuals who are honored with the description of "having feared G-d."  They are Avraham, Yosef, Iyov (Job), and Ovadiah.  

Section 2

Melachim II, 4:8

"And there lived a great woman"

RADAK:

She was famous, rich and had an excellent reputation for her character.  According to the Midrash, she was the sister of Avishag HaShunamit, and the mother of Ido the  Prophet (the child born miraculously to her, who died and was brought back to life by Elisha).

Melachim II, 4:9

"Behold now, I realize that this is a holy man"

Metzudat David:

CHAZAL say that women are able to appreciate the nature of their guests to a greater extent than men.

Melachim II, 4:14

"And he said, 'What then is to be done for her?'  And Gechazi answered…"

RADAK:

Gechazi said to Elisha, "She has no need for what you asked her (a favor from the King or high public official).  But she does have a great need; that is, that she is childless.  And she has very little chance to have a child through the normal course of nature without a "nes," a miracle, for her husband is very elderly."

Melachim II, 4:29

"…and take my staff.."

RADAK:

"But Gechazi was unsuccessful, because he didn't take the possibility of success (bringing the boy back to life by using the staff of the Prophet) seriously enough (or maybe, because he bragged about it).  As he went, he would say, 'Do you believe that this staff can bring someone back to life!' "

Melachim II, 4:34

"…and he put his mouth upon his mouth…"

RADAK:

"As we explained with Eliyahu, the purpose was to make specific the prayer unto the one being prayed for, as we saw in connection with Yitzchak, where it says, "And Yitzchak prayed opposite his wife."

"It may also be true that he did this in order to provide some of his own bodily warmth to the boy, because in general a miracle requires some human effort in order to be successful."

Rabbi Pinchas Frankel

Rabbi Frankel is an Educational Coordinator at the OU

Archive