Re-Counting the Prophets - Rabbi Pinchas Frankel

Haftarah of Parshat Chaye Sarah - 5761

The Haftarah of Parshat Chaye Sarah, according to both the Sefardic and the Ashkenazic communities is taken this week from the Book of "Melachim"/Kings I, "Perek"/Chapter 1, "Pesukim"/Verses 1-31.

Connections between the Haftarah and the Parshah

Oddly enough, the following connection is not between the Parshah and the Haftarah.  Rather, it is between the Parshah and the Chapter of the Prophets immediately  preceding the Haftarah.  That Chapter is not even in the same Book, but rather in the  Book that has just been completed; namely Shmuel II.  This, incidentally, shows the continuity of this part of the Bible, where we find that from Yehoshua through  "Shoftim"/Judges through Shmuel I and II through "Melachim"/Kings I and II, the text is  one continuous narrative of the early centuries (approximately 700 years) of the residence of the Jewish People in the Land of Israel. The connection:

In the Parshah, Avraham wishes to purchase the Meorat HaMachpelah, which will become the Burial Place of the "Avot," the Forefathers and the "Imahot," the Founding Mothers of the Jewish People, located in Chevron, from Ephron HaChiti.  Ephron initially offers the property to Avraham as a gift.  Avraham declines to accept it as a gift and instead purchases it for a sum without bargaining, and with unquestionably legal tender.

Immediately preceding the Haftarah, at the end of the last chapter of Shmuel II, Chapter 24, Verses 18-25, we find the account of the purchase of another great spiritual treasure, the Temple Mount, the site of the Beit HaMikdash, by King David from Aravna HaYevusi.  Aravna also offers the site initially as a gift, but David refuses to accept it on those terms.  Anticipating that this will be the place of the Temple, he pays for the entire field in addition to the threshing floor that was the initial object of the purchase.

In the Parshah, the Torah teaches us about the activities of Avraham Avinu in his final years.  Avraham was the Founding Father of the Jewish People, who introduced into the world the idea of Monotheism, the Existence of One and Only One G-d, Who had Created the World, and everything in it, Who did not reside in the world, but in Whom the World resided.  He represented the Spiritual beginning and the Past of the Jewish People.

In the Haftarah, we learn of the activities of David HaMelech in his final years.  He was the one who conceived the idea of building the Beit HaMikdash for the Honor of HaShem, although he would not be allowed to build it, because he had been involved in wars, but rather it would be built by his son, Shelomoh HaMelech, King Solomon.  David represented the beginning of the Dynasty of Jewish Kings which, though absent from the world now, would ultimately re-appear in the person of the "Mashiach," the Anointed Redeemer of Israel.  Thus David represents the Destiny and the Future of the Jewish People.

In the Parshiyot that we are reading now, one of the major themes is the succession, and the blessing and inheritance of first Avraham - Yitzchak or Yishmael, then of Yitzchak - Yaakov or Esav.  These were titanic struggles for the inheritance of the Leadership of the Spiritual world, among the nations, and for the title of "The Chosen Nation."

In the Haftarah, we also find a continuation of the struggle among the sons of David for the succession to his throne.  In the Haftarah, we see the rebellion of Adoniyahu ben Chagit, who allied himself with Yoav ben Tzeruyah, as his Military Advisor and with Evyatar HaCohen, as his Spiritual Advisor.  Earlier, in Shmuel II, Chapter 18, there is recounted the end of the rebellion of Avshalom, a beloved son of David, with Avshalom's death.

In the Parshiyot, the attempt by Yishmael to be the heir of Avraham and to block the succession by Yitzchak is thwarted by "Sarah Imenu," the Founding Mother of the Jewish People, who was considered greater in prophecy than Avraham.  Likewise, the attempt by Esav to be the inheritor of Yitzchak and the recipient of his blessing, was thwarted by "Rivkah Imenu," who had the greater insight into the characters of her two sons, and loved Yaakov.

In the Haftarah, the rebellion of Adiniyahu is thwarted also through the efforts of a woman,  Bat-Sheva, mother of Shelomoh, and a prophet; namely Nathan the Prophet.

In this Parshah and nearby Parshiyot, we find that both Avraham and Sarah are "tested."  Last week, Avraham faced the ultimate test of Faith, and was about to obey HaShem's command to sacrifice his son, Yitzchak. In this week's Parshah, according to the Midrash, Sarah is informed of the Akeidah, and the shock of the idea of sacrificing Yitzchak is what kills her.  HaShem does not make things easy for his greatest heroes.  They will be fully rewarded in the World-to-Come.

In the Haftarah, and immediately preceding it, David is punished (at the end of Shmuel II) for counting the Jewish People not at the command of HaShem.  In the Haftarah, he is punished for his sin with Bat-Sheva, and he is unable to find warmth no matter how he tries and how his surrounding court tries for him by finding the beautiful and righteous Avishag HaShunamit to be his nurse and companion.

Summary and Selective Commentary on the Haftarah

Summary of the Haftarah

The Haftarah is divided into five sections:

Section 1

King David is very old, and is unable to become warm, no matter how many coverings are used to cover him. A beautiful woman is sought to be his bedside companion, and the beautiful and righteous virgin who is selected is Avishag HaShunamit.  She assumes her duties but the King does not live with her.

Section 2

A conspiracy forms around Prince Adoniyahu, son of Chagit, who has never been disciplined effectively by his father, to make him give up his royal ambitions.  The conspiracy includes the general Yoav ben Tzeruyah, the Priest Evyatar but excludes those who remain loyal to David: Tzadok HaCohen. The general Benayahu ben Yehoyada, the Prophet Nathan, and the warriors Shimi and Geri.  Adoniyahu makes a celebration, to which he invites the other princes, sons of David, but pointedly excludes Shelomoh.

Section 3

The Prophet Nathan approaches Bat-Sheva to discuss a mission vital to her life, the life of her son, and probably the lives of the others who have remained loyal to David.  He advises her to approach the King and remind him that he had promised the succession to Shelomoh, and to inquire why then had Adoniyahu assumed the role of heir apparent?  Nathan says that he will enter the conversation at that point and fill in additional information.

Section 4

Bat-Sheva follows Nathan's advice and enters the inner chambers of the King.  She reminds him of his oath to her that her son would be King after him, and informs him that Adoniyahu has just about assumed the Kingship already.  He has sacrificed a multitude of sacrifices, and important officers are involved in the would-be coronation,  but she and Shelomoh and other loyalists have been excluded.  She says that her life and Shelomo's are in danger if the King does not intervene.

Nathan enters at that point and asks the King if he has indeed changed his mind and decided to award the succession to Adoniyahu.  For a celebration is already in progress, to which he and Tzadok and Benayahu and Shelomoh have not been invited.  Has the King authorized the acts of Adoniyahu?

Section 5

David calls Bat-Sheva to return to his presence and renews his oath to her that Shelomoh her son will rule after him, and he will begin the implementation of this royal edict this very day!  Bat-Sheva returns, bows to him, and says "May His Majesty the King live forever!"

Selective Commentary on the Haftarah

"Melachim" I (1:1)

"And King David was old"

RADAK: He was seventy, which we know because he began to rule at the age of thirty and he ruled forty years

"And they covered him with garments, but they didn't warm him"

RASHI: CHAZAL say that the garments didn't warm him because he had shamed the garments of King Shaul when he cut a corner off his royal robe when Shaul was pursuing him, to show him that he could have killed him but refrained from doing so. 

Melachim I (1,6)

"And the King did not discipline him from the time of his youth"

RASHI:  From this we learn that he who does not discipline his child endangers his life.

Melachim I (1,7)

"And his plans included Yoav ben Tzeruyah…"

RASHI explains why Yoav ben Tzeruyah was selected by Adoniyahu.  The reason was that he knew that Yoav would be a willing participant because Yoav knew that David was angry with him for his role in the killing of Avshalom and in the killing of Avner and Amasa bnei Yeter.  Yoav knew that David would command his successor to replace him, so Adoniyahu thought that Yoav would shift his loyalty from David to himself as a part of the conspiracy.

Rabbi Pinchas Frankel

Rabbi Frankel is an Educational Coordinator at the OU

Archive