A Second Opinion - Rabbi Pinchas Frankel
Shabbat Parshat Beha'alotecha 5762

A Common Aspect of the Menorah and the Human Being

At the beginning of Parshat Beha'alotecha, we learn of HaShem's command to Aharon to light the Menorah in the Mishkan.  The Menorah was such a remarkable "piece of work" that Moshe Rabbeinu at first could not picture it in his mind's eye, until HaShem showed him a vision of it.  One of the aspects of its uniqueness was that it was "all of a piece," a single block of gold, as  RASHI explains in his commentary on the word "Mikshah," "of a piece" (Bamidbar 8:4), that was  chiseled and hammered out with such precision and beauty that the Menorah became a single,  and singular entity.  Its branches were arrayed in their correct form and place, and they were not  "attached" in the usual manner as separate pieces.

Its light represented the light of Torah, also a single and singular entity, the "Blueprint of the World" used by the Master Architect in His Creation of the Universe.  The human being, created "B'tzelem Elokim," in the "image of G-d," is also a single and singular entity, a potential source of Torah and spiritual light.  He or she is a "block of gold chiseled and hammered out" by HaShem, the "Tzayar HaOlamim," the Supreme Artist of the World, in such a manner that all his or her branches are arrayed in their correct form and place.

Modern science has only just begun to shed light on the mechanism by which a single genetic source, though betraying no apparent potential for specificity, can be "chiseled and hammered out" such that it becomes a source for cells of the heart, the brain, the eye, etc.

A single source of light inhabits the entire body.  It is the "Ner Elokim" - the "Lamp of G-d," "Nishmat Adam" - the "Soul of the human being" that is "Chofes kol Chadrei Baten," that "examines and illuminates all the chambers of the body."

We are beginning to learn how for the blind, additional areas in the brain are enlarged, developed and enlightened, such that the given individual can develop his human and Torah potential, that are in fact one and the same.  That is why it is about the blind Rabbi Yose, whom the Talmud is still able to refer to as "Rabbi Yose Sagi Nahor," "Rabbi Yossi, full of light," that the Talmud also says, "whatever Rabbi Yose says can be assumed to be correct."

The Laws of Damages obligate the criminal who has caused another human being to lose a limb, to pay vast sums of money in damages.  It is thus possible to "ransom" a limb, because a fatal blow was not dealt to the victim.  The "Neshamah," the "Soul," is still present in the injured party.  Only for murder, for the taking of life, the robbing of the Neshamah, can there be no ransom, and therefore must the punishment be "a life for a life."

This interplay of body and soul, the idea that even a diminished body can be inhabited by an  undiminished soul, would seem to be a basic idea in Judaism,  implicit in the Blessing that  a Jew recites at least three times a day in the "Shemoneh Esray" (the "Eighteen," the fundamental Prayer), that G-d is the "Faithful and Merciful Physician of the World."  G-d is able, as it were, to perform the process of "Tzimtzum," "Contraction," upon His Infinite Self in order to relate to the  finite and mortal creatures of His world, so is He able, by an analogous process of "Tzimtzum," to contract an infinite human Soul so that it can continue to occupy a damaged body.

At the end of the Parshah, Moshe begs HaShem to heal his sister, who had been stricken when, in an attempt to intervene in behalf of Tzipporah, Moshe’s wife from whom he had separated, she minimized the greatness of her brother.  Moshe uttered the prayer “E-l na, refa na lah;” “Lord, I beg of you, please heal her.”  It is in connection with the healing power of G-d in keeping our bodies and souls together, that we see the wondrous power of HaShem, as we say in the Blessing of “Asher Yatzar,” that HaShem “heals all flesh in a wondrous manner.”

Rabbi Pinchas Frankel

Archive