A Second Opinion - Rabbi Pinchas Frankel

Parshat Yitro - 5761

The Six Remembrances

The "Shloshim," the thirty-day period that is the second most intense after the "Shivah," the original seven-day period of mourning for my mother, is complete.  At this point, the custom is for the "Avel," the Mourner, to provide a "Tikkun," a mini-"breakfast" after the final Shacharit  of the "Shloshim," for the congregants who have shared in his prayers for the month.  The    purpose is that the congregants may make "brachot," blessings, on the food and the "avel" can respond with "Amen" and the participants can express the wish that the soul of the  departed will experience an "aliyah," an elevation in its heavenly status and the "avel" can  respond "Amen" as well to that blessing.  One of my fellow congregants remarked to me that I must be a real "Shabbat Jew" (would that it were true!).  He meant that I seem to "daven" so-o slowly on Shabbat and so f-fast on weekdays.

This fast "davening" is a necessary evil during the week to allow people to get to their jobs on time. It occurred to me that a review of the "Six Remembrances" listed in the Siddur to be reviewed each  morning after Shacharit, but almost universally ignored for the reason mentioned above, might be a timely subject, especially in view of the fact that one of the remembrances plays a central role in Parshat Yitro.

The Six Remembrances are the following:

The Exodus

In Devarim 16:3, we find, "That you may remember the day of your Exodus from Egypt all the days of your life."  One is immediately reminded of the disagreement in the Haggadah, the text of the Seder, between Ben Zoma and the Sages, where Ben Zoma says, "the days"  refer, literally, to the daylight hours of one's life, while "all the days" includes the night-time  hours.  This means that one should recite the "Kriat Shema," the Prayer whose basic themes are  the Unity of G-d, the obligation upon the Jew to observe all the commandments, and the command to wear "Tzitzit," the fringes dyed with "techeilet," the blue-colored dye, the color of the sea as a reminder of the Exodus and the Splitting of the Sea, both by day and by night.

The Sages add another level of meaning, when they say that "the days" refers to the Pre-Messianic World, while "all the days" includes the time of the Mashiach.  Meaning that the lessons of the Exodus concerning the Might of HaShem, His Will to  intervene in human history and His Morality (indeed, as the "Author of Morality") that He displayed and taught at  that time will remain significant even after the Jewish People will have experienced the miracles of the  Final Redemption.

The Giving of the Torah

The Second Remembrance concerns the event that occupies center stage in Parshat Yitro, "Maamad Har Sinai," perhaps the peak event in human history, when HaShem transmitted the Torah to the Jewish People at Mt. Sinai.  The command appears in Devarim 4:9-10, ”Only be aware and guard yourselves carefully, lest you forget the things that your eyes have seen, and lest they stray from your heart all the days of your life… - the day that you stood before HaShem, your G-d, at Sinai."

One might ask, "Why is it not sufficient to simply (of course, it's not so simple) become an expert in the Torah.   Why is it necessary to recall the manner in which the Torah was given to Man?"

One answer is that it is essential to know and remember that the Torah is different from all other "possessions" of Man, in that "Torah min HaShamayim," the Torah is of Divine origin.  As we pray on Rosh HaShanah, "You revealed Yourself in the Cloud of Your Glory to Your Holy Nation to speak with them.  From Heaven did they hear your Word, and Your Holy Utterances, from flames of fire."  It was the failure to remember this fact that tragically led millions of our co-religionists astray.

The Act of Amalek

In Devarim 25:17-19, we find, "Remember what Amalek did to you on the way out of Mitzrayim.  How he encountered you on the way and cut down the weaklings trailing behind you, while you were faint and exhausted, and he did not fear G-d….You are to erase the memory of Amalek from under the heaven.  Do not forget."

Earlier in the Torah, in Shemot 17:16, we find, "…a state of war exists between HaShem and Amalek, from generation to generation."

The question arises, "Why is Amalek different from Egypt, concerning which HaShem told the Jewish People to be quiet and let Him fight for them, and Amalek, where HaShem, so to speak, needs the help of the Jewish People?"  One answer may lie in the principle that "Everything is in G-d's hands, so to speak, except for the fear of heaven."  And the Torah says specifically that Amalek did not fear G-d; so HaShem, as it were, needed the help of the Jewish People against this implacable foe, who represents absolute evil, and does not fear G-d.

The Golden Calf

"Remember, do not forget, how you angered HaShem, in the desert" (Devarim 9:7).

This is a reference to the tragic sin committed by the Jewish People, while yet at the foot of Mt. Sinai, the worship of the Golden Calf.  Adorned with "edyam me'Har Chorev,"  their "spiritual jewelry attained at Mt. Chorev (Sinai)," the "impatient People" who had reached celestial heights when they said "We will obey and afterwards we will understand," had lost patience in waiting for the return of Moshe.  For this disloyalty and unfaithfulness, the impetuous People earned the comparison to a "shameful bride who committed adultery while yet under her marriage canopy," and were required to take off the "jewelry" earned at Chorev.

Miriam's Sin

"Remember what HaShem did to Miriam on the way, when you left Egypt"  (Devarim 24:9).

This is a reference to the time when Miriam, the great prophetess who earlier, while still in Mitzrayim, had urged her father, Amram, to re-marry Yocheved and who had echoed Moshe's great Song of the Sea for the women of Israel,  had underestimated the level of holiness that Moshe was on.  Allowing herself to be blinded by the pain of a fellow woman, Tzipporah, Moshe's wife, she had criticized Moshe for separating himself from his wife, so as to be "on call" to HaShem at all times.

The lesson to be drawn is that if the great Miriam, with pure intentions, was punished harshly for criticizing Moshe, how careful must we be not to speak ill of a fellow human being.

The Holiness of the Shabbat

The Torah says, "Remember the Shabbat Day to keep it holy"  (Shemot 20:8).

The Sages associate this Command mainly with the obligation to recite the "Kiddush," usually recited over wine, at the Shabbat meal.

Indeed, wine is associated, via Purim and Pesach with remembering and also with forgetting.

With respect to Purim, the Talmud tells us in Masechet Megillah that one is required to drink wine or liquor on that day until the point where one "cannot distinguish between 'Arur Haman' (Cursed be Haman) and 'Baruch Mordechai' (Blessed be Mordechai)."  One possible interpretation of this unusual requirement is that the Jew should drink until his emotions are  raised and enhanced to the point where he or she can no longer distinguish between the two possible methods of enhancing the degree of "good" in the world; namely, the destruction of evil ("Arur Haman!") and the direct blessing of righteous Mordechai ("Baruch Mordechai!").  One can only remember this truth by forgetting the hatred of and prejudice against one's enemies.

On Pesach, we drink four cups of wine at the Seder.  The Family Seder is a time of Exaltation, of identification with one's fellow Jews across all time and space.  It is a time of enhanced memory.  "In every generation, the individual is obligated to view himself as if he or she actually was redeemed from Mitzrayim;" we make the blessing praising G-d as the One Who redeemed "us and our forefathers."

"Yayin," wine, has the ability, on Shabbat and the Holidays, to raise the Jew out of his finite frame of reference into an infinite frame of reference.  He or she is now able to view events, to an extent, from the "perspective of eternity."

One More Remembrance

Jewish Tradition requires that a person be careful to remember and never to forget  his or her mother's name.  One might see in this the additional requirement to remember, and never to neglect, oneself, because the mother's very existence was intertwined with her child's.  Be that as it may, it would be very difficult to forget you, mother, for so wonderful (as Eddie Fisher (though the reference may "date" me) used to sing of his "papa") were you to me, to each and every member of my family, and to all who knew you.

Rabbi Pinchas Frankel
Rabbi Frankel is an Educational Coordinator at the OU

Archive