A Second Opinion - Rabbi Pinchas Frankel

Parshat Vayetze - 5761

The First Exile

The "Parshat HaShavua," the Weekly Portion of the Torah that will be read this Shabbat, Parshat VaYetze, begins (Bereshit 28:10), "Vayetze Yaakov MiBe'er Sheva, vayelech Charanah," "And Yaakov left Be'er Sheva, and traveled towards Charan."  Over and above the significance of this  event in his life and in the life of his family, which was extremely great - perhaps still greater was its significance, from the perspective of the  Jewish People as a whole.  For, using the principle of "Maasei Avot Siman LeBanim," "Actions of the  Forefathers are models for their descendants," this departure of Yaakov from Be'er Sheva can be seen as the first "Galut," the first Exile, of the Jewish People.

In a sense, it was also the first expulsion, for Yaakov was forced by events, and by the requirement to obey his mother, to leave the Land of Israel.  And he was to travel to a dangerous place, a place rife with idol worship and thievery.  His destination was the home of Lavan, his uncle who, in the end, would try to rob him of all his "possessions," including his wives, his children and all his property and who, in the words of the Pesach Haggadah, "wanted to uproot everything."

During his stay in the household of Lavan, Yaakov enacted the experience of his descendants in a thousand locations.  We read (Bereshit 31:38-42), "These twenty years I have been with you, your ewes and she-goats never miscarried, nor did I eat rams from your flock.  That which was mangled I never brought you - I myself would bear the loss.  In the case of a theft, you would deduct it from me, whether it was stolen by day or stolen by night.  By day, heat scorched me; frost consumed me by night; sleep wandered from my eyes."

"This was my twenty years in your household:  I served you for fourteen years for your two daughters, and six years for a percentage of your flocks; and you changed my salary ten times!  Had not the G-d of my father - the G-d of Avraham and the 'One Who Aroused Dread in Yitzchak' - been with me, you would surely have sent me away empty-handed…"

In a sense, this journey of Yaakov was the reverse image of the journey that his grandfather, Avraham, had made early in the activities that he undertook in "partnership," so to speak, with the "Ribbono shel Olam," the Master of the Universe.  HaShem had commanded him, as we read several weeks ago (Bereshit 12:1), "…Go forth from your land, and from your birthplace, and from the house of your father, to the Land that I will show you."  This was the first "Aliyah," the first "going up," especially in the spiritual sense, to the Holy Land.  

Thus we see HaShem, operating in the world according to the principle that "He creates the healing before the injury;" the "Aliyah," the "Geulah," or Redemption, before the "Galut," or Exile.

Yaakov's own father, Yitzchak, having consecrated the "Har HaBayit," the Temple Mount, with the intended sacrifice of himself at the "Akeidat Yitzchak," had risen to the highest level of holiness and was never permitted to leave the Holy Land.

Yaakov teaches us how to fortify oneself for life in the "Galut."  On the way to his uncle's house, he spends fourteen years in the "Yeshivah" of Shem and Ever, son and grandson, respectively, of  Noach, the Captain of Noah's Ark, who saved humanity and all forms of non-aquatic life on earth, and who passed down all, or most, of his spirituality to his son, Shem.  Shem and Ever founded a "Beit Midrash," an "Academy of Study" of the "Torah."  Now the curriculum of this "Yeshivah" is a  fascinating subject in itself, for there was taught the "Torah" generations before HaShem would give his "holy treasure" to the Jewish People on Mt. Sinai.  But, whatever the subject matter was, it  contained the Foundations of the Torah, principles of thought and behavior that would later be revealed at Sinai.

Having integrated this learning into his personality, Yaakov was prepared to deal with everything that  the evil "Lavan," the hypocritical "White One," was able to throw his way.  He would be able to say "Im Lavan garti, ve'Taryag Mitzvot Shamarti," "Although I lived with Lavan, I was still able to observe the entire Torah (all 613 Mitzvot contained therein)!"

This fortification with Torah is so necessary to survive spiritually in "Galut," in the embrace of a foreign culture.  One bus-ride down Broadway, taking in the billboard advertisements, one walk in the "new" Times Square, is enough to undo years of religious upbringing.  One's only chance at self-defense is the integration of a system of values, not man-made, that emphasizes "Kedushah," holiness, and enables one to come to grips with and defeat Lavan and "Saro shel Esav," the Representative of Esav, the "Yetzer HaRa," one's aroused Inclination towards Sin."

When Yaakov felt ready, when his family, the nucleus of the People of Israel, was complete, Yaakov made the decision to return to "Eretz Yisrael," the Holy Land of Israel.  Upon his arrival, the Midrash tells us that he had not yet found peace.  "Bikesh Yaakov leyshev b'shalvah, kafatz alav rugzo shel Yoseph;" "Just as Yaakov thought that he would finally be able to find peace, the tragedy of Yoseph engulfed him" (Bereshit Rabbah 84:6).  Even in the Holy Land, major problems and bitter struggles had yet to be fought.

In our time, the struggle of "Medinat Yisrael" with the Palestinians, and the infinitely more important struggle of "Yisrael Sava," "Grandfather Yisrael," the true Spirit of Jewish Destiny, with his "enlightened and sophisticated, willfully ignorant and self-destructive" descendants, are fully engaged.  We pray that the outcomes of these struggles will be as it was with "Yaakov Avinu" (Bereshit 32:29), "for you have been engaged in spiritual combat with Angels, and in physical combat with men; and you have prevailed."

May we soon see the movement of our entire People "me'afelah l'or gadol," from thick darkness to great light.  And, as we pray in the "Kinot," the Lamentations of Tishah B'Av,  may the sorrow and travail of "betzaitainu mi'Yerushalayim," of our "Departure from Yerushalayim" be replaced by the joy of the sons and daughters of Yaakov who became Yisrael, "beshuveinu li'Yerushalayim," "upon our return to Yerushalayim."

Rabbi Pinchas Frankel
Rabbi Frankel is an Educational Coordinator at the OU

Archive