A Second Opinion - Rabbi Pinchas Frankel

Parshat Vaera - 5761

Human Arrogance and Hard Lessons

Now that a new administration is settling in, in Washington, and new elections are anticipated soon in Eretz Yisrael, it is appropriate to speak of new beginnings.  In the Garden of Eden, "Adam HaRishon," First Man, and "Chava," the first "First Lady" or the "First Woman," were commanded not to eat from the "Eitz HaDaat," the Tree of Knowledge.  A clever and subtle member of the original staff  spoke on the record with Chava,  and advised her that it was not necessary to obey that command.  So she disobeyed, and easily convinced her husband likewise to disobey.  When questioned concerning these events there were initial denials followed by some finger-pointing, but the truth came out, and the rest is history (Bereshit 2:15-3:24).

The Greeks tell a tale, similar in some respects.  Prometheus stole the sacred fire from Zeus and was punished by the chief god in the following grisly manner: that he would be chained to a rock for all  eternity and an eagle (the "national bird" of the USA), others say a vulture, would feast on his liver  each day, for his liver would be renewed in the evening.  This continued until another god strangled the bird.

The Creator in the Bible had a different idea for the "punishment" of the human race.  That was to give them more commands, since one was apparently too few, first just seven to all of humanity, ultimately to one People, the Torah, containing six hundred thirteen commands.

But knowledge is very precious, knowledge of the Torah, and knowledge of the world.  And perhaps it was the underlying desire of the Creator that the human race pursue knowledge, of both types, the first combined with a spirit of reverence and humility, the second somewhat "colder," basically involving only the Divinely-given gift of logic.

With the eating of the "Eitz HaDaat," another challenge had also come into the world.  That was the challenge of the "Yetzer HaRa," the so-called "Evil" Inclination.  Really the element of desire, creative energy, together with the controlling element of "Bechirah Chofshit," Free Will, by which the human being chooses which way to direct his or her desire.

"Reshit Chochmah Yirat HaShem," "The beginning of wisdom is the fear of Heaven."  The most important type of Knowledge is the Knowledge, and the Acknowledgement, of HaShem.  This "Knowledge" involves the correct perception of the relationship between the Creator and the created being.  From the point of view of the latter, this is the relationship of servant to Master.  And that relationship is in conflict with another aspect of the human being that was revealed when the "Eitz HaDaat" was tasted; the aspect of "self" or "ego."

Another Creation, that came into being over time, was the People of Israel.  This nation was charged with a special purpose, that of accepting the Torah, and teaching its laws to the rest of the world.  This People was the "Servant of G-d" par excellence, as exemplified by its founder, Avraham, who was prepared to sacrifice his beloved son, Yitzchak, his future, his destiny, his ego, to HaShem.

On the opposite pole from "Avraham Avinu," according to Pirkei Avot 5:22, is "Bilaam HaRasha," Bilaam, the Wicked Prophet of the non-Jewish world, who was blessed with gifts at least equal to those of "Moshe Rabbeinu," but who wasted and spoiled those gifts.  Avot says, "Whoever has the following three traits is among the disciples of our forefather Avraham, and whoever has three other traits is among the disciples of the wicked Bilaam.  Those who have a generous eye, a humble spirit, and who is not self-centered, is from the disciples of our forefather Avraham.  Those who have an "evil eye," an arrogant spirit, and a greedy soul are from the disciples of the wicked Bilaam…"

Bilaam does not himself appear in this Parshah, indeed not in the entire Book of Shemot, and we  don't come across his nasty self until the Book of BaMidbar, but our Tradition does identify him as   one of the panel of advisors that Pharaoh, King of Egypt, convened to advise him concerning his plan to drown all Jewish baby boys.  The other advisors were Iyov and Yitro, the future father-in-law of Moshe.  Yitro, wanting to have no  part of the genocidal plan, fled.  Iyov kept silent, and was therefore, according to this Midrash, punished.  Bilaam avidly supported the idea that was adopted by Pharaoh, as recorded in last week's Parshah.

We meet Pharaoh most directly in this week's Parshah, Vaera.  He reveals himself to share an aspect of Bilaam's personality; namely an extremely arrogant spirit.  As I mention in a discussion on the Haftarah, he refuses to release his Jewish slaves, even after being told time after time that this is the command of the Creator of the Universe, and despite receiving blow upon blow for his stubbornness.

In the Haftarah, we are also struck by his arrogance, as we hear him say, "My River is Mine, and I have created it" (Yechezkel 29:3), having convinced himself that somehow he is a god and a creator.

Of course, the Jewish People was not exempt from equal or even harsher treatment when it was deserved, as Moshe let them know in the "Tochachot," the frighteningly accurate predictions of the horrors that would befall the Jewish People when it would forget the nature of its relationship to HaShem.  

But in the end, as Moshe foretells in Devarim 30:2-3, "You will return to the L-rd your G-d, and you will obey Him…you and your children, with all your heart and with all your soul.  Then HaShem will return your captives and He will have mercy upon you, and He will return, and He will gather you from all the nations among which the L-rd your G-d scattered you."

To close this essay as I close the one on this week's Haftarah: In the Haftarah, Yechezkel speaks of an Exile and a Redemption as part of the destiny of the Egyptian Nation, ”…after forty years, I will gather in Mitzrayim from the nations among which they were scattered.  And I will return the captivity of Mitzrayim…" (Yechezkel 29:13-14).

In Yeshayahu 19:19-25, there is a series of enigmatic verses, that are interpreted in two radically different ways.  They speak, on the surface, in positive terms, that the Master of the Universe will begin the ingathering of the human race, beginning with the Egyptian and the Assyrian Peoples, at the End-of-Days.  These positive images include the Repentance of both of those Peoples.  And the final verses there are:

"In that Day shall Israel be the third and highest, followed by Egypt and Assyria, a blessing in the midst of the earth; for that the L-rd of Hosts has blessed him, saying, 'Blessed be Egypt My People, and Assyria the work of My Hands, and Israel Mine Inheritance."

RASHI explains the above blessings as all being upon the head of Israel, because of events that took place in connection with the other two nations.  But RADAK explains the verses more, it would seem, in line with the plain meaning of the text, as explained above.

And indeed there is a Biblical reference to the People of Ashur doing "Teshuvah," when the Prophet Yonah announced to them that "in another forty days," Nineveh (capital of Ashur) will be overturned!"  The King of Ashur took those words to heart and led his people in doing complete Teshuvah, which caused the definition of "overturned" to be changed from destruction, at that time, to renewal.

Let us hope that with the new administration in this country and, hopefully, with changed  leadership in Israel and, most important, with firm reliance on the G-d of our Fathers, we will begin to see and hear good news from Eretz Yisrael, "Reshit Tzemichat Geulateinu," "the beginning of the sprouting of our Redemption."

Rabbi Pinchas Frankel
Rabbi Frankel is an Educational Coordinator at the OU

Archive