A Second Opinion - Rabbi Pinchas Frankel

Parshat Lech Lecha - 5761

The First RASHI - Revisited

In the essay related to Parshat Bereshit, I mentioned that we need the first RASHI now as never before, as we battle with the Muslims over the right of possession of the Holy Land and of Jerusalem in particular.  In his first comment on the Torah, RASHI quotes Rabbi Yitzchak as asking in the Midrash Tanchuma, "Why does the Torah begin where it does?  Should it not begin in Shemot 12:2, where the Jewish People are given their first communal Mitzvah, Sanctification of the New Moon at the beginning of each month?"

Rabbi Yitzchak, in the Midrash, answers, "It was to teach the world the principle stated by "David HaMelech," King David, in Psalms 111:6; namely, 'He has declared to His People the power of His works.' So that if the nations of the world say to Israel, 'You are thieves, for you took possession of the land of the Seven Nations by force,' they will be able to answer, 'All the world belongs to G-d.  He Created it, and gave it to whomever He wished.  It was His Will that it first be allocated to those Nations, and it was by His Will that it be taken from them and given to us.' "

I pointed out there that this understanding of Rabbi Yitzchak is incomplete, for the Muslims can argue, "Just as He gave it to you once, so He has now determined to take it from you and give it to us."  So when we look more closely at Rabbi Yitzchak's words, we see that he meant that the whole Book of Bereshit and the beginning of the Book of Shemot make it clear that HaShem promised to Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov, that the Land of Israel would ultimately belong to their descendants, the Jewish People.  The beginning of that chain would be with the "seed of Avraham," and that "seed" refers  to Yitzchak, and not to Yishmael!  The decisive proof of this comes when HaShem tells Avraham to listen to Sarah when she demands that Avraham send Hagar and Yishmael away, "for it is in Yitzchak that your seed will be called" (Bereshit 21:12)

I would like to extend here the idea of Rabbi Yitzchak to include that, in this Parshah of "Lech Lecha," we see Avraham performing an act of conquering, very real in itself, but also by which he symbolically took possession of the Land for his  descendants, and that this act was ratified by HaShem in the "Brit Bein HaBetarim," the Covenant  that took place "among the pieces."  By this act, Avraham was performing "Maasei Avot,"an "Act of the Forefathers" that is considered to be "Siman LeBanim," a "symbolic and reference act for later acts in history performed by their descendants."

This idea was found in "Binah BaMikra," the collection of "Divrei Torah" on the Parshiyot of the Week  by HaRav Yissachar Yaakovson that was originally conceived, in 1950, as educational radio presentations on "Kol Yisrael" in the newborn Jewish State, in order to familiarize the population with the great texts of its heritage.

The author/editor cites M.D. Kassuto who points to the relationship between the War Among the Kings, recounted in Chapter 14, and the "Brit bein HaBetarim," described in Chapter 15.  In Chapter 14, a cataclysmic "World War" is described, in which five subjugated Kingdoms rebel against an Alliance of Four Kings, and are soundly defeated.  Avraham is called upon to undertake the heroic role of fighting against the victorious and vastly outnumbering forces of the Four Kings, in order to rescue his nephew, Lot.  In Chapter 15, that recounts the "Brit bein HaBetarim," Avraham is promised, in the course of that Covenant, the Land that was just conquered by the Four Kings, whom he has defeated.

Thus, the later conquests by Moshe and Yehoshua, of Lands abutting and comprising "Eretz Yisrael" were in fact re-conquests of Land that had already been conquered in actuality, but also symbolically, by the courageous Father of the Nation, Avraham Avinu.

One thing we see is that a "Promise by HaShem" of a certain outcome is not enough to guarantee its actualization.  An element of "hishtadlut," "human effort," is required to bring even a promise by the One Whose Seal is Truth from potential to reality.  Avraham had to go to war against the Four Kings, in order to achieve the ratification by HaShem of his ownership of the Land in the "Brit bein HaBetarim."

HaShem of course came to the miraculous aid of Avraham as with his 318 troops, he administered a decisive defeat to his opponents.   As he would come to the miraculous aid of Moshe, on the outskirts of the Holy Land, and of Yehoshua in the body of the Land as, led by the "Aron," the Ark of the L-rd, they marched against their opponents.

And as He came to the miraculous aid of the Jewish People in 1948, after the nightmare of the "Holocaust," perhaps also foreshadowed by two centuries of slavery in Egypt, in the "Milchemet HaShichrur," the War for Independence, after nearly two thousand years in Exile.

So that if our "cousins," the Arabs, had only honestly read the Bible, and not tampered with it, they would have seen that it was to the Jewish People that the Holy Land of Israel was given by the L-rd.  And that it is on the Temple Mount that the Third Temple will be built by the "Mashiach."

The face of "Eretz Yisrael" is hard to gauge.  On one hand, there is much ignorance and corruption  and immorality.  Yet, at the same time, there is more Torah being learned there now than perhaps at any time since Biblical times.  Therefore, we will not lose hope of Redemption and of "Teshuvah," Repentance, and of great things to come, including the fairly imminent arrival of the "Mashiach."

It is likely that we have entered the period of time known as "Ikvesa de-Mashicha," the "ushering in of the time of the Mashiach;" but, even if not, and because of our unworthiness, our wait is still to be prolonged, we will say with our ancestors, "And even if he may delay, I anticipate every day that he will come." (Twelfth Principle of Faith of the RAMBAM)

Rabbi Pinchas Frankel
Rabbi Frankel is an Educational Coordinator at the OU

Archive