OU TORAH
Rabbi Avrohom Gordimer - Simchat Torah 5767
Chazal (our sages) relate that Moshe saw not only the physical aspects of Eretz Yisroel on that final day of his life; Moshe was also shown the panorama of Jewish history in the Land, including the conquest and settlement of the nation, its struggles and successes, and the depth of Torah learning that would ensue. Moshe was shown the span of Jewish life in Eretz Yisroel until the End of Days. (See Midrashim, Targum Yonasan ben Uziel and Rashi.)
Perhaps this can enable us to understand why Hashem told Moshe, 'This is the Land...but you will not pass therein.' This statement was not one of chastisement or admonishment; rather, it was God's way of actually comforting Moshe. Hashem was proclaiming, 'Look Moshe - your devoted care and leadership will have eternal consequences. The people you weaned, tended to and led for 40 years will have developed into an everlasting nation defined by Torah adherence and learning. They will be at the forefront of welcoming in the Eschatological Era. Your life's mission of leading K'lal Yisroel was a smashing success with fully permanent value, even though you will not take the nation into the Land. Your role was fulfilled to such a degree that the nation will prosper and develop even without your presence in the Land, such was the extent of your success.'
We sometimes hear of the passing of monumental Torah leaders who leave behind few or no physical remnants of their greatness. These giants may not have authored seforim or even built new institutions. However, their greatness endures forever through those upon whom they had an impact, for such people carry on the teachings and/or influence of the monumental leader and change Jewish history forever. No seforim or institutions are needed; a living, eternal legacy and permanent, critical impact was made nonetheless. This is what God was telling Moshe in His final Divine encounter. Even without bringing the people into Eretz Yisroel, Moshe Rabbeinu was assured that his leadership was fully impactful and enduring. Moshe then left the world knowing that his task was accomplished in full, and he passed away aware of his eternal success, lacking any sense that his accomplishments were marred by any shortcomings.
------------------------------------------------------------
'And Moshe was 120 years old at his death; his eye had not dimmed and his vitality had not waned.' (Devarim 34:7) Why does the Torah relate the good physical condition of Moshe Rabbeinu upon his passing? It seems unlikely that the purpose is to demonstrate 'Kovod Ha-Torah', that Moshe, the talmid chochom par excellence, remained in a state of physical prowess and perfection until his end; for Moshe also suffered from a speech impediment, and he was hardly representative of complete physical perfection.
Chazal relate that Moshe's prophetic vision was 'bi-aspaklaria ha-me'irah' - 'with a perfectly clear lens', for whereas other prophets experienced visions and dreams that were symbolic of a Divine message, Moshe merited to hear and convey the word of God directly. This concept is key to the issue at hand.
Parshas V'zos Ha-beracha centers around the uniqueness of Moshe's prophecy and stature. As such, the transition of leadership from Moshe to Yehoshua was more than a handing over of control to another leader. With Moshe's passing, the direct prophetic connection was to terminate. This is what the Torah is underscoring by depicting the vigor of Moshe through his last day. Most leaders are overtaken by signs of age, and they gradually pass on aspects of their responsibility to their successors. These successors are seen as similar to those whose roles they take over. In the case of Moshe, it was different. There could be no replacement or true successor of Moshe as a navi, and a gradual transition was therefore not feasible nor desirable. By emphasizing Moshe's physical signs that indicated a lack of aging and slowing down, the Torah declares Moshe's greatness as a prophet by stating that he remained in his position until the literal end, as a real replacement, whose prophetic qualities were comparable to those of Moshe, was not possible.
------------------------------------------------------------
In light of the above concepts, perhaps we can better understand why Simchas Torah serves as the conclusion and pinnacle of the Sukkos period.
Once we have become purified through the forgiveness granted on Yom Kippur, we merit to enter the sukkah, representative of envelopment in kedushah (holiness), for dwelling in the sukkah commemorates the dwelling of B'nei Yisroel in the Midbar (Desert) under God's protective veil. Life in the sukkah reflects a state of existence in which one lives in the shadow of God, as it were. This is precisely why the Beis Ha-Mikdash (Temple) is referred to as a sukkah in our liturgy, as the Beis Ha-Mikdash is the locus of experiencing the Shechinah (Divine Presence) in this world.
Once we exit the sukkah after a mere week, how are we to retain that sense of living in the veil of Hashem? How can we experience His Presence beyond the sukkah as we return to 'normal' life? The answer is Torah. Immersion in Torah study is the one connection that we always have. As Chazal stated, 'After the Beis Ha-Mikdash was destroyed, all that God has left in this world is the four cubits of halacha.' By immersing ourselves into Torah learning, we again become enveloped with kedushah and enter into an encounter with the Shechinah.
This is the message of Simchas Torah. We leave the sukkah, but we do not leave God's Presence. We take with us the experience of being enveloped in kedushah and perpetuate it via our Torah study and commitment to never depart from the Torah, renewing that commitment by starting the Torah afresh and building our year around it. Torah is God's direct connection with Man, and we celebrate and highlight this through Simchas Torah.
