Shabbat Shalom  |  Food Column  |  OURadio.org  ShopOU.org  NCSY.org  NJCD.org  |  OU.org

June 19, 2008
It’s Not Gush Katif
By Ann Goldberg
image
“We’re at Nezer Hazani,” the woman sitting next to me called into her cell-phone. “I’ll be back in a couple of hours.”

Obviously someone was arguing with her at the other end.

“I said we’re in Nezer Hazani”, she insisted.

I tapped her on the shoulder.

“We’re not at Nezer Hazani,” I whispered. “We’re at Kibbutz Ein Zurim where the people expelled from Nezer Hazani, in Gush Katif, are now living.”

I could understand her confusion. The areas in this corner of Kibbutz Ein Zurim were each named for the settlement of Gush Katif where the residents came from.

And we were sitting in the home of a family from the former settlement of Nezer Hazani.

I had hesitated before going on this trip to visit the expellees of Gush Katif . Was I just being a voyeur, staring at other people’s suffering? Did they really want people to come and see them in their temporary, cramped, makeshift homes?

But I was assured that they did indeed want visitors. They desperately needed to know that they hadn’t been forgotten.

But the sad truth is that they have been forgotten by many people – certainly by the government. All the promises that were made to them have come to nothing.

Our hosts were a very warm, friendly couple. Their home was small, attractive and obviously well cared for and they had made the most of the little garden they had. But I remembered with tremendous sadness, the magnificent homes in the real Nezer Hazani. Homes that this family and many others, had built with their bare hands, over the last 20 years, before they were thrown out and their homes destroyed.

Rachel, our hostess, was a small, gentle woman, who told us with obvious joy that she had only recently become a young grandmother. One of the other visitors who was with me asked her if she had a photograph of her former home. Rachel shuddered. “Yes, but I can’t look at it. My husband will show you.”
We were silent. No one asked to see the picture.

She also told us that she couldn’t bear the thought of our enemies touching her home. “So when our soldiers came to take us away,” she said, “ I told them that I wanted to burn my home down.”

We all gasped.

“Did they let you?”

“Yes.”

“And did you do it?”

“Yes “

We were silent for a moment. How could any of us possibly comprehend the pain that makes a gentle homemaker destroy her own home. A home that she had built and cared for and in which she had brought up all her children.

Someone asked Rachel and her husband if they would start again if they had the chance. “Certainly,” they replied, “We would go back tomorrow and start to build and farm all over again. That’s all we want.”

A very small percentage of the expellees are now living in permanent accommodation. But most are temporary visitors on other kibbutzim or moshavim or are still in tiny ‘caravans’ which are burning in summer and freezing in winter. Over half of the families have no one employed and virtually no income. But their emunah, their faith, is as strong as it ever was.

We were guided on our visit by the irrepressible Anita Tucker, still known as the “celery lady” from the days of the celery hothouses she and her husband tended in their former home. The last time I had seen Anita was a few months before the expulsion as a group of us sat on the beautiful lawn in the centre of Kfar Darom, sipping coke and eating pizzas – all in total denial that the disengagement and expulsion could take place. Anita was imploring us to act, to do something to ensure that it wouldn’t happen. “This is no time for letter writing to members of knesset, it has to be something more active and immediate. We’re running out of time.”

We had failed her and all the others who had been forced out of their homes, but it hadn’t broken Anita’s spirit. No youngster herself, she was still in the forefront of fighting for the rights of the expellees, guiding visitors, speaking to the press and showing the indomitable spirit which infuses so many of these people who lived by their faith through so much trouble.

We visited the “caravilla” site in Nitzan and had the privilege of meeting an extraordinary young, but mature, girl, Shifra Shomron. Barely out of her teens now, she lived through the horror and pain of losing her home in Neve Dekalim and found the courage and strength to chronicle the events in the months before the intifada until the expulsion, in a fictional book entitled “Grains of Sand”. She told us about the difficult time her parents were going through having not worked for over two years. There is little in the way of job prospects for displaced farmers.

She also told us about the depression amongst the youngsters who were so ideological and so Zionistic before the government and country they revered and adored turned them into homeless wanderers.

Later on we drove past a high rise apartment block which housed another group from Gush Katif. We were told that their sons rarely came home from their schools and yeshivot, even for Shabbatot because after living most of their life in the wonderful open air and space of Gush Katif they can’t stand these cramped, airless apartments.

image
It’s not possible to paint a rosy picture of their life, but after a day which could have been so depressing we all came away in awe of these incredible people. Their homes were destroyed but their emunah, their faith, is still intact. They know that everything God does is for the best, that things will be all right. They only ask us to try and ensure that they are not forgotten. They would be grateful if we would continue to demonstrate, to persuade the government officials to give them some land where they can build their homes and their families once again and sow and reap the earth which Hashem gave us and which they loved to tend and till.

But most of all they ask us to pray for them and their families.


Ann Goldberg is a freelance writer in Israel


Subscribe to Shabbat Shalom!

© Orthodox Union - All Rights Reserved.
The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect those of the Orthodox Union and its agencies

Recent Comments

You are absolutely right, Ann. We need to make sure these tragic heroes are not totally forgotten. But we also need to make sure this doesn't happen to any other Israelis, anywhere they choose to live. If you live in Israel, you must vote for leaders with yirat shamayim, who understand that Jews must never be expelled from their homes in this holy land. Writing letters is important, and so is demonstrating, but voting is the only constructive way to ensure our future (and I humbly suggest that Moshe Feiglin is the right man for the job).

AKL posted on 06/20 at 02:22 AM.

I disagree with the writer's "sad truth" value judgment (a no-no in any journalistic effort!). GKers have not been "forgotten" by the Israeli government. Knesseteers have always treated these loyal, hard-working, tax-paying citizens as the now dispossed, always despised Torah lovers they are: with contempt. The Jew-hateres are consistent, not surprising.

Yocheved Golani
Author, Journalist, Self-Help Coach
Israel

email: (JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
Coping with a Medical Crisis?
Make the Changes You Need in Your Life

Learn about the highly acclaimed book It's My Crisis! And I'll Cry if I Need To: A Life Book that Helps You to Dry Your Tears and to Cope with a Medical Challenge. See http://itsmycrisisandillcryifineedto.blogspot.com/. The Musella Foundation for Brain Tumor Research and Information calls it "Recommended Reading." Buy it at http://www.bn.com

Hear Yocheved speak about her book at http://www.ouradio.org/index.php/ouradio/channel/C299/

Yocheved posted on 06/20 at 04:37 AM.

I would do anything for peace.

But what kind of peace comes when farms are destroyed?
And now, with food prices rising around the world, who dares say the expulsion was justified?
With no guarantees for the protection of the food supply which was shared with the world?
How do broken greenhouses lead to peace for anyone?

I REMEMBER GUSH KATIF

Mike posted on 06/20 at 07:00 PM.

Shalom Shalom Ann Goldberg and The Orthodox Union,

As a non-Jew who saw and also *experienced the devastation of Gush Katif -( I also felt the devastation and still do ....)- It makes me very VERY sad, yet also - at the same time - makes me very very ANGRY- indignant - at the ignoble treatment of the wonderful, blessed and Holy people that are The Gush Katif - The Settlers - by their government, People of Israel and their Jewish brethren in galus.... I just cannot believe this 'evacuation' of the precious settlers even occurred in the first place - especially in Israel ?!

My question for you Jews in The Galus ( The Exile ) is: Why haven't you moved to The Land of Israel - already? Why haven't you opened not only your eyes, but your heart and soul to your precious and G-d fearing *brothers and sisters in The Settlements - that *NEED YOU - NOW* at their side - to strengthen them, help them and build a *real and lasting* home, people and future according to The Eternal Promises made to you by your Eternal , Real and Living G-d, L-rd - The G-d, L-rd of Israel ? Will you Jews in the Galus - decide - even now- Where you are going to build your future? Is it going to be in a strange land that does not share your values, hope and destiny? Or is it going to be with those that are with you, that are your brothers and sisters, in the Land of Milk and Honey - The Land Promised by your Eternal, Living and True G-d, L-rd to your forefathers?

My hope, prayer and wish is that you Jews in the Exile - WAKE UP - before it is too late - and MOVE, MOVE WITHOUT LOOKING BACK , to your Land Promised to YOU by the Almighty of Israel!

Finally, to the Jews in Galus, : Are you not *COMMANDED* to live and settle Eretz Israel?

G-d bless you all the Expellees of Israel, The People of Israel and The Jewish People all around the world ,

Edward Francisco Villa

Edward Francsico Villa posted on 06/20 at 08:25 PM.

Ann, thanks for this article. we have not forgotten the former residents of Gush Katif; but it is embarrassing for the Israeli govt and media to admit that the destruction of these thriving Jewish communities did not bring peace, but simply brought the terrorists' missiles closer to the center of the country. this is why Gush Katif is never mentioned in the media. but since it is not mentioned, many people think that the former residents of Gush Katif have been compensated for the loss of their homes and jobs - and they have not!

I highly recommend Shifra Shomron's book for its description of life in Gush Katif, and the expulsion.

Leah S posted on 06/22 at 04:36 AM.

Shalom!
Yocheved, the government may have always treated us with contempt, but before the expulsion, we had greenhouses, including quotas for water, which were utilized with efficiency that served as an example to the entire world. Also our schools, preschools, community center, etc. were part of the national system and funding was as regular as funding ever is for religious institutions. We also lived in proper houses, not the 90 square-meter boxes in which most of my fellow expellees are living. The government is treating us differently than before the expulsion and that's a fact that's hard to deny. I would say that we're not forgotten, rather intentionally ignored.
I lived in that high rise block described, or one similar to it, until it became clear that my family's time was better spent back on the "wrong side" of the "Green Line" rather than waiting for the government to fulfill its promises. Dozens of other families from various settlements have come to the same conclusion.
It's worth noting that K'far Darom's apartment building in Ashkelon is well within Katuyshia range now.
On a different note, what's wrong with a "sad truth" value judgment in an opinion piece, especially one backed up with ample anecdotes?
To conclude, thank you OU for supporting the expulsion. Your "just follow orders" stance definitely hurt our cause.
Hadassa

Hadassa DeYoung, K'far Darom/Elon Moreh posted on 06/22 at 07:02 AM.

Unfortunately, I have to agree with others who say that our latest "wandering JEWS" were made so not only by a Jewish government that had no idea of the effects its horrible act would cause (and is considering a repeat of that senseless aid to enemies) but also others, esp. the media, who watched but did not protest and now do not assist those they harmed.

m z fruchtman posted on 06/22 at 06:38 PM.

I heard (in the U.S. media) today that the US finally got a truck of humanitarian aide into the Gaza strip for the Palestinians. They said that the Palestinians can't grow food there so they have to rely on imports to eat. I was so furious that I told my dad of all the green houses that had been in Gush Katif and how it was the bread basket of Israel before the expulsion. i told him of all the rockets fired into Israel from Gaza since the expulsion and how some of those rockets were made from the materials of the greenhouses left behind Israeli's from Gush Katif. My prayer is that HaShem will bless you and you will one day be able to return to your land and rebuild. I do what I can to help. I have not forgotten you. I will tell others of your plight.

Ramon

ramon posted on 01/12 at 12:26 AM.


Submit a Comment

Name:

Email: (Rest assured, your email address will not be published.)

Comment:

Please enter the word you see in the image below:




« Back to list of all articles

 
Subscribe to
Shabbat Shalom!

First Name:
Last Name:
Email:


THIS WEEK AND PAST SHABBAT SHALOM ARTICLES
Paying Babysitters on Time - Jewish Law

My 35th Wedding Anniversary

Tel Aviv Centennial Slideshow

The Fifth Glass of Vodka

Pacing

More articles...


 More of what's in
 Shabbat Shalom

 • Times of hadlakat nerot, motzei Shabbat, and other important zmanim
  Rabbi Weinreb's Audio D'var Torah on the Parsha
  Haftarah for the Week
 • OU featured story of the week
 

Parsha summary

  Torah Tidbits Audio
  A choice of divrei Torah you can print out for your Shabbat reading
  Featured Kashrut article of the week
  Shabbat recipe of the week
  Trivia question of the week
  Halachah of the week
  Audio link to a Shabbat song
  and more exciting options!


This Week's Shabbat Shalom  |  www.ou.org