Dulberg Case Information Center

Telephone Conversation with Father Pedamonti
of the Church of Santa Zia

We have posted both the conversation of Father Pedamonti and his denial of both the conversation and its content.  This is not being posted for sensationalism, rather to clearly underscore the reality of Mr. Dulberg's religious status. After representing himself as a religious Jew the transcribed tape calls into question his veracity.  The statement of Father Pedamonti regarding the taped transcription forces us to ask what the truth really is.

Dulberg Case

- Background

- Information Center

Genova, Italy, 21/9/99, Timed for Commencing 12:10

[Translator’s note: translation based on Italian transcript and Hebrew translation of Hever Translation Company. For the sake of simplicity, commas and dashes only have been used to mark off broken phrases and sentences.]


Father Pedamonti [answering telephone, trans.] Santa Zia Parish Church. Good afternoon.
Caller Yes, good afternoon. Can I speak to Mr. - ?
Father Pedamonti Yes, with the priest? Certainly. I am the priest.
Caller Pardon?
Father Pedamonti Who do you want to talk to?
Caller With Father Pedamonti.
Father Pedamonti Yes, that’s me.
Caller Good morning, Father. I am Zaki. Two weeks ago, we were with Marko, the gentleman who wants to do the baptism.
Father Pedamonti Yes.
Caller Do you remember?
Father Pedamonti Yes, yes, I remember.
Caller Yes, I am the friend of his from Mexico. Maybe you speak English?
Father Pedamonti No, I don’t.
Caller I am his friend from Mexico who -
Father Pedamonti Is he in Mexico now?
Caller No. no. He works in import-export in Mexico but from Rome. Since he’s arriving now to work in Genova, he said to you that he wants -
Father Pedamonti Yes, yes. Tell me when he arrives. With pleasure.
Caller Yes, yes. That’s it. So the problem is now that he wants to make the conver-. How do you call it?
Father Pedamonti The Sacrament.
Caller The whole process. But he’s in a little difficulty at the moment. What’s happening? I’m phoning. (Sound of dialing on the phone) Yesterday, for the Jews, he knows, it was, they have the day when they don’t eat. It’s called the Day of Atonement, isn’t it?
Father Pedamonti Yes, of the Sabbath.
Caller Yes, when they don’t eat. You know.
Father Pedamonti Yes. Those are various rules because there is the general rule of the Sabbath, which is the festival of the Jew, but besides, there are Jewish groups.
Caller No, their, their, the Jews have, well, a national day on which they don’t eat anything.
Father Pedamonti Yes, those are the national holidays.
Caller Yes. Yes, he, he, and he was with the family and well what happened, he who was also the father, and the father is Jewish, but the mother not, and he starts, the father starts to say, No, I don’t want you to change and become a Christian, and so on. And he says, just as he was very irritated with his father, he was very emotional -
Father Pedamonti But he is an adult. Therefore -
Caller Yes, yes. Right. No. But he wanted to go on that path which he’d already started out on. Then I saw that that man was under a tiny bit of pressure since he had to be with the family and so on. There was a lot of pressure. And then yesterday evening, he said to me, “How can we do it when there’s the pressure of my father,” and so on.
Father Pedamonti Tell him he must feel independent with regard to making that decision because there is nothing wrong. If the father was opposed to some serious, criminal idea, it would be possible to justify the father. But since these are religious choices, choices concerning one’s duty in life, the father cannot interfere anymore because he is an adult.
Caller Yes, he is 34.
Father Pedamonti Therefore, he should tell him, I am an adult. I make my choice just as you made yours and you carry the consequences. I make my choice and carry the consequences. If need be, he should sever himself intellectually from the father.
Caller Yes.
Father Pedamonti Social, family ties is one thing. Intellectual, spiritual ties is something else. Therefore a man has his own outlook, his own spirituality. He is in charge of his own intellectuality. Beyond this, there must be family ties. He must honor his father, and so on, co-operate. But nothing more than this. That’s enough.
Caller Yes, but you, Father, for example, you don’t have to obtain the permission of Marko’s father, do you?
Father Pedamonti No. no, certainly not.
Caller He can go his own way with you?
Father Pedamonti Above the age of 12.
Caller In your church, yes?
Father Pedamonti Yes. After 12, the lad does not need to get anybody’s
permission anymore
Caller Yes.
Father Pedamonti After 12.
Caller But he can do the whole thing with you in the Santa Zia Church?
Father Pedamonti Yes, yes, yes.
Caller When he is in Genova?
Father Pedamonti When he is here, I told him, when he is here, he’ll come along and we’ll talk and we’ll make progress bit by bit.
Caller I understand. No, because he said that if it has to take a long time, because he needs someone to urge him along, because he still has not made a hundred percent decision. But that’s normal, isn’t it?
Father Pedamonti Very normal.
Caller So I told him, All right, the father of the church said there is someone who does this.
Father Pedamonti There sure is.
Caller It’s not a serious thing, not a -?
Father Pedamonti Absolutely.
Caller Yes, but he’s also a little afraid that it takes time because you said that you did, I don’t know the, you did the baptism of Mr. -
Father Pedamonti Of the Jew? Yes, of, what’s his name?
Caller Of the doctor?
Father Pedamonti Yes, the doctor. The one who has the chemist’s.
Caller Dr. Dulberg.
Father Pedamonti Dulberg, yes.
Caller Dr. Dulberg did the baptism?
Father Pedamonti The baptism? Yes.
Caller He was baptized. You also told him, and that’s what he’s afraid of, that he did the thing 5 years, that it takes 5 years to convert.
Father Pedamonti So you know. Then Dulberg was observant. That’s why, then, little by little, he had to change his habits a little.
Caller What was he? I didn’t understand.
Father Pedamonti Religious, wasn’t he?
Caller Dulberg was a Jew before, wasn’t he?
Father Pedamonti Yes, but he was also observant, wasn’t he?
Caller What’s the meaning of “observant”?
Father Pedamonti From a practical point of view, it means a Jew who observes all the festivals, the Jewish customs, doesn’t it?
Caller Yes, yes.
Father Pedamonti That’s why he had to change, shall we say, his habits. I don’t know if the young man observes the rituals of the festivals, the holidays, customs.
Caller But he is afraid it will go on. Did you conduct for Dr. Dulberg, how do you call it?
Father Pedamonti The conversion? Yes.
Caller So that he has become, now he’s a Christian, is he?
Father Pedamonti Sure. He is a Christian.
Caller Yes, but it takes time. How long did it take with Dr. Dulberg? That's what he’s afraid of, that you told him 5 years. I told him, No.
Father Pedamonti 5 years on a personal level, shall we say, as an inner development.
Caller When does he start, like the baptism and so on?
Father Pedamonti He can do that in a few months.
Caller No. For example, because he wants to speak to someone who was like him before.
Father Pedamonti Yes but, in the end, everyone has his own way. One person might be slower, another might be faster, then there’s the person who does it with more -
Caller But Dulberg, when he did start? 5 years ago?
Father Pedamonti No, 5 years ago, he made a start. Probably. No, I’m not sure it was 5 years ago. He probably started the inner process 5 years ago.
Caller And when did he finish, Dulberg?
Father Pedamonti Dulberg went through baptism a little more than a year ago.
Caller A year that he is completely finished. But the thing took then, almost 4 years, he’s been doing -
Father Pedamonti Not so. No studies, no dialogue with us. He wasn’t in dialogue with us even a year.
Caller But you are the man who counseled him?
Father Pedamonti But Dulberg talked about a gradual drawing near. You know, first a person sees it a little from the outside. Then he gets interested and so on and so forth, no?
Caller Yes.
Father Pedamonti Then he starts to talk a little with the priest with the object of preparation for a deep understanding.
Caller But, for example, if he, if Marco, could speak to someone who’s already gone through the whole process, someone who’s not in the middle of the process. Dulberg is in the middle of the process. And that’s not good. Maybe there’s someone else?
Father Pedamonti No, no. Dulberg is a Christian now, performs all the sacraments, is completely Christian.
Caller What? Dulberg is really a Christian?
Father Pedamonti Yes, yes, yes.
Caller He can really explain everything?
Father Pedamonti He already participates in communion, goes to mass, does everything.
Caller But if he has converted to Christianity, he must also have an authorization which [he received] after he finishes. You can give Mr. Marco an authorization that he did everything correctly?
Father Pedamonti Of course, of course.
Caller Is there an authorization which the Church gives?
Father Pedamonti Of course. But there is no need for a special authorization. It is enough that he has accepted the doctrines of faith, destiny.
Caller If he wants to get married, for example.
Father Pedamonti  After baptism, he can marry when he wants. There’s no problem. No one will ask him any questions, you understand?
Caller I understand. That’s fine.
Father Pedamonti Yes, there’s great freedom, let’s say, when you get to faith. After this, there’s great freedom. We don’t have rigid rules.
Caller
There’s something else. A problem that I am explaining to you. But don’t tell him that I said this when, because in a week’s time, ten days’ time, he is arriving in Genova, for a short time. We are also coming. But I wouldn’t like that you, Father, heard it from me.
Father Pedamonti No, no.
Caller For example, now he has divorced his wife, well he left her, he is separated. He is not divorced, he is separated and there is the two-and-a-half-year old child. So in the future when he converts to Christianity, does the child automatically become a Christian also?
Father Pedamonti No, no, no.
Caller How do you explain that?
Father Pedamonti It’s impossible to force anyone to be a Christian.
Caller What happens if -?
Father Pedamonti The father, the father can choose for his child up to the age of 12. But he is not obligated to choose since he can say, I will allow my child to choose, or say, I made the choice and I want my son to have my faith. So until 12, the father can choose. After the child is 12, he cannot choose for him anymore since we hold that it’s right that the child chooses. You understand?
Caller Then he must wait. No, it’s not just curiosity to know because now, he is a little, a little -
Father Pedamonti It’s the same thing for marriage. If he wants to marry a Christian, to have a Christian marriage service, he can have a Christian marriage service. Just that the Italian Church respects the laws of the country. So if the State has still not declared the divorce, the Church says, First get a divorce. You understand? To respect all the State -
Caller Fine. Listen, Father.
Father Pedamonti The Church doesn’t have to, but -
Caller Eh?! It doesn't have to?
Father Pedamonti No, it doesn’t have to. The Church could hold a Christian marriage without a civil marriage, but to respect -   you see? - in order to, let’s say, live together for mutual respect.
Caller I understand, fine.
Father Pedamonti The State minds certain Church affairs and the Church minds some of the rules of the State.
Caller I understand. Fine. I think that he, bit by bit he’ll take it up. But you say that this way, if he’s close to you, if there’s enough time, well not everyday, then you think he can complete the process. Is there an exam or something afterwards?
Father Pedamonti No. It’s not an exam.
Caller So who says everything’s fine, that O.K? Him?
Father Pedamonti Me, me, me. Him. Together we say, together we give the O.K. No, I understand that, it seems to me, it looks to me, that is, I am sure he has a clear understanding of Christian issues, and he is saying, It suits me fine, and he will get baptized. He is not a child whom the professor has to decide for him. You understand?
Caller Yes, yes, sure. But how long does it take?
Father Pedamonti That depends on how gradually he gets close, understands, appreciates, how much deep thinking he does.
Caller But not 5 years like Mr. Dulberg.
Father Pedamonti No. It took him 5 years in my opinion, not in the sense that he developed an interest, then bit by bit drew near. In his case, I don't know how much he is interested in Christianity and how long he has been getting nearer since he already told me that he is reading the Bible here and there. So it could possibly be two or three years he has had this thought, no?
Caller Yes, yes.
Father Pedamonti I don’t know. He hasn’t yet told me.
Caller Well, whatever, he does everything in your church and under your responsibility, and so on?
Father Pedamonti Yes, yes. He has to make a choice.
Caller Whatever, you are the one who listens afterwards, when you start to talk to him, to his problem and so on. Don’t tell him about the matter of the child which I told you about.
Father Pedamonti No, no, I won’t say anything.
Caller He thinks that -
Father Pedamonti Yes, little by little he will tell us. As soon as he has developed confidence and talks, he will tell us.
Caller Fine. So let’s fix a day before he arrives. I’ll phone to make an appointment.
Father Pedamonti Thanks.
Caller Thanks.
Father Pedamonti You’re welcome.
 

Hear an audio tape of the actual conversation

[public/statements/1999/dulbergfooter.htm]

More from OU.ORG

More from OU.ORG