Aliyah: Have We Stopped Dreaming?

by | in Aliyah

imageThis year we celebrate the sixtieth anniversary of the birth of the modern State of Israel. The reappearance of an independent Jewish nation after a 2,000-year-long galut (exile)—one that witnessed the ingathering of more than one-third of the Jewish people, the revival of an ancient language and the ever-growing fulfillment of “Ki miTzion tetzei Torah”—is nothing short of miraculous. It is therefore distressing that American Orthodoxy seems to not be wholeheartedly embracing the dream to return home.

In our daily lives, we often say that we are dreaming of our return to Eretz Yisrael (“Shir hama’alot, beshuv Hashem et shivat Tzion hayinu kecholmim,” from the introductory psalm to Birkat Hamazon said on Shabbat and yom tov), but do we really mean it? Are we are doing enough to place aliyah on the top of the American Orthodox agenda?

We, of course, look with pride and admiration at the many thousands of Americans who have made aliyah over the years, but if we are true to ourselves we must acknowledge that we have failed to elevate aliyah to the level of a yearning; we have failed to instill in our people a personal striving to fulfill that which many of our grandparents, great-grandparents and the generations before them dreamed about. For the first time in two millennia, we have the unprecedented opportunity to fulfill this dream.

Interestingly, many American Jews long to be buried in Israel and purchase expensive plots in prime locations in the Holy Land. But what about longing to live in Israel? One advertisement for internment in Israel actually states, “Today, the opportunity for which previous generations prayed and yearned is now available to all, and is easily attainable.” How ironic! This should be the headline for an article about aliyah. The words we recite in the berachah just before Keriyat Shema come to mind—we pray to be taken“komemiut leArtzeinu,” upright to our Land. We beseech God to let us go to Eretz Yisrael in a vertical, not a horizontal, position!

It is repeatedly stressed in our Torah and liturgy that the destiny of the Jewish people is to build a model Jewish society, based on Torah values, in the Land of Israel. Shir Hama’alot, for example, refers to the “dream” of returning to Israel: “Shuvah Hashem et shviteinu ka’afikim baNegev, return our captivity like flash floods in the Negev.” In fact, Birkat Hamazon itself is based on our connection to the Land. In parashat Ekev, it states, “Veachaltah vesavata uverachta et Hashem Elokecha . . . al haAretz asher natan lach, You shall eat and be satisfied and bless the Lord, your God, on the good Land that He has given you.” It is clear that Birkat Hamazon is essentially a blessing on the Land of Israel.

In our daily lives, we often say that we are dreaming of our return to Eretz Yisrael, but do we really mean it?

Parashat Ekev also includes the second paragraph of the Shema, beginning with the words “Vehaya im shemoa.” This paragraph reminds us that if we keep God’s commandments we will be rewarded with prosperity in the Land. But if we do not, God forbid, we will be banished from ha’Aretz hatovah, the good Land. The concept contained in these verses, that our prosperity in the Land of Israel is linked to our behavior, is fundamental. The passage was therefore incorporated into the Shema, is recited twice daily and is written in every mezuzah and pair of tefillin. Similarly, in parashat Devarim, the verse states, “All of the commandments which I command you this day you shall observe to do in order that you should live and multiply and come and possess the Land that the Lord promised to your forefathers.” Again and again, the Torah speaks of consequences in terms of our physical connection with the Land of Israel. What could be clearer?

Unfortunately, we are masters at rationalizing why the mitzvah to live in Israel is different from any other mitzvah and therefore not incumbent upon us. There are good reasons—emotional, practical and financial—why one may be unable to move to Israel. Our families are in the States. There are elderly parents whose needs must be considered. Our businesses are here. We have just built a multi-million dollar shul, school or JCC. The Israeli government is corrupt.

Mitzvot are not always easy but they are mitzvot nonetheless, and we do everything we can to live in accordance with their dictates. We are scrupulous in our adherence to the laws of kashrut—the high cost does not deter us from building kitchens with two sinks and two dishwashers and buying two sets of dishes. We purchase a large sukkah and the finest etrog. But when it comes to aliyah, we find all sorts of ways to conclude that it is simply not a halachic imperative. This unfortunate mindset leads us to ask ourselves the wrong question. Instead of asking, “Is it practical for me to be thinking of aliyah?” the question we should be asking is, “What must I be doing to work towards fulfilling this mitzvah, to see the dream come to fruition?” Many Jews simply fail to live their lives with the ambition of living in Israel—which is God’s goal for Am Yisrael and should be the ultimate driving force of our people. The longing just isn’t there.

The challenge for this generation is to revitalize the message of yearning to live in Israel in meaningful and powerful ways. Too many Jews don’t realize that America is just another temporary stop for the Jewish people on the way home.

Mr. Abelow lives in Efrat with his family. He made aliyah from Baltimore in 1980.

This article was featured in Jewish Action Winter 2008.

Leave a Comment