Purim and Yom kePurim

| 0 Comments

Email

“Rava said: One is required to become intoxicated on Purim until the point that he cannot differentiate between ‘Cursed be Haman’ and ‘Blessed be Mordechai.’” (Gemara Megillah 7b) Why is inebriation halachically mandated? Do other forms of celebration not suffice to express our joy at the salvation precipitated by the nes of Purim?

The story of Purim is unique in that each segment of the tale appears to be a coincidence which is unrelated to the balance of the narrative. God’s name does not appear in the text, and the miraculous nature of Purim is only detected by piecing together all of the events and realizing that the each occurrence was a purposeful piece in God’s puzzle for bringing Bnei Yisroel near to Him and saving them. The miracle of Purim occurred via Hester Panim, which means that Hashem interacted with the world in a hidden, imperceptible manner. (The custom to adorn masks and costumes (see Remo in Shulchan Aruch O.Ch. 696:8) bears recognition of this state of affairs, for we celebrate God’s salvation of Hester Panim, in which His hand is outstretched but hidden from view.)

In the same vein may we understand the halachah of drinking on Purim. The Gemara in Sanhedrin explains that one’s inner essence is externalized as a result of intoxication. Inebriation reminds us that one can appear to be a certain way on the outside, whereas that same person is totally different internally, when his true essence is perceived behind his “mask”. Thus, by merrying through the medium of drink, we, too, celebrate and recognize once more God’s nes via Hester Panim.

The Arizal stated that Yom Kippur is related to Purim ["Yom kePurim" - "A day like Purim"]. On Yom Kippur, we return to Hashem and are represented by the Kohen Gadol, who enters the Kodesh Ha-Kodoshim – the most inner sanctum of holiness – which is removed and off-limits from day-to-day life. We shed our material shell and identify ourselves as malachim – angels – relating to God via our inner essence, our neshamah. This is the parallel of Yom Kippur and Purim, for the teshuvah of Purim and Yom Kippur necessitate our realization that our inner, spiritual, Godly selves be recognized and flourish beyond our exterior facade so as to draw near to God.

On an halachic note: The Gemara (Megillah 7b), the Rambam (Hilchos Megillah 2:15 ) and the Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 695:2) rule that drinking on Purim is a halachah of the seudas Purim. It is thus clear that those who drink large quantities at night after the Megillah is read as well as on Purim day before the seudah and following it are acting quite inappropriately, as their drunkenness is not in the context of mitzvah performance and is not condoned.

RELATED STORIES FROM PURIM
COMMENTS
  • Yoshiyahu

    The title of this article is misleading.

  • Larry Engelhart

    Rabbi Goldberg states: “The destruction we mourn until this date is the result of Hashem withdrawing His intense countenance from our midst. He did so because we misbehaved in our attitude towards one another. But, he did so also because we failed to appreciate the divine gifts He bestowed upon us and we took for granted what it means to be protected by His presence.”

    Perhaps that’s the point that his antagonist, the israeli Rabbi, was trying to make … that we aren’t recognizing what we DO have while “obsessively” mourning for what we don’t have.

    I don’t believe Rabbi Goldberg addresses that concern.

    The myriad serious situations he describes are existentially dangerous and ominous, but he doesn’t explain how fasting will ameliorate any of those.

  • Nahum Schnitzer

    Was this “israeli rabbi” anonymous? Did he provide any halachic basis for his assertion? Did he quote any sources? Or was it a fluffy opinion piece?

  • Abe

    Other than not being subservient to the nations, there is no difference between our times and the messianic times, states the Gemara (in one observation) and the Rambam. Are we fooling ourselves into thinking the age of geulah will be some sort of utopia?

    • Yoshiyahu

      Right. And when the Jews originally lived in Israel they were constantly plagued by foreign invaders, probably more so than today, and they didn’t have days just to mourn over it.

  • ben

    I;m not sure what the whole question is about. It’s obvious. We don’t have the beis hamikdash back. more than half of all the mitzvos are not applicable today. We lack the complete closeness to Hashem that we had with nevuah and the beis hamikdash. So how could any think that we don’t need to fast? And how can the answer be “because we still are under attack?” Even if we could walk around freely, without being scared, and without political pressure of any sort, we’re still far from being where we should be. On the contrary, a person who thinks that the main problem we have is the political issues, and we “also” are lacking the beis hamikdash and everything that goes with it – that person has his priorities mixed up.

  • SavtaT

    Sometimes it seems that we lose merit when we don’t say “Hallel” for what we have been given. Netanyahu sends out a magnificent photo of Yerushalayim on Facebook each Friday. That act reflects that we have a sovereign Jewish government and a flourishing Yerushalayim being built daily. Somewhere these Brachos need to be reflected. When the Jews left Mitzrayim, they said Shira. What about us?

  • Israel

    The “sinat chinam” is still with us. In the government, amongst the rabbis and among the people. We need the 9th of Av to remind us to change our behaviour. Im ba’arazim nafla shalhevet ma yagidu eizovei hakir.

  • True Believer

    While I agree we should still be fasting (since we don’t have the Bet HaMikdash, etc), this article reminds me of the statements of the Meraglim in Parshat Shlach. It’s time the Rabbis of America and other countries woke up – got on a plane and made Aliya, and encouraged their Kehilot to join them. Not scare them away, by telling them – “the Land is good, but…..”