"Maamad Har Sinai" - The Stand at Mt. Sinai
When the Jewish People stood at the foot of Mt. Sinai, and accepted the Torah, was
probably the most momentous event in the history of the human race. At that time, what
occurred taught the following profound lessons:
- There is a G-d in the World
- The World was created by G-d
- G-d established rules for the behavior of Man and, at the root of them, are these ten:
The text (in bold); following the text are some comments -
1. "I am Hashem, your G-d, Who has taken you out of
the land of Egypt, from the house of slavery. You shall not recognize the gods of others
in My presence." (Shemot 20,2)
Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman (RAMBAN) asks,
"Why did Hashem introduce Himself to the Jewish People as the One Who had taken them
out of slavery in Egypt. Great as that was, wasn't He also the One Who had done something
even greater; namely, created the universe? And RAMBAN answers that while it's true that
Hashem had created the universe, there had been no human witnesses present at that event!
Whereas, there had been millions of witnesses to the Exodus of the Jews from Egypt. And
these witnesses were expected to pass that testimony onward from generation to generation,
till our day.
The Ten Commandments are written as commands to individuals, so that each individual
should know and realize that the Commandments are meant for him, and he cannot say,
"let them be fulfilled by others."
Since Hashem had appeared to the Jewish People at the Sea as a warrior, and at Sinai as
a Teacher of Torah, and He would appear to them in the time of Shlomo as a young man, and
in the time of Daniel as an old man full of mercy - the Holy One Blessed be He said to
them, "Although you see different manifestations, you should realize that I Was the
One at the Sea, I Am the One here at Sinai, I Am the One at all times - I Am the L-rd your
G-d."
2. "You shall not make a carved image nor any
likeness of that which is in the heavens above or on the earth below or in the water
beneath the earth. You shall not prostrate yourself before them nor worship them, for I am
Hashem your G-d - a jealous G-d, Who visits the sin of fathers on children to the third
and fourth generations, for My enemies; but Who shows kindness for thousands [of
generations] to those who love Me and observe My commandments." (Shemot 20:4-6)
- This is one of the three cardinal sins in
Judaism, such that if Person A approaches Person B and says to him, "I will kill you
if you do not worship idol so-and-so," Person B must allow himself to be killed
rather than worship the idol.
- The ratio of the "mercy" of G-d to His "judgment" is at least 500 to
1. For we see that he visits the sins of the fathers onto the sons only to a maximum of
four generations, whereas he remembers the good deeds of the fathers for thousands
(minimum of thousands is two thousand). Perhaps the way this trans-generational transfer
of guilt and merit works is like this: A parent's sinful behavior can affect a child, but
only up to a maximum of four generations. Whereas, an ancestor's good behavior will
"sink into the bones" of the descendants, and remain as a positive influence for
at least two thousand generations.
3. "You shall not take the name of Hashem, your G-d,
in vain, for Hashem will not absolve anyone who takes His Name in vain." (Shemot
20:7)
- Do not be quick to take oaths which involve mention of Hashem's Name. And do not let
oaths become commonplace in your mouth, because someone who behaves in this manner, will
swear even when he or she has no desire to do so. Therefore, it is forbidden to swear even
on something true (this is why many people, when asked to swear, in certain administrative
and judicial contexts, will request the right to "affirm," rather than swear).
And anyone who desecrates G-d's Name by swearing falsely or even truthfully (in a matter
not justifying use of G-d's Name) his end will be that Hashem, acting in accordance with
the principle of "midah k'neged midah," or "measure for measure," will
cause information that this person would have preferred to remain private, to enter the
public arena, and be "bandied about" like something trivial.
4. "Remember the Day of Shabbat to sanctify it. Six days
shall you work and accomplish all your work; but the seventh day is Shabbat to Hashem,
your G-d; you shall not do any work - you, your son, your daughter, your slave, your
maidservant, your animal, and your convert within your gates - for in six days Hashem made
the heavens and the earth, the sea and all that is in them, and He rested on the seventh
day. Therefore, Hashem blessed the Day of Shabbat and sanctified it." (Shemot
20:8-11)
- According to Jewish Tradition, Hashem uttered the Command of "Remember the
Shabbat" and the Command of "Guard the Shabbat" (which is the
form of the Shabbat command as it appears when Moshe reviews the history of the People of
Israel in the Book of Devarim, and refers to the events described here the first time
around, in the Book of Shemot) simultaneously, which is impossible for a human
being to do, and yet the Jewish People were enabled to understand the Command. This is to
teach that to "Remember" Shabbat, which relates to the positive aspects of Shabbat and to "Guard
Shabbat", which relates to the prohibition side of Shabbat, are both essential
aspects of the Holy Day.
- The way to fulfill the Commandment of "Remember the Shabbat" is to recite the
Kiddush at the Shabbat table. This is the minimum requirement; for other aspects of this
command, see Remember the Shabbat.
- Shammai the Elder used to say, "Remember the Shabbat" before it comes, and
"Guard it" once it has come. It was said about Shammai the Elder that the
remembrance of Shabbat "never left his mouth." He would buy a nice item, and say
"this is for Shabbat." And they said further about Shammai the Elder that he
would eat all week "for the honor of Shabbat;" he would buy a nice cow, and he
would say, "This is for the honor of Shabbat." Then if he found a nicer one, he
would eat from the first and set the second aside for the Shabbat. But Hillel the Elder
had a different characteristic; he would trust Hashem to provide the best for each day on
that day, and would say, "Blessed is Hashem each day."
- Turnus-Rufus, the Roman official, asked Rabbi Akiva concerning the Shabbat, "How is
one day different from any other day?" Rabbi Akiva responded, "How is Tunnus-Rufus
different from other men? Turnus-Rufus asked Rabbi Akiva to clarify his meaning. Rabbi
Akiva said, "You asked me, 'How is the Shabbat different from other times?' and I
asked you, 'How are you different from other men?' " Turnus-Rufus angrily responded,
"The Emperor wishes to honor me!" To which Rabbi Akiva answered, "The King
of Kings wants the Jewish People to show honor to the Shabbat."
5. "Honor your father and your mother, so that your days
will be lengthened upon the land that Hashem, your G-d, gives you." (Shemot 20:12)
"Honor your father and your mother;"
and it is also written "a person should revere his mother and father." What is
reverence and what is honor? "Reverence" includes such behaviors to be avoided
as not to stand in their place or sit in their place, not to contradict them and not even
to lend your support to what they have to say. "Honor" includes
such actions as to provide food and drink, indirectly and even directly, to provide
clothing and even, if necessary, to dress them, to cover them, to bring them in and take
them out, etc., etc., in accordance with their needs.
"They asked Rav Ulla, 'To what extent is a child obligated to honor his or her
parents?' He answered, 'go and see how a certain non-Jewish resident of Ashkelon behaved,
and his name was Dama, son of Nesina. Once the Rabbis wished to purchase an object from
them for ritual purposes, for the sum of six hundred thousand "shekalim," let's
say, dollars, but the key to the safe was under the head of his sleeping father, and Dama
would not disturb his father!' "
"They asked Rabbi Eliezer, 'To what extent is a child obligated to honor his or her
parents?' He said to them, 'to the extent that even if the parent would throw the child's
wallet into the ocean for no reason, the child should not embarrass the parent!' "
6. "You shall not murder!" (Shemot
20:13)
This is one of the three cardinal sins in Judaism, for which an individual is obligated
to give up his life. This means that if Person A approaches Person B and says to him,
"I will kill you if you do not kill person C," Person B should allow himself
to be killed, rather than murder Person C.
7. "You shall not commit
adultery!" (Shemot 20:13)
- This is the third of the three cardinal sins in Judaism, such that if Person A
approaches Person B and says to him, "I will kill you if you do not commit adultery
with the wife of Person C," Person B must allow himself to be killed rather than
commit adultery.
8. "You shall not steal!" (Shemot 20:13)
- This form of stealing is the stealing of souls; that is, kidnapping, for which the
penalty is "bet-din," Jewish Court-administered death. Stealing of money, for
which the penalty is financial, is referenced elsewhere in the Torah.
9. "You shall not bear false witness against your
fellow!" (Shemot 20:13)
- Jewish Tradition holds that one is not even allowed to speak favorably about other
individuals, because that too can relatively easily lead one to speak ill of that person.
For example, if one says, "What a nice house (car, job, wife, etc.) so-and-so
has," it is easy to see how that can lead to feelings of jealousy and "lashon
hara," unfavorable speech, or worse.
10. "You shall not covet your fellow's house. You
shall not covet your fellow's wife, his manservant, his maidservant, his ox, his donkey,
nor anything that belongs to your fellow!" (Shemot 20:14)
In the Devarim version of the Utterances, or Commandments, a different verb is used.
Here the prohibition is "Lo Tachmod!," "Do not actively desire!"
There, in Devarim, the verb is "Lo Titaveh!," "Do not desire in your
heart!" For there is a causal chain - if one allows himself to desire someone else's
property, etc., that will lead to more active desire, which will lead to stealing, etc.,
etc.
How is it possible to command someone concerning his or her emotions? First of all, it
is possible, as we see from other commands, positive (such as "You shall love your
neighbor as yourself!") and negative ("You shall not hate your neighbor in your
heart!"). Alternatively, the meaning here is that one should distance the thought of
possessing some "thing" "belonging" to someone else so far outside the
realm of possibility, that the thought actually recedes from one's imagination.
A Poetic Description of the Giving of the
Torah
